Genus
Waxcaps
Mushrooms in the taxonomic group “Hygrocybe”. 4 species in the database.
Waxcaps (Hygrocybe) are small, brightly coloured mushrooms with thick gills that look and feel like wax: scarlet, orange, yellow, as if dipped in candle wax. They don't grow in woodland but on old grassland, pasture and lawns that have gone unploughed and unfertilised for many years. That is why wax caps matter less as food than as a sign: where you find lots of them, a genuinely old meadow has survived.

Blackening waxcap
Hygrocybe conica
Poisonous
Crimson waxcap
Hygrocybe punicea
Inedible
Scarlet waxcap
Hygrocybe coccinea
Inedible
Vermilion waxcap
Hygrocybe miniata
Inedible
How waxcaps differ from other mushrooms
Waxcaps have a white spore print, widely spaced thick gills that seem made of wax, and a smooth stem with no ring or volva. In wet weather the cap is often moist or slimy. Woodwaxes (Hygrophorus) share the waxy gills but grow in woodland under trees and are mostly duller in colour.
DNA studies moved some waxcaps into separate genera, so on this site they sit nearby rather than on this page: the snowy waxcap and meadow waxcap (Cuphophyllus) and the parrot waxcap (Gliophorus). The four species below remain in Hygrocybe proper.
How to tell the waxcaps apart
Blackening waxcap is the easiest to recognise: a sharply conical orange to reddish cap, and the whole mushroom turns black with age, the flesh darkening where it breaks. It is the most widespread species in Ukraine.
Crimson waxcap is the largest of the four: cap up to 10 cm, deep red, often with a yellowish edge, and a coarse, fibrous stem that is white at the base. It is rare.
Scarlet waxcap is smaller, cap 2–5 cm, blood red fading to orange with age, with a smoother stem than the crimson waxcap.
Vermilion waxcap is tiny, cap 1–3 cm, dry and finely scurfy to the touch, bright red.
Are waxcaps edible?
Waxcaps are not for the basket, for two reasons.
Blackening waxcap was long called poisonous, but no toxin has been found in it and there are no well-documented poisonings: at least one report from China is mentioned, but its original source could not be traced. The mycologist David Arora thought the reported cases may have involved other mushrooms. Ukrainian guides list it as inedible, and so do we. No proof of toxicity does not mean it is safe.
Crimson waxcap is called edible in some sources, but there are reports from the US of very unpleasant stomach upsets. The scarlet and vermilion waxcaps are also mentioned as edible, yet they are small, scarce and have no flavour to speak of.
The second reason matters more: most waxcaps are becoming rare, and every mushroom picked from an old meadow counts.
Where and when waxcaps grow across Europe
Waxcaps need short, long-unploughed turf kept down by grazing or mowing: mountain pasture, old sheep grazing, churchyards, old lawns and parks. Unlike most grassland mushrooms they don't feed on dead material: their threads have been found inside living plant roots, and exactly how they feed is still being studied. Fertiliser, lime and ploughing wipe them out quickly.
GBIF records show most waxcaps are found in Britain, Sweden, Norway and Denmark. In Britain, the Netherlands, Denmark, Belgium and France the season peaks in October and November; in Scandinavia, Switzerland and Austria it comes earlier, in September. In Ukraine there are few records and they spread differently: the most in September, but almost as many in June, July and August. The blackening waxcap occurs across Ukraine, from the Carpathians and Polissia to the steppe and Crimea, while the crimson waxcap is known only from the Carpathians and the Left-Bank Forest-Steppe.
Why waxcaps are under threat
Waxcap grassland is disappearing all over Europe. In the Netherlands the mycologist Eef Arnolds showed in the 1980s how quickly waxcaps vanish once grassland is fertilised, and over the last three quarters of a century more than 90% of old grassland in western Europe has been ploughed or fertilised. Around 30 grassland fungi are on the IUCN Red List as vulnerable or endangered, the crimson waxcap among them.
Britain considers its waxcap grasslands among the most important in the world: every autumn volunteers count them in a national survey, and the number of waxcap species on a site helps decide whether it deserves protection. In Ukraine no species of the genus Hygrocybe is in the Red Data Book, but a close relative, the pink waxcap (Porpolomopsis calyptriformis), is. Five species of the waxcap family that the IUCN rates as vulnerable are also known from Ukraine, the crimson waxcap among them.
If you find a meadow full of waxcaps in different colours, photograph them and leave them where they are: a site like that deserves a mycologist's attention.
Sources
Lodge D.J. et al. Molecular phylogeny, morphology, pigment chemistry and ecology in Hygrophoraceae (Fungal Diversity, 2014, vol. 64): how waxcaps were split into genera.
Chvikov V., Prylutskyi O. Annotated checklist of Hygrophoraceae in Ukraine (Biodiversity, Ecology and Experimental Biology, 2020, vol. 22): distribution in Ukraine, threatened species.
Halbwachs H. et al. (Environmental Microbiology, 2018): how waxcaps feed, the effect of fertiliser.
Order No. 111 of the Ministry of Environment of Ukraine, 15.02.2021 (zakon.rada.gov.ua): the Red Data Book of Ukraine.
Zerova M.Ya. et al. Hryby: yistivni, umovno yistivni, neyistivni, otruini (1979): the blackening waxcap as inedible.
First Nature waxcap species pages: features, edibility, British season. Plantlife, Waxcap Watch survey.
IUCN Red List: crimson waxcap (2019).
GBIF: records of waxcaps in Europe and Ukraine by country and month.