Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Family

Stinkhorn fungi

Mushrooms in the taxonomic group “Phallaceae”. 3 species in the database.

Stinkhorns (Phallaceae) are mushrooms that burst out of a white "egg" in a few hours and smell so strongly you notice them from far away. The smell is for flies: they eat the spore-laden slime on the tip and carry the spores off. The common stinkhorn, the dune stinkhorn with its pink egg and the slender dog stinkhorn are the ones you are most likely to meet. They are edible only at the egg stage, and the stinkhorn's reputation as a medicine is not backed by evidence.

How a stinkhorn grows from its egg, and why it smells

A young stinkhorn looks like a soft white ball 4–8 cm across, half buried in leaf litter. Inside, under a layer of jelly, the whole mushroom is already folded up. When it is ready, the stem straightens very fast, a few millimetres a minute, and reaches 10–30 cm in a few hours. It pushes with enough force to break through asphalt.

The tip is covered in olive slime full of spores. It smells of carrion and radish at once: chemists have found the same sulphur compounds in it as in rotting meat. Flies arrive, clean off the slime within a day, and leave a bare white honeycombed cap. That is why early morning is the best time to see a stinkhorn.

How to tell the stinkhorn fungi apart

Common stinkhorn has a white egg and a white, pitted stem 10–30 cm tall, and you can smell it from a long way off. It grows near rotting wood in broadleaf and mixed woodland, parks and gardens.

Dune stinkhorn has a pink to violet egg and pink cords in the soil, visible before the mushroom has even grown. It is shorter, often grows in groups and smells faint and sweetish, noticeable only within about a metre. It likes sandy and disturbed ground.

Dog stinkhorn is slender, 8–15 cm, with a yellowish to orange stem and a pointed tip with no separate cap. Its egg is small, 2–4 cm, and almost entirely underground. It smells less than the common stinkhorn.

In Europe you may also come across relatives from another family: the red lattice basket stinkhorn (Clathrus ruber) and the octopus stinkhorn (Clathrus archeri) with its red arms. Both were introduced, and both smell just as strongly.

Is the stinkhorn edible?

The common stinkhorn is eaten only at the egg stage, while everything inside is still white: the jelly layer is removed and the centre is fried or eaten raw, tasting of radish. In parts of France and Germany the eggs are sold fresh or pickled. A grown stinkhorn is inedible.

The dune stinkhorn egg is eaten too, but we would not recommend it. We treat the dog stinkhorn as inedible: guides disagree about its eggs, and dogs have reportedly become very ill after eating mature ones.

The real danger is not the stinkhorn itself. Deadly amanitas also have an egg stage. Cut your find in half: a stinkhorn egg shows the young stem inside a slimy jelly layer, while an amanita egg has no such slime. If you are not sure, don't eat it.

Does the stinkhorn have medicinal benefits?

There is no evidence that stinkhorns treat anything in people. They have a long history in folk medicine, against gout and as a love potion, and tinctures are still sold. But the only "clinical" mention is a short conference abstract that could not be traced, the popular figures about thousands of cured patients come from sellers' websites with no references, and the lab papers on anti-cancer effects concern a different, tropical species. On the other hand, one lab study found that common stinkhorn extract damaged mouse sperm-forming cells. We would not use it as a remedy.

Where and when stinkhorns grow across Europe

GBIF records show most stinkhorns across Europe are found in September and October. In the Netherlands, Britain, Belgium, France and Germany the peak is October; in Sweden and Denmark it comes earlier, in September. Further south the season is longer: in Spain many finds are in winter and spring, and in Portugal most of them are. In Ukraine stinkhorns appear from June to October.

The dune stinkhorn is spreading in Ukraine: once known from only a few regions, it now turns up almost everywhere, mostly on disturbed sandy ground. In Britain, by contrast, it grows almost only on coastal dunes.

Protected stinkhorns

The dog stinkhorn is in the Red Data Book of Ukraine. Other members of the group, including the red lattice basket stinkhorn and the octopus stinkhorn, used to be listed too, but were removed in 2021. The common and dune stinkhorns are not protected in Ukraine. In Poland the common stinkhorn was protected from 1983 to 2004, and the dune stinkhorn is in the Latvian Red Data Book.

Etty Darwin and the stinkhorns

Charles Darwin's granddaughter, the artist Gwen Raverat, wrote in her memoir about her Aunt Etty, Darwin's daughter. Etty thought stinkhorns indecent, tracked them down in the woods by their smell and burned them in secret.

Sources

Heluta V.P. Distribution of Phallus hadriani in Ukraine (Ukrainian Botanical Journal, 2019, vol. 76, no. 1): range and features of the dune stinkhorn in Ukraine.

Heluta V.P., Zykova M.O. Distribution in Ukraine of some Phallales species included in the Red Data Book of Ukraine (Ukrainian Botanical Journal, 2019, vol. 76, no. 2).

Order No. 111 of the Ministry of Environment of Ukraine, 15.02.2021: the Red Data Book of Ukraine and the list of species removed from it.

First Nature pages on the common, dune and dog stinkhorns and the lattice stinkhorns: features, edibility, British season.

DGfM, Mushroom of the Year 2020 (PTA heute, 08.09.2020): stinkhorn eggs, growth speed, folk medicine.

Solek P. et al. (Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 2021, vol. 209): effect of stinkhorn extract on mouse cells.

Raverat G. Period Piece (1952): Etty Darwin and the stinkhorns.

Borg-Karlson A.-K. et al. (Phytochemistry, 1994); Niksic M. et al. (Mycologist, 2004): the smell and growing force of the stinkhorn.

GBIF: records of stinkhorns in Europe and Ukraine by country and month.