Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

How to tell Olive oysterling from Jack-o'-lantern mushroom

Jack-o'-lantern mushroom is poisonous

Olive oysterling and Jack-o'-lantern mushroom look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Olive oysterling is edible, while Jack-o'-lantern mushroom is poisonous. The main visible difference: stem: Olive oysterling — lateral, Jack-o'-lantern mushroom — central. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: cap surface, partner trees, cap shape. If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Olive oysterlingJack-o'-lantern mushroom
Comparison of characteristics: Olive oysterling and Jack-o'-lantern mushroom
Edibility classOlive oysterling: EdibleJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Poisonous
SeasonOlive oysterling: AutumnJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Summer, Autumn
UseOlive oysterling: Cook fresh, PicklingJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Not eaten
Cap colourOlive oysterling: Olive, Brown, YellowJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Orange, Yellow, Red
Cap shapeOlive oysterling: IrregularJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Funnel-shaped
Cap surfaceOlive oysterling: SlimyJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Smooth
TasteOlive oysterling: MildJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Bitter
SmellOlive oysterling: —Jack-o'-lantern mushroom: Odourless
StemOlive oysterling: LateralJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Central
SubstrateOlive oysterling: Dead wood, Living treeJack-o'-lantern mushroom: On wood, Dead wood, Living tree
Nutrition typeOlive oysterling: SaprotrophJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Parasite
Partner treesOlive oysterling: Aspen, BeechJack-o'-lantern mushroom: Oak

Same in both: size, flesh colour change, hymenophore, growth habit.

When and where they meet

Together: September–December

Their seasons overlap: September–December. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: deciduous forest.

Olive oysterling

Fruiting season

January, September, October, November, December

Jack-o'-lantern mushroom

Fruiting season

August – December

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Olive oysterling

Cap 3–10 cm across, shell-, kidney- or fan-shaped, with a margin that's rolled in at first. Olive green, often with yellow, brown or violet tones, fading to light brown with age. Smooth and slimy when wet, with a gelatinous layer under the surface.

Jack-o'-lantern mushroom

The cap is 5-15 cm across. Young caps are convex-conical with an inrolled edge, later becoming funnel-shaped with a thin, wavy edge. It's bright orange, yellow-orange or brick, darker in the centre, and the surface is smooth, shiny in wet weather, without scales.

Hymenophore

Olive oysterling

Gills crowded, attached to the stem or running down it, pale yellow to orange-yellow, browning with age. Spore print white to pale cream.

Jack-o'-lantern mushroom

Underneath are true, crowded gills that run down the stem (not the blunt ridges of a real chanterelle), yellow-orange like the cap. The spore print is pale cream to yellowish. In the dark the gills may glow faintly with a pale green light (bioluminescence driven by luciferase enzymes).

Stem

Olive oysterling

Stem a short, thick, off-centre stub up to 2–3 cm long, yellowish to ochre with fine dark scales, and sometimes almost absent. No ring.

Jack-o'-lantern mushroom

The stem is 5-12 cm tall and 1-2 cm thick, cylindrical, often tapering toward the base, frequently curved. The colour is yellow-orange, matching the cap or slightly paler. The surface is smooth, without a ring. Several stems are often fused at the base into a cluster.

Flesh

Olive oysterling

Flesh white to yellowish, soft in young mushrooms and stringy in old ones. It doesn't change colour when cut. Guides describe the taste as mild to bitter, and old mushrooms are the bitter ones.

Jack-o'-lantern mushroom

The flesh is dense and yellow-orange and doesn't change colour when cut. Sources describe the smell differently, so it isn't a reliable feature.

Smell

Olive oysterling

No distinctive smell.

Jack-o'-lantern mushroom

Sources describe it differently, from faint and mushroomy to quite strong and pleasant or even intensely aromatic. So smell won't tell it apart from a chanterelle: look at the true gills and the clustered growth instead.

Related comparisons

Sources · 14

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]Sarcomyxa serotina, Olive Oysterling
  • [8]Wikipedia (en): Sarcomyxa serotina
  • [9]Wikipedia (de): Gelbstieliger Muschelseitling
  • [10]Wikipedia (pl): Łycznik późny
  • [11]NatureSpot: Olive Oysterling
  • [12]Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund: Normlisten 2026
  • [13]DGfM: Liste der Pilze mit uneinheitlich beurteiltem Speisewert (Stand 01.05.2026)
  • [14]Die Mär vom giftigen Muschelseitling und eine Frage des guten Geschmacks, Kunze, Neubauer, Foerster (2012)