Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Family

Ink cap mushrooms

Mushrooms in the taxonomic group “Psathyrellaceae”. 6 species in the database.

An ink cap (Coprinus, Coprinopsis, Coprinellus) is a mushroom whose gills, and then the whole cap, dissolve into a black liquid that looks like ink. That is why people also call them ink mushrooms. You are more likely to meet ink caps on a lawn, a verge, an old stump or a compost heap than deep in a forest. Some are edible while young, and one of them, the common inkcap, makes you ill if you drink alcohol with it or for days afterwards.

This page gathers the ink caps of the family Psathyrellaceae. The shaggy ink cap, the best known and best to eat, now sits in a different family (Agaricaceae, the mushroom family), so it is not in the list below, but we cover it in the text.

Why ink caps turn to ink

It is not rot. It is how the mushroom spreads its spores. Spores ripen on each gill from the bottom up, and the ink cap digests the strip of gill that has already shed its spores, clearing the way for the next ones to fall. The cap edge darkens and drips until only a stem with a small black disc is left. The mycologist Reginald Buller described this back in 1910.

It happens fast. A picked ink cap can start to darken within an hour and turn to black mush in your basket within a day or two. Heat stops the process, so edible ink caps are cooked on the day they are picked.

Not every ink cap melts. The fairy inkcap, a tiny mushroom that covers stumps in hundreds, barely dissolves at all. And the weeping widow in the list below is not an ink cap: dark droplets bead along its gill edges like tears, but it never turns to ink.

How to tell ink cap mushrooms apart

Shaggy ink cap is easy to recognise: a tall white cylinder up to 10–15 cm high, covered in fluffy scales like a judge's wig, which gives it its other name, lawyer's wig. It grows in groups and lines on lawns, verges, playing fields and loose, fertile ground.

Common inkcap is grey or grey-brown and smooth, with no scales. The cap is 3–7 cm, egg-shaped, then bell-shaped. It grows in tight clumps by stumps, on buried wood, on lawns and roadsides, often right in town.

Glistening inkcap is smaller, 2–4 cm, tawny-ochre, and when young it is dusted with tiny white glittering grains, like mica. Rain washes them off. It grows in big clusters on stumps and the roots of broadleaf trees.

Magpie inkcap is the handsome one: a dark, almost black cap with white patches of veil, like a magpie's plumage. It grows alone in broadleaf woods, mostly under beech, on chalky soil. It is not common.

Grey shag is small and greyish with flecks of veil. It likes dung, straw heaps and compost.

Fairy inkcap is tiny, up to 1.5 cm across, and grows in huge troops on rotting wood.

Which ink caps are edible and which are poisonous

Shaggy ink cap is edible and good, but only when young, while the gills are still white. Once they turn pink or black, leave it. Cook it the same day, ideally within a few hours of picking. It is not known to cause the alcohol reaction of the common inkcap, though one German lab found traces of coprine in it, so it cannot be called entirely safe with drink. Pick it away from roads: shaggy ink caps take up heavy metals.

Common inkcap is the poisonous ink cap mushroom to know about, but only with alcohol. It contains coprine, which stops the body breaking down alcohol. Even a small drink brings on a flushed face and neck, a hot feeling, a pounding heart, nausea, vomiting, sometimes low blood pressure and, rarely, heart complications. The reaction typically comes within about three days of the meal, some sources say up to five, so avoid alcohol for at least five days. Alcohol drunk a few hours before the meal, while it is still in your blood, can trigger it too. Without alcohol the mushroom is not poisonous, and older guides call it edible when young. But in animal studies purified coprine damaged the testes, and nobody has studied that risk in people. So we advise not eating the common inkcap at all.

Magpie inkcap is not edible and is best treated as poisonous: stomach upsets have been reported, but there are no detailed accounts of poisoning. No data does not mean safe.

Glistening inkcap is edible, but again without alcohol: German data suggest it may hold a little coprine. The flesh is thin, the flavour faint, and a mix-up with the common inkcap costs more than it is worth. The grey shag has barely been studied, so we advise against eating it. The fairy inkcap is too small to be worth cooking. If in doubt, leave it out.

Where and when ink caps grow across Europe

Ink caps grow all over Europe, from Scandinavia to the Mediterranean, including Britain, Ireland and Ukraine. They are mushrooms of places people use: lawns, parks, verges, sports fields, flower beds, compost and old stumps in gardens.

GBIF records show that most ink caps across Europe are found in October. In the north, in Sweden and Norway, the peak comes earlier, in September. In the west, in the Netherlands, Britain, Germany and France, they carry on into November, and in Spain the peak is November, with a good share of finds in winter and spring. After warm rain the shaggy ink cap can appear in spring and summer too. In Ukraine it is found from summer to late autumn on fertile ground and in planted woodland.

Countries see the shaggy ink cap differently. In Britain and Ukraine it is valued as a good edible, while in Poland it is not on the official list of edible mushrooms. In Asia it is grown commercially on a large scale.

Why ink caps now sit in different families

All ink caps used to belong to one genus, Coprinus. In 2001 DNA studies showed they were several separate lineages. The name Coprinus stayed with the shaggy ink cap and a few close relatives in Agaricaceae, while the rest were split into Coprinopsis (common inkcap, magpie inkcap, grey shag), Coprinellus (glistening and fairy inkcaps) and Parasola, all placed in Psathyrellaceae. So the same inky habit does not mean close kinship.

Ink from mushrooms and an ink cap in the lab

The black liquid of the common inkcap really was used as ink: it was boiled with a little water and a few cloves. It is often said that such ink was used to sign important documents because the spores, visible under a microscope, made forgery hard, but there is no solid historical record of this.

The grey shag, meanwhile, became a laboratory mushroom. It completes its whole life cycle in about two weeks, so scientists use it to study how fungi build a fruiting body and how heredity works in fungi.

Sources

Redhead S.A. et al. Coprinus Pers. and the disposition of Coprinus species sensu lato (Taxon, 2001, vol. 50): how ink caps were split into genera and families.

Buller A.H.R. (Annals of Botany, 1910): why ink cap gills dissolve.

Lindberg P. et al. (Journal of the Chemical Society, 1975, 1977): coprine in the common inkcap.

Michelot D. Poisoning by Coprinus atramentarius (Natural Toxins, 1992); Jönsson M. et al. (1979): how coprine acts, animal studies.

Wennig R. et al. Mushroom poisoning (Deutsches Ärzteblatt International, 2020); North American Mycological Association: symptoms and timing of the alcohol reaction.

Nowakowski P. et al. The two faces of Coprinus comatus (Phytotherapy Research, 2020): shaggy ink cap, heavy metals, status in Poland, cultivation.

Stajich J.E. et al. (PNAS, 2010): the grey shag as a model organism.

Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund, Normlisten 2024; Deutsche Gesellschaft für Mykologie: edibility of ink caps.

First Nature, MushroomExpert, Woodland Trust: features and habitats; Roger Phillips, Mushrooms: ink from ink caps.

GBIF: records of ink caps across Europe by country and month.