How to tell Slender pholiota from Sulphur tuft
Slender pholiota and Sulphur tuft look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Slender pholiota is unknown, while Sulphur tuft is poisonous. The main visible difference: ring (veil): Slender pholiota — ring remnants, Sulphur tuft — no ring. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: cap surface. If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.
Not sure? Identify by photoSide by side
| Characteristic | Slender pholiota | Sulphur tuft |
|---|---|---|
| Edibility class | Slender pholiota: Unknown | Sulphur tuft: Poisonous |
| Season | Slender pholiota: — | Sulphur tuft: Spring, Summer, Autumn |
| Use | Slender pholiota: — | Sulphur tuft: Not eaten |
| Size | Slender pholiota: Small (up to 5 cm), Medium (5–15 cm) | Sulphur tuft: Small (up to 5 cm) |
| Cap colour | Slender pholiota: Brown, Rusty, Yellow | Sulphur tuft: Yellow, Olive |
| Cap shape | Slender pholiota: — | Sulphur tuft: Convex, Flat |
| Cap surface | Slender pholiota: Slimy | Sulphur tuft: Smooth |
| Taste | Slender pholiota: — | Sulphur tuft: Bitter |
| Flesh colour change | Slender pholiota: — | Sulphur tuft: No change |
| Stem | Slender pholiota: — | Sulphur tuft: Central, Hollow |
| Ring (veil) | Slender pholiota: Ring remnants | Sulphur tuft: No ring |
| Substrate | Slender pholiota: Dead wood, On wood, Soil | Sulphur tuft: Dead wood |
| Partner trees | Slender pholiota: Pine | Sulphur tuft: Oak, Birch, Pine, Spruce |
| Growth habit | Slender pholiota: In clusters from one base, In groups | Sulphur tuft: In clusters from one base |
Same in both: smell, hymenophore, nutrition type.
POISONOUS
Eating it causes poisoning. Do not pick it unless you have identified it with certainty.
It causes severe gastrointestinal poisoning, and in rare severe cases liver damage and death have been described. Which compound (fasciculols, fasciculic acids or muscarine) is responsible for poisoning in humans hasn't been established. Symptoms usually appear after a few hours (anywhere from half an hour to 8–10 hours), and the poisoning mostly passes within a few days.
If you suspect poisoning, call your local emergency number (112 in the EU, 999 in the UK) immediately
When and where they meet
Together: August–November
What they look like
Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell
Cap
Slender pholiota
Cap 2–8 cm across, conical to convex when young, then flat, sometimes with a low bump. Ochre brown to reddish brown, darker and tawny in the centre, with a yellow margin that's often tinged green. Surface slimy or tacky, smooth with flattened fibres.
Sulphur tuft
The cap is 2–7 cm across, convex or hemispherical when young, then flattening. It's sulphur yellow or egg-yolk yellow, often orange-brown in the centre, with a smooth, moist surface and no scales. The margin is uneven and, in young mushrooms, joined to the stem by a cobwebby veil.
Hymenophore
Slender pholiota
Gills attached or slightly running down the stem, close, sulphur yellow or pale greenish yellow when young, cinnamon brown with age, often keeping a greenish tinge. Spore print rusty brown.
Sulphur tuft
The gills are crowded, yellow or yellow-green at first, then darkening to grey-green or brownish olive. This is the key feature that sets it apart from the edible honey fungus, whose gills are whitish or cream. The spore print is purplish brown.
Stem
Slender pholiota
Stem 3–8 cm tall and 0.4–1 cm thick, cylindrical, hollow when mature. Yellow above with a powdery greenish-yellow apex, browning from the base upward. Surface fibrous, with yellow fibres from a thin veil; no distinct ring, at most a faint zone that soon fades.
Sulphur tuft
The stem is thin, 4–10 cm tall and 0.4–0.8 cm thick, yellowish above and brownish or rusty below, and fibrous. There's no ring, or only a faint fibrous one that soon disappears. True honey fungus usually has a membranous ring, but it can be torn off, so the ring alone won't tell them apart: look at the gill colour first.
Flesh
Slender pholiota
Flesh yellow, soft, sometimes watery bright greenish yellow.
Sulphur tuft
The flesh is yellowish, thin and bitter, very bitter when raw. But cooking removes the bitterness while the toxins remain, so in a finished dish the mushroom won't give itself away.
Smell
Slender pholiota
Odour mild and indistinct; one description compares the smell to freshly husked green corn.
Sulphur tuft
The smell is mushroomy but indistinct, so you can't tell it from honey fungus by smell.
Related comparisons
Sources · 12
- [1]Species Fungorum
- [2]Smith & Hesler, The North American Species of Pholiota: Pholiota spumosa (mykoweb)
- [3]Smith & Hesler, The North American Species of Pholiota: Importance (edibility)
- [4]Wikipedia (English)
- [5]Вікіпедія (українська)
- [6]BioImages: Pholiota spumosa
- [7]griby.org: Pholiota spumosa
- [8]Funga Nordica: Pholiota (Jacobsson 2008), Jacobsson S., in Funga Nordica (2008)
- [9]First Nature: Galerina marginata, Funeral Bell
- [10]First Nature: Hypholoma fasciculare, Sulphur Tuft
- [11]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
- [12]GBIF