How to tell Giant puffball from Death cap
Giant puffball and Death cap look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Giant puffball is edible, while Death cap is deadly poisonous. The main visible difference: flesh colour change: Giant puffball — yellowing, Death cap — no change. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: colour, smell, size. If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.
Not sure? Identify by photoSide by side
| Characteristic | Giant puffball | Death cap |
|---|---|---|
| Edibility class | Giant puffball: Edible | Death cap: Deadly poisonous |
| Use | Giant puffball: Culinary, Cook fresh | Death cap: Not eaten |
| Size | Giant puffball: Large (over 15 cm), Giant (>25 cm) | Death cap: Medium (5–15 cm) |
| Colour | Giant puffball: White | Death cap: Green, Olive, Pale yellow |
| Cap shape | Giant puffball: — | Death cap: Convex, Flat |
| Cap surface | Giant puffball: — | Death cap: Smooth, Fibrous |
| Taste | Giant puffball: Mild | Death cap: Neutral taste |
| Smell | Giant puffball: Pleasant | Death cap: Honey, Odourless |
| Flesh colour change | Giant puffball: Yellowing | Death cap: No change |
| Hymenophore | Giant puffball: — | Death cap: Gilled |
| Stem | Giant puffball: — | Death cap: Central, Bulbous |
| Ring (veil) | Giant puffball: — | Death cap: Ring present |
| Volva | Giant puffball: — | Death cap: Volva present |
| Nutrition type | Giant puffball: Saprotroph | Death cap: Mycorrhizal |
| Partner trees | Giant puffball: — | Death cap: Oak, Beech, Birch |
| Growth habit | Giant puffball: Solitary, In rings | Death cap: Solitary, In groups |
Same in both: season, substrate.
DEADLY POISONOUS
Eating it can cause death. Do not pick it and do not taste it.
It contains amatoxins (α-amanitin), which block RNA polymerase II and cause liver and kidney cells to die (necrosis).
The first symptoms (nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea) usually come 8–12 h after eating, but anywhere from 4 to 36 h. Around the second day there's a deceptive improvement. Then, from the third day, acute liver failure sets in.
If you have the slightest suspicion, go to the hospital immediately. Hospitals may give intravenous silibinin. But it hasn't proved to be a magic antidote: controlled studies have never shown that it works. Most of the heavy lifting is done by simpler things: hours of IV fluids, sorbents, intensive care and, in the worst cases, a liver transplant. The sooner you get to the hospital, the more options the doctors have.
If you suspect poisoning, call your local emergency number (112 in the EU, 999 in the UK) immediately
When and where they meet
Together: August–November
What they look like
Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell
Cap
Giant puffball
The fruit body is a ball or a slightly flattened, lumpy loaf, usually 10–50 cm across, with no separate cap and stem. The skin is leathery, finely velvety at first and soon smooth, white or cream, then yellowing and browning. On mature ones it cracks and peels away.
Death cap
The death cap's cap is 5–15 cm across, hemispherical when young, then opening out flat.
Its colour ranges from olive green and yellowish green to greyish and almost white, which is exactly what makes it tricky to identify. The surface is smooth and a little slimy in wet weather, with a characteristic pattern of darker fibres radiating from the centre. The margin is even, with no striations.
Hymenophore
Giant puffball
There are no gills or pores: the spores form inside the fruit body. In a young mushroom the flesh (gleba) is firm, pure white and uniform throughout. As it matures, it turns greenish yellow, then olive and brown, and ends up as a powdery mass of spores that escapes through cracks in the skin. Spore print olive-brown.
Death cap
The gills are crowded, thin and free, meaning they don't touch the stem. They're white and may turn creamy with age, sometimes with a faint pinkish tinge, but they never turn chocolate brown.
It never has the chocolate-brown gills of a mature Agaricus. The gap between gills and stem is clear. In young mushrooms a white, membranous veil covers the gills completely.
Stem
Giant puffball
There's no stem. The fruit body sits on the ground, held to the soil by a short, thick cord of mycelium. There's no sterile base either, which helps separate it from the mosaic puffball.
Death cap
The stem is slender, 7–15 cm tall and 1–2 cm thick. It's cylindrical and swells at the base into a characteristic club-shaped bulb wrapped in a membranous, sac-like volva. That volva is the main diagnostic feature.
It's whitish green, often with a faint, banded snakeskin pattern. A thin, fragile white ring, left over from the veil, hangs in the upper third and can tear or disappear. Below the ring the surface is faintly scaly.
Flesh
Giant puffball
The flesh (gleba) is evenly white when young, soft and springy, with no cavities and no pattern. It's mild, with little flavour of its own. Once it shows any yellow, olive or brown, it's no longer fit to eat and can upset your stomach.
Death cap
The flesh is white and doesn't change colour when cut, and that's the treacherous part: none of the safety signs foragers usually rely on work here. It's thin and brittle in the cap, thicker and firmer at the base of the stem.
It doesn't darken in the air, not after a minute and not after an hour. Don't let lovely white flesh reassure you: the death cap's flesh is just as white as that of edible mushrooms.
Smell
Giant puffball
A young one has only a faint smell, with nothing distinctive about it. Mature ones smell unpleasant, often of urine, a sign that the mushroom is past eating.
Death cap
Fresh, it has a faint smell that's easy to miss, and young ones barely smell at all. Mature mushrooms pick up a slightly sickly-sweet note, like wilted honey or stale dough.
That smell isn't strong enough to warn an inexperienced forager. Like other poisonous amanitas (the fly agaric, the panther cap), the death cap smells faint and nondescript, so it gives you no warning at all, which is one more treacherous trait. Only rotting mushrooms smell any stronger.
Related comparisons
Sources · 18
- [1]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
- [2]MycoBank Database
- [3]GBIF
- [4]Deathcap (Amanita phalloides), Woodland Trust
- [5]First Nature: Amanita phalloides, Deathcap
- [6]Wikipedia (en): Amanita phalloides
- [7]Mushroom poisoning, MSD Manual Professional Version
- [8]Poisonous mushrooms in Norway, Norwegian Poisons Information Centre, Helsenorge
- [9]First Nature: Calvatia gigantea, Giant Puffball
- [10]Kuo M., MushroomExpert: Calvatia gigantea
- [11]Wikipedia (en): Calvatia gigantea
- [12]Wikipedia (en): Puffball
- [13]First Nature: Amanita virosa, Destroying Angel
- [14]first-nature: Scleroderma citrinum
- [15]Stadt Wien, Pilzberatung: Riesenbovist
- [16]Missouri Department of Conservation: Giant Puffball
- [17]Galloway Wild Foods: Puffballs
- [18]Lycoperdonosis associated with puffball mushrooms, Wisconsin, 1994, CDC (1994)