Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Genus

Earthstars (Geastrum)

Mushrooms in the taxonomic group “Geastrum”. 2 species in the database.

Earthstars (Geastrum) are fungi whose outer skin splits into rays that fold back, leaving a round spore sac sitting in the middle of a star. The name is Greek for "earth star". There are at least fifty species worldwide and a few dozen in Europe. Earthstars are inedible and some European species are rare, so photograph any you find and leave them be. Two species are in this group on our site: the collared earthstar and the arched earthstar.

How an earthstar opens

A young earthstar looks like a puffball, often with a pointed beak on top. Its outer skin has three layers. As it matures, the inner layer absorbs water and swells while the tough fibrous layer resists, so the skin splits from the tip downwards into rays that curl outwards. Spores puff out through the hole at the top of the sac whenever a raindrop, a twig or a passing animal strikes it.

You will often read that earthstars close in dry weather and reopen after rain. For both our species that is untrue: once open, the rays stay put, wet or dry. Only some other Geastrum species behave like that, along with the look-alike barometer earthstar (Astraeus hygrometricus), which curls its rays over the sac when dry and flattens them when wet. It is not a close relative: Astraeus belongs with the boletes, Geastrum with the stinkhorns, and the star shape evolved separately. Astraeus also has much larger spores and no defined rim around its opening.

How to tell our earthstars apart

The collared earthstar (Geastrum triplex) is the largest earthstar. Unopened it measures 1–5 cm, with an obvious beak; opened it reaches 5–10 cm, occasionally 11.5. Its 4–8 rays often crack so that the sac sits in a saucer or collar, though not always. The opening is fibrous, often in a paler zone. It grows in broadleaf litter, often under beech, and also under firs and spruces. Geastrum saccatum and Geastrum fimbriatum look similar, and a certain identification sometimes needs a microscope.

The arched earthstar (Geastrum fornicatum) stands on the tips of 4–5 arched rays like an acrobat, holding its spore sac, 1.5–2.5 cm across, above the ground. The whole fungus is up to 6 cm wide and 8 cm tall; unopened, it is dark brown, 1–4 cm. It grows under shrubs and trees in broadleaf woodland, and in Britain mostly under old yews. In southern Ukraine it has been found in woods, plantations, shelterbelts and parks.

Are earthstars edible?

No, earthstars are inedible. They are not considered poisonous, but mature ones are fibrous and tough, and German expert lists include them neither as edible nor as poisonous. The American author David Arora noted that young, unopened collared earthstars have a reputation for being edible, but that is a reputation, not a recommendation. The collared earthstar's use in Chinese and folk medicine is no reason to pick it and no proof that it treats anything.

Protected earthstars

No Geastrum species is listed in Ukraine's Red Data Book. The only earthstar there is a relative, the pepper pot (Myriostoma coliforme), listed as rare, which grows on sandy soils in forest-steppe and steppe, in pine and acacia plantations and in southern Crimea.

In Poland the arched earthstar and eight other Geastrum species are strictly protected, as are the pepper pot and the barometer earthstar, while the collared earthstar is not. In Britain the arched earthstar was rated Vulnerable on the 1992 Red Data List. They are useless in the kitchen anyway, so please leave them for the next person to enjoy.

Where and when earthstars grow across Europe

GBIF holds about 89,000 European records of earthstars, a third from the Netherlands and nearly a quarter from Sweden, then Britain and Germany. For the collared earthstar alone, almost two thirds of the records are Dutch. The arched earthstar is scarce: just over a thousand European records, mostly from Britain, Sweden, Germany and Hungary.

October brings the most records, nearly a third, followed by September and November; in Austria, Switzerland and Norway the peak is in September. Earthstars last for months, though, so winter and spring records are mostly old stars, which explains a second wave of records in April in Sweden and Spain.

Of Ukraine's 376 records, 222 date from September, but that is probably a single survey, not a sign of the season. A regional guide from Khmelnytskyi oblast gives May to November, mostly July to October, in pine and mixed forests. The species recorded most often in Ukraine are Geastrum striatum, G. saccatum and G. coronatum; the arched earthstar has 26 records, the collared earthstar only 9. In Odesa oblast, Geastrum is the richest genus among the puffball-like fungi, with seven species, two of them growing even on clay steppe slopes.

Questions and answers

The short answers

Are earthstars edible?

No, earthstars are inedible: they are not considered poisonous, but mature ones are fibrous and tough. Young, unopened collared earthstars have a reputation for being edible, but that is a reputation, not a recommendation.

Do earthstars open and close with the weather?

Not the collared or arched earthstar: once their rays have opened, they stay put whether it is wet or dry. Some other Geastrum species and the barometer earthstar (Astraeus hygrometricus) do curl their rays up in dry weather.

How do you identify the collared earthstar?

The collared earthstar (Geastrum triplex) is the largest earthstar, 5–10 cm across when open, with 4–8 rays that often crack so the spore sac sits in a saucer or collar. It grows in broadleaf litter, often under beech, and similar species sometimes need a microscope to separate.

Are earthstars protected?

Some are: in Poland the arched earthstar and eight other Geastrum species are strictly protected, although no Geastrum is in Ukraine's Red Data Book. Since they are inedible anyway, please photograph earthstars and leave them where they grow.

Sources

Crespo E.M., Domínguez de Toledo L. (Boletín de la Sociedad Argentina de Botánica, 1993, vol. 29, no. 1–2): how the star opens, moving and non-moving rays.

Babenko O.A., Epigeous gasteromycetes of the north-western Black Sea region (Ukrainian Botanical Journal, 2013, vol. 70, no. 5).

Order of the Ministry of Environmental Protection of Ukraine No. 111 of 15.02.2021: Red Data Book of Ukraine; Red Data Book of Ukraine online (redbook-ua.org): Myriostoma coliforme.

Polish Minister of the Environment regulation on the species protection of fungi (Dz.U. 2014 poz. 1408).

DGfM, Positivliste der Speisepilze and list of poisonous mushrooms by taxon (2026).

First Nature, pages on the collared and arched earthstars; MushroomExpert, pages on the collared earthstar and Astraeus hygrometricus; MykoWeb, page on Astraeus hygrometricus: features, edibility, habitat.

Wikipedia (English): articles on Geastrum, Geastrales, Geastrum triplex and Geastrum fornicatum. German Wikipedia, article Erdsterne. Ukrainian Wikipedia, article Geastrum (after Hovorun and Tymoshchuk, Fungi of Khmelnytskyi Region, 2014).

GBIF: records of earthstars in Europe and Ukraine by country and month.