Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Giant puffball or Common stinkhorn

Giant puffball and Common stinkhorn: both are edible. The species look alike and can be mixed up while foraging. The main visible difference: flesh colour change: Giant puffball — yellowing, Common stinkhorn — no change. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: smell.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Giant puffballCommon stinkhorn
Comparison of characteristics: Giant puffball and Common stinkhorn
SeasonGiant puffball: Summer, AutumnCommon stinkhorn: Spring, Summer, Autumn
UseGiant puffball: Culinary, Cook freshCommon stinkhorn: Cook fresh, Medicinal
SizeGiant puffball: Large (over 15 cm), Giant (>25 cm)Common stinkhorn: Large (over 15 cm)
ColourGiant puffball: WhiteCommon stinkhorn: White, Olive, Brown
SmellGiant puffball: PleasantCommon stinkhorn: Putrid
Flesh colour changeGiant puffball: YellowingCommon stinkhorn: No change
SubstrateGiant puffball: SoilCommon stinkhorn: Soil, Forest litter
Partner treesGiant puffball: —Common stinkhorn: Beech, Oak, Birch
Growth habitGiant puffball: Solitary, In ringsCommon stinkhorn: Solitary, In groups

Same in both: edibility class, taste, nutrition type.

When and where they meet

Together: June–November

Their seasons overlap: June–November. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Our cards list no shared habitats.

Giant puffball

Fruiting season

April – November

Common stinkhorn

Fruiting season

June – November

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Giant puffball

The fruit body is a ball or a slightly flattened, lumpy loaf, usually 10–50 cm across, with no separate cap and stem. The skin is leathery, finely velvety at first and soon smooth, white or cream, then yellowing and browning. On mature ones it cracks and peels away.

Common stinkhorn

At the egg stage it's a white or cream ball 4-6 cm across with a thick, slimy skin. When mature, it has a bell-shaped cap 3-5 cm tall, coated in dark olive or greenish-brown slimy gleba with a honeycomb pattern.

Hymenophore

Giant puffball

There are no gills or pores: the spores form inside the fruit body. In a young mushroom the flesh (gleba) is firm, pure white and uniform throughout. As it matures, it turns greenish yellow, then olive and brown, and ends up as a powdery mass of spores that escapes through cracks in the skin. Spore print olive-brown.

Common stinkhorn

Instead of gills or pores, the cap is coated in slimy gleba. The tiny spores are carried off by flies drawn to the powerful carrion smell, a specialised way of spreading that the whole stinkhorn family uses.

Stem

Giant puffball

There's no stem. The fruit body sits on the ground, held to the soil by a short, thick cord of mycelium. There's no sterile base either, which helps separate it from the mosaic puffball.

Common stinkhorn

The stem is 12-22 cm tall and 2-4 cm thick, white or cream, cylindrical and hollow. Its surface is spongy, delicate and brittle. It emerges from the egg in just 2-4 hours, one of the fastest growth rates of any fungus.

Flesh

Giant puffball

The flesh (gleba) is evenly white when young, soft and springy, with no cavities and no pattern. It's mild, with little flavour of its own. Once it shows any yellow, olive or brown, it's no longer fit to eat and can upset your stomach.

Common stinkhorn

In the egg, the flesh is white and firm, with a greenish gelatinous layer under the skin and a delicate taste. In the mature mushroom it's spongy, brittle and white. It doesn't change colour when cut.

Smell

Giant puffball

A young one has only a faint smell, with nothing distinctive about it. Mature ones smell unpleasant, often of urine, a sign that the mushroom is past eating.

Common stinkhorn

A young egg smells faint, barely mushroomy, with a hint of radish. The mature mushroom smells extremely strong and unpleasant, like carrion or rotting meat. The smell carries tens of metres and draws the flies that spread the spores.

Related comparisons

Sources · 23

  • [1]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [2]GBIF
  • [3]First Nature: Calvatia gigantea, Giant Puffball
  • [4]Kuo M., MushroomExpert: Calvatia gigantea
  • [5]Wikipedia (en): Calvatia gigantea
  • [6]Wikipedia (en): Puffball
  • [7]First Nature: Amanita virosa, Destroying Angel
  • [8]first-nature: Scleroderma citrinum
  • [9]Stadt Wien, Pilzberatung: Riesenbovist
  • [10]Missouri Department of Conservation: Giant Puffball
  • [11]Galloway Wild Foods: Puffballs
  • [12]Lycoperdonosis associated with puffball mushrooms, Wisconsin, 1994, CDC (1994)
  • [13]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [14]MycoBank Database
  • [15]Index Fungorum
  • [16]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [17]First Nature: Phallus impudicus, Stinkhorn
  • [18]first-nature: Phallus hadriani
  • [19]Phallus impudicus, Wikipedia
  • [20]Stinkhorn (Phallus impudicus), Woodland Trust
  • [21]Stinky Horn Mushroom (Phallus impudicus), American College of Emergency Physicians, Toxicology Section (2023)
  • [22]Plants 400: Phallus, University of Oxford Herbaria
  • [23]Foraging guide: stinkhorn, Foraging Course Company