Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Common puffball or Dog stinkhorn

Common puffball and Dog stinkhorn are similar species: Common puffball is edible, while Dog stinkhorn is inedible. The main visible difference: flesh colour change: Common puffball — yellowing, Dog stinkhorn — no change. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: smell, size.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Common puffballDog stinkhorn
Comparison of characteristics: Common puffball and Dog stinkhorn
Edibility classCommon puffball: EdibleDog stinkhorn: Inedible
UseCommon puffball: Cook fresh, Drying, PicklingDog stinkhorn: Not eaten
SizeCommon puffball: Small (up to 5 cm)Dog stinkhorn: Medium (5–15 cm)
ColourCommon puffball: White, Cream, BrownDog stinkhorn: Orange, White, Pale yellow
TasteCommon puffball: MildDog stinkhorn: —
SmellCommon puffball: PleasantDog stinkhorn: Unpleasant
Flesh colour changeCommon puffball: YellowingDog stinkhorn: No change
SubstrateCommon puffball: Soil, Forest litterDog stinkhorn: Soil, Leaf litter, Dead wood
Growth habitCommon puffball: In groups, In clusters from one baseDog stinkhorn: In groups

Same in both: season, nutrition type.

When and where they meet

Together: August–October

Their seasons overlap: August–October. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: deciduous forest, mixed forest, conifer forest.

Common puffball

Fruiting season

August – December

Dog stinkhorn

Fruiting season

June – October

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Common puffball

The fruiting body is shaped like an upside-down pear or a club, 2-6 cm tall and 1.5-4 cm wide at the top. The upper (fertile) part is a rounded head; the lower (sterile) part is a narrower “stalk” 1-3 cm long. Young ones are white or cream, turning yellowish grey to brown with age. The telltale feature is the covering of coarse spiny warts (1-2 mm), which gradually fall off and leave a net-like pattern.

Dog stinkhorn

There's no separate cap. The top of the stem is pointed, orange-red and finely bumpy, and only the tip is covered in sticky, shiny dark olive slime that carries the spores. Once flies have eaten it, the tip shows bright orange.

Hymenophore

Common puffball

Inside is the gleba, the spore-producing tissue. When young it's white, dense and uniform; with age it turns yellow, then green, and finally becomes a dark olive-grey powdery spore mass. A mature puffball opens a hole at the top, and the spores puff out when a raindrop hits it (hence the Ukrainian name, “rain mushroom”). Spore print dark olive-brown.

Dog stinkhorn

There are no gills or pores: the spores are carried in the olive slime at the tip. There's no ordinary spore print; the spores are pale yellow in mass.

Stem

Common puffball

There's no separate stem: the fruiting body is all one piece. The lower, sterile part forms a “stalk-base” 1-3 cm tall, somewhat narrower than the top, white and scaly, which passes into whitish rhizomorphs (mycelial cords) in the soil.

Dog stinkhorn

The stem is 6 to 15 cm tall and about 1 cm thick, cylindrical, hollow, spongy and pitted like expanded polystyrene, white, pale yellow or pale orange, often curved and fragile.

At the base the remains of the egg form a white sac (volva) with white mycelial cords. The young fungus looks like a white or yellowish egg 2 to 3 cm across, half buried in leaf litter.

Flesh

Common puffball

The flesh of young ones is pure white, uniform and dense, with a delicate, pleasant flavour. With age it turns yellow, then green, and becomes a spore mass. The test is to cut it open: uniform white means it's good to eat; any other colour, throw it out.

Dog stinkhorn

The stem walls are spongy like polystyrene, whitish to pale orange. Inside the egg, a layer of clear jelly lies under the skin.

Smell

Common puffball

A faint, pleasant mushroomy smell with no sharp notes. The taste is mild and neutral; it takes on the flavours of the dish.

Dog stinkhorn

The smell is unpleasant and carrion-like, but much weaker than the common stinkhorn's.

Related comparisons

Sources · 18

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]Species Fungorum
  • [8]Wikipedia (English)
  • [9]Википедия (русская)
  • [10]Червона книга України: Мутин собачий Mutinus caninus
  • [11]First Nature: Mutinus caninus, Dog Stinkhorn
  • [12]First Nature: Phallus impudicus, Stinkhorn
  • [13]Wild Food UK: Dog Stinkhorn
  • [14]Kuo M., MushroomExpert: Stinkhorns
  • [15]Kuo M., MushroomExpert: Mutinus ravenelii
  • [16]Wikipedia (de): Gemeine Hundsrute
  • [17]Wikigrib: Мутинус собачий
  • [18]GBIF: знахідки Mutinus caninus в Україні