Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Deer shield or Rooting shank

Deer shield and Rooting shank are similar species: Deer shield is edible, while Rooting shank is conditionally edible. The main visible difference: cap surface: Deer shield — smooth, Rooting shank — slimy.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Deer shieldRooting shank
Comparison of characteristics: Deer shield and Rooting shank
Edibility classDeer shield: EdibleRooting shank: Conditionally edible
UseDeer shield: Cook fresh, PicklingRooting shank: Cook fresh
Cap colourDeer shield: Brown, Dark brown, GreyRooting shank: Brown, Grey, Cream
Cap shapeDeer shield: ConvexRooting shank: Convex, Umbonate, Flat
Cap surfaceDeer shield: SmoothRooting shank: Slimy
TasteDeer shield: MildRooting shank: —
SmellDeer shield: Radish-like, OdourlessRooting shank: Odourless, Fruity
StemDeer shield: CentralRooting shank: Central, Rooting
SubstrateDeer shield: On wood, Dead woodRooting shank: Dead wood, Soil
Partner treesDeer shield: Oak, Beech, Hornbeam, Aspen, BirchRooting shank: Beech, Oak

Same in both: season, size, flesh colour change, hymenophore, nutrition type, growth habit.

When and where they meet

Together: June–October

Their seasons overlap: June–October. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: deciduous forest, mixed forest.

Deer shield

Fruiting season

June – November

Rooting shank

Fruiting season

May – October

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Deer shield

Cap 4-12 cm across, hemispherical to conical-convex with an umbo when young, later flattening out with a low umbo. Colour brownish-grey, deer-brown, dark brown, darker when young and fading to grey-brown with age. Surface smooth with fine, darker radial fibres, slightly sticky in wet weather.

Rooting shank

The cap is 3 to 10 cm across, occasionally 12 cm, bell-shaped or convex at first, then flat with a broad central bump.

It's slimy when wet, shiny or silky when dry, and radially wrinkled or pitted, especially around the centre. The colour varies a lot: pale grey-brown, brown, ochre, olive-brown and sometimes almost white.

Hymenophore

Deer shield

Gills free (not attached to the stem) and crowded, whitish at first, later turning pink as the spores mature. Spore print PINK: a hallmark of the genus Pluteus (though pinkgills, Volvariella and some other mushrooms have pink spores too).

Rooting shank

The gills are white to cream, broad, thick and widely spaced, attached with a small tooth or notched, and often brown-edged on old caps.

The spore print is white.

Stem

Deer shield

Stem 5-12 cm tall, 0.8-1.5 cm thick, cylindrical, long and fairly slender, often thickened toward the base. Colour whitish to grey-brown, with fine, darker lengthwise fibres. No ring and no volva. The missing volva is the more reliable difference from amanitas: some amanitas have no ring.

Rooting shank

Above ground the stem is 8 to 20 cm tall and 0.3 to 1 cm thick, white at the top and brown lower down, grooved lengthways and fibrous, often twisted and tough. There's no ring or veil.

Underground the stem continues as a long, tapering 'root' to buried wood or tree roots, often as long as the part above ground. It swells slightly just above the root.

Flesh

Deer shield

Flesh soft, watery, white. When cut, it does not change colour. Smell faint; in some populations with a hint of radish.

Rooting shank

The flesh is thin and white, soft and springy in the cap, fibrous and tough in the stem.

Smell

Deer shield

Faint, neutral, mushroomy; in some populations with a hint of radish or raw potato.

Rooting shank

The smell is indistinct or faintly fruity.

Related comparisons

Sources · 16

  • [1]Index Fungorum
  • [2]Species Fungorum
  • [3]GBIF
  • [4]Wikipedia (English)
  • [5]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [6]First Nature: Hymenopellis radicata, Rooting Shank
  • [7]First Nature: Megacollybia platyphylla, Whitelaced Shank
  • [8]Wild Food UK: Rooting Shank
  • [9]NatureSpot: Rooting Shank
  • [10]Niego A.G.T. et al. Taxonomy, Diversity and Cultivation of the Oudemansielloid/Xeruloid Taxa Hymenopellis, Mucidula, Oudemansiella, and Xerula with Respect to Their Bioactivities: A Review. Journal of Fungi, 2021, 7(1): 51, Niego A.G.T. et al. (2021)
  • [11]Wikipedia (de): Grubiger Wurzelrübling
  • [12]Шульга В. М. Світ грибів України: Oudemansiella radicata
  • [13]GBIF: знахідки Hymenopellis radicata в Україні
  • [14]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [15]MycoBank Database
  • [16]iNaturalist Ukraine