Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Humpback brittlegill or Pirate brittlegill

Humpback brittlegill and Pirate brittlegill are similar species that can be mixed up while foraging. The main visible difference: flesh colour change: Humpback brittlegill — yellowing, Pirate brittlegill — no change. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: smell, cap shape, size.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Humpback brittlegillPirate brittlegill
Comparison of characteristics: Humpback brittlegill and Pirate brittlegill
UseHumpback brittlegill: Cook fresh, PicklingPirate brittlegill: —
SizeHumpback brittlegill: Small (up to 5 cm)Pirate brittlegill: Medium (5–15 cm)
Cap colourHumpback brittlegill: Violet, BrownPirate brittlegill: Violet, Red, Pink
Cap shapeHumpback brittlegill: UmbonatePirate brittlegill: Convex, Flat, Depressed
Cap surfaceHumpback brittlegill: SlimyPirate brittlegill: Slimy, Velvety
TasteHumpback brittlegill: BitterPirate brittlegill: Mild
SmellHumpback brittlegill: PleasantPirate brittlegill: Chemical
Flesh colour changeHumpback brittlegill: YellowingPirate brittlegill: No change
StemHumpback brittlegill: CentralPirate brittlegill: Central, Solid, Hollow
SubstrateHumpback brittlegill: SoilPirate brittlegill: Soil, Conifer needle litter
Partner treesHumpback brittlegill: PinePirate brittlegill: Pine, Spruce, Fir
Growth habitHumpback brittlegill: In groupsPirate brittlegill: Solitary, In groups

Same in both: edibility class, season, hymenophore, nutrition type.

When and where they meet

Together: August–October

Their seasons overlap: August–October. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: conifer forest.

Humpback brittlegill

Fruiting season

August – November

Pirate brittlegill

Fruiting season

July – October

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Humpback brittlegill

The cap is 3-8 cm across and, when young, conical-convex with a sharp papillate bump in the centre, a diagnostic feature. With age it becomes flat-convex, but the bump stays. The skin is smooth, slimy and sticky in wet weather, dry and matte in dry weather, and peels 1/3 of the way to the centre. It's dark violet, violet-azure or purple-chestnut, richer in the centre, paler toward the edge, fading to greyish. Mature caps have fine radial grooves at the edge.

Pirate brittlegill

The cap is 3–8 cm across, occasionally up to 10 cm. It starts convex, soon flattens and finally becomes depressed in the centre.

The colour is violet, dark purple, lilac or wine-red, sometimes greyish pink. The centre is darker at first but soon fades to dirty pink, olive or yellowish, often with bright yellow spots. A form with an entirely yellow cap has also been described.

In wet weather the skin is slightly greasy, but it dries quickly from the margin and then looks matt and velvety, as if dusted. The skin peels easily, about a third of the way to the centre.

Hymenophore

Humpback brittlegill

The gills are attached or free, moderately crowded, fleshy and brittle. They're whitish at first, becoming cream-ochre-yellowish with age as the spores mature. The spore print is yellow-ochre, a diagnostic feature.

Pirate brittlegill

The gills are cream or pale yellow at first and a rich ochre-yellow when mature. They are fairly crowded, becoming more distant with age, attached to the stem and joined by cross veins near the base.

The spore print is pale yellow to ochre. A white print points to a different russula, such as the charcoal burner or the purple brittlegill.

Stem

Humpback brittlegill

The stem is 4-8 cm tall and 1-2 cm thick, firm and cylindrical, hollow in older mushrooms. It's whitish, often with a faint violet-pink tint low down, and its surface is smooth with fine lengthwise wrinkles. No ring.

Pirate brittlegill

The stem is 3–8 cm tall and 1–2 cm thick, cylindrical or slightly club-shaped. It is pure white, rarely pinkish, and yellowish in wet weather.

Young stems are firm; old ones become chambered or hollow, especially at the base. There is no ring and no volva.

Flesh

Humpback brittlegill

The flesh is firm, brittle and white, and slowly turns yellow where cut. The smell is faint and pleasant, with a hint of coconut and fruit in young mushrooms; the taste is mild and slightly bitter, especially in the stem, but not burning-acrid, which sets it apart from its poisonous relatives.

Pirate brittlegill

The flesh is white, yellowing with age and lilac just under the cap skin. It is brittle, as in most russulas, and does not change colour when broken. Field guides describe the taste as mild and sweetish.

Smell

Humpback brittlegill

A faint, pleasant fruity-coconut smell in young mushrooms, turning neutral with age.

Pirate brittlegill

The key feature of the species: the base of the stem smells of iodoform, an old-fashioned antiseptic. The smell stays at the bottom of the stem and is not always obvious, so it is worth checking several specimens. The cap and gills have no particular smell.

Related comparisons

Sources · 14

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]First Nature, Pat O'Reilly
  • [8]Wikipedia (English)
  • [9]Википедия (русская)
  • [10]GBIF: перелік видів Червоної книги України (наказ № 111, 2021)
  • [11]Червона книга України: Сироїжка синювата (Russula turci)
  • [12]Wikipedia (de): Jodoform-Täubling
  • [13]First Nature: Russula sardonia, Primrose Brittlegill
  • [14]First Nature: Russula queletii, Fruity Brittlegill