Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Salty mushroom or Field mushroom

Salty mushroom and Field mushroom are similar species that can be mixed up while foraging. The main visible difference: smell: Salty mushroom — unpleasant, fishy, Field mushroom — pleasant, mushroomy, anise. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: size.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Salty mushroomField mushroom
Comparison of characteristics: Salty mushroom and Field mushroom
UseSalty mushroom: Cook freshField mushroom: Culinary, Cook fresh, Freezing
SizeSalty mushroom: Large (over 15 cm)Field mushroom: Medium (5–15 cm)
Cap colourSalty mushroom: White, Cream, BrownField mushroom: White, Cream
Cap surfaceSalty mushroom: Cracked, Scaly, Dry, SmoothField mushroom: Dry, Smooth
SmellSalty mushroom: Unpleasant, FishyField mushroom: Pleasant, mushroomy, Anise
Growth habitSalty mushroom: Solitary, In groups, In ringsField mushroom: In groups, In rings

Same in both: edibility class, season, cap shape, taste, flesh colour change, hymenophore, stem, ring (veil), substrate, nutrition type.

When and where they meet

Together: July–November

Their seasons overlap: July–November. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: meadow, field.

Salty mushroom

Fruiting season

May – November

Field mushroom

Fruiting season

July – November

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Salty mushroom

The cap is 6–15 cm across and very fleshy. Young caps are hemispherical, then convex and flattened, and the margin stays inrolled for a long time.

The skin is white, cream or greyish, dry and smooth at first, often with brownish spots. With age it cracks into coarse brownish scales and furrows, so the cap looks like cracked earth. Mushrooms often come up already dirty, with sand or soil on the cap.

Field mushroom

Cap 5–15 cm across, spherical when young, then flat or slightly umbonate. White or slightly creamy, cracking in dry weather; fibrous scales may appear as it matures. The margin is inrolled at first, then straight.

Hymenophore

Salty mushroom

The gills are free, meaning they don't reach the stem, and very crowded. In young mushrooms they are greyish pink or pink, then reddish brown, and chocolate in mature ones. They are never white in a mature Agaricus.

The spore print is chocolate brown. A white print means it isn't an Agaricus.

Field mushroom

Gills free (not reaching the stem) and crowded: soft pink at first, then bright pink, and chocolate-brown or blackish in mature mushrooms. Pink gills are a key safety feature that sets the field mushroom apart from poisonous species with white gills.

Stem

Salty mushroom

The stem is 4–10 cm tall and 2–4 cm thick, white, firm and solid. It's usually shorter than the cap is wide, which makes the mushroom look squat.

There is a single narrow, sleeve-like ring with an upturned edge; in young mushrooms it is thick and rubbery. There is no sac (volva) at the base. The base often sits deep in the soil, so dig the mushroom up whole to check it.

Field mushroom

Stem 4–8 cm tall, 1–2 cm thick, cylindrical, solid and straight. White. A firm membranous ring sits in the middle of the stem, a characteristic feature. No volva.

Flesh

Salty mushroom

The flesh is thick, firm and white. When cut or pressed it reddens, turning orange-red or reddish brown, sometimes vividly, sometimes slowly and only faintly. It never turns yellow. The taste is mild, slightly salty according to some.

Field mushroom

Flesh firm and white; it turns slightly pink when cut or stays unchanged. It doesn’t turn yellow (yellowing is a sign of poisonous species). The taste is pleasant and richly mushroomy.

Smell

Salty mushroom

Descriptions of the smell vary: briny, fishy, unpleasant, and some authors also notice a hint of aniseed. That is where its German and French names meaning smelly mushroom come from. Treat the smell as a hint only: the reddening flesh, the pink to chocolate gills and the single ring decide. A strong smell of ink or carbolic points to the poisonous yellow stainer.

Field mushroom

A pronounced smell of anise and almond with mushroomy notes, making it one of the most aromatic wild mushrooms. Cooking intensifies the aroma, and it can dominate the dish.

Related comparisons

Sources · 14

  • [1]Index Fungorum
  • [2]GBIF
  • [3]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [4]Wikipedia (English)
  • [5]Википедия (русская)
  • [6]Prylutskyi O. et al. Reference-based checklist of gilled Agaricales from Ukraine. Biodiversity Data Journal, 2023, 11: e99101, Prylutskyi O. et al. (2023)
  • [7]First Nature: Agaricus bernardii, Salty Mushroom
  • [8]Discover the Wild: Salty Mushroom
  • [9]Totally Wild UK: The Salty Agaric
  • [10]First Nature: Agaricus xanthodermus, Yellow Stainer
  • [11]First Nature: Agaricus bitorquis, Pavement Mushroom
  • [12]Wikipedia (en): Amanita virosa
  • [13]GBIF: Agaricus bernardii, знахідки в Україні
  • [14]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)