Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Blackening waxcap or Crimson waxcap

Blackening waxcap and Crimson waxcap are similar species that can be mixed up while foraging. The main visible difference: flesh colour change: Blackening waxcap — darkens, Crimson waxcap — no change.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Blackening waxcapCrimson waxcap
Comparison of characteristics: Blackening waxcap and Crimson waxcap
Edibility classBlackening waxcap: PoisonousCrimson waxcap: Inedible
SeasonBlackening waxcap: Summer, AutumnCrimson waxcap: Autumn
SizeBlackening waxcap: Small (up to 5 cm), Medium (5–15 cm)Crimson waxcap: Medium (5–15 cm)
Cap colourBlackening waxcap: Orange, Red, Yellow, BlackCrimson waxcap: Red, Orange, Pale yellow
Cap shapeBlackening waxcap: ConicalCrimson waxcap: Conical, Convex, Umbonate, Flat
TasteBlackening waxcap: MildCrimson waxcap: —
Flesh colour changeBlackening waxcap: DarkensCrimson waxcap: No change

Same in both: use, cap surface, smell, hymenophore, stem, substrate, growth habit.

When and where they meet

Together: September–October

Their seasons overlap: September–October. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: meadow.

Blackening waxcap

Fruiting season

July – November

Crimson waxcap

Fruiting season

September – October

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Blackening waxcap

Cap 2-7 cm, cone-shaped or sharply pointed at first, later flattening into a broad cone with a sharp umbo. Bright orange or red-orange, sometimes with yellow tones. Surface moist and waxy, slimy in wet weather. Key feature: it turns black when damaged.

Crimson waxcap

The cap is 3 to 10 cm across, occasionally 15 cm. It's bell-shaped or conically domed at first, then convex or broadly umbonate and finally flattened, with an irregular edge that becomes wavy in old caps.

It's a dark blood red, often with a narrow yellowish rim. The surface is smooth and greasy or slimy when wet; young caps sometimes have a whitish bloom. As it ages, the cap fades in patches, usually from the centre, to yellowish buff.

Hymenophore

Blackening waxcap

Gills widely spaced, waxy and free. Yellowish to orange at first, they turn black when damaged, and in old mushrooms they're completely black. Spore print white.

Crimson waxcap

The gills are thick, waxy and fairly widely spaced, narrowly attached or almost free, and often cross-veined near the cap. They're yellow, orange or reddish.

The spore print is white.

Stem

Blackening waxcap

Stem 4-10 cm tall, 0.4-1 cm thick, slender, cylindrical, hollow, sometimes twisted. Orange-yellow to reddish, with lengthwise fibres. With damage and age it turns black all over. No ring.

Crimson waxcap

The stem is 5 to 12 cm tall and 1 to 2 cm thick, stout, dry, coarsely fibrous and streaked lengthways. It's yellow flushed red at the top, orange lower down and white at the base. There's no ring.

The fibrous, streaky stem is the best way to tell it from the scarlet waxcap, whose stem is smooth.

Flesh

Blackening waxcap

Flesh thin, brittle, yellowish. It turns black when cut or touched, the key diagnostic feature of the group (subgenus Pseudohygrocybe).

Crimson waxcap

The flesh is waxy and fairly firm, and doesn't change colour or blacken when cut.

Smell

Blackening waxcap

No distinctive smell, or faintly mushroomy. The taste is mild, but tasting it isn't a good idea.

Crimson waxcap

The smell is indistinct.

Related comparisons

Sources · 19

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]Species Fungorum
  • [8]Wikipedia (English)
  • [9]Википедия (русская)
  • [10]First Nature: Hygrocybe punicea, Crimson Waxcap
  • [11]First Nature: Hygrocybe splendidissima, Splendid Waxcap
  • [12]First Nature: Hygrocybe aurantiosplendens, Orange Waxcap
  • [13]Wood M., Stevens F., MykoWeb California Fungi: Hygrocybe punicea
  • [14]IUCN European Red List: Hygrocybe punicea (VU, Mešić 2019), via redlist.info
  • [15]JNCC. Guidelines for the Selection of Biological SSSIs, Chapter 14: Non-lichenised fungi (Bosanquet et al. 2018)
  • [16]Plantlife. Waxcaps and Grassland Fungi ID guide, 2024
  • [17]Chvikov V., Prylutskyi O. Annotated checklist of Hygrophoraceae of Ukraine. Biodiversity, Ecology and Experimental Biology, 2020, 22(2): 6–23, Chvikov V., Prylutskyi O. (2020)
  • [18]Wikipedia (de): Granatroter Saftling
  • [19]Wikigrib: Гигроцибе пунцовая