Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Edibility class

Unknown

Unknown — mushrooms with the trait «Unknown»

Despite centuries of research, for a huge number of mushroom species the "Edibility" field in mycological guides holds one terse word: "Unknown" (or "Not studied"). It means science has no reliable clinical data on whether that mushroom contains dangerous toxins or not.

3 species in the database.

Why does edibility remain unknown?

David Arora estimates that the forests of North America and Europe hold thousands of macrofungi species that no one has ever tried to cook. The reasons are very practical:

1. "LBM" (Little Brown Mushrooms): "Little brown mushrooms" is an unofficial but widely accepted term among mycologists. It covers hundreds of species of small, thin-stemmed, inconspicuous mushrooms (bonnets, Galerina, small webcaps) that have no culinary value at all. There is simply no point in picking them for food.

2. Rarity: If a species is extremely rare and never fruits in large numbers, there are no statistics on people eating it (or on possible poisonings).

3. Difficult identification: Some species can only be told apart under a microscope. If one of them is edible and another is "unknown", the general advice is to avoid both.

Presumed poisonous

In her works, M.Ya. Zerova takes a strict medical approach: any mushroom of unknown edibility must be considered dangerous by default (inedible or poisonous).

Experimenting on your own health by testing an "unknown" mushroom is deadly dangerous. Many lethal poisons (such as orellanine in webcaps) have a hidden latency period of up to 14 days. A person eats the mushroom, feels perfectly fine, and two weeks later their kidneys fail irreversibly.

Questions and answers

If animals (squirrels, wild boars or slugs) eat a mushroom, does that mean it is edible for humans?
THIS IS THE BIGGEST MYTH! The digestive system and metabolism of many animals and insects are fundamentally different from ours. Slugs happily munch on the death cap, which will kill a human. Squirrels store toxic mushrooms because their bodies are immune to certain poisons.
How does science determine whether new mushroom species are edible?
Modern science does not run tastings. Edibility and toxicity are tested by chemical analysis (chromatography) of fruiting bodies for known groups of toxins (amatoxins, muscarine, coprine, etc.), and by collecting clinical statistics on poisonings in hospitals.
What should I do if I accidentally ate a mushroom of "unknown" edibility?
Don't panic, but watch closely how you feel. If symptoms appear within 6-24 hours (nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, dizziness), go to a hospital immediately and be sure to tell them you ate unidentified wild mushrooms.

Sources

  1. 1.Зерова М.Я. та ін. Визначник грибів України. 1979
  2. 2.Roger Phillips. Mushrooms (Roger Phillips)
  3. 3.David Arora. Mushrooms Demystified
  4. 4.Index Fungorum