Field mushroom or Weeping widow
Field mushroom and Weeping widow are similar species: Field mushroom is edible, while Weeping widow is inedible. The main visible difference: ring (veil): Field mushroom — ring present, Weeping widow — cobweb-like, ring remnants. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: flesh colour change, cap colour, smell.
Not sure? Identify by photoSide by side
| Characteristic | Field mushroom | Weeping widow |
|---|---|---|
| Edibility class | Field mushroom: Edible | Weeping widow: Inedible |
| Season | Field mushroom: Spring, Summer, Autumn | Weeping widow: Summer, Autumn |
| Use | Field mushroom: Culinary, Cook fresh, Freezing | Weeping widow: Not eaten |
| Cap colour | Field mushroom: White, Cream | Weeping widow: Brown, Orange, Rusty |
| Cap shape | Field mushroom: Convex, Flat | Weeping widow: Convex, Umbonate |
| Cap surface | Field mushroom: Dry, Smooth | Weeping widow: Fibrous, Scaly, Dry |
| Taste | Field mushroom: Mild | Weeping widow: — |
| Smell | Field mushroom: Pleasant, mushroomy, Anise | Weeping widow: Odourless |
| Flesh colour change | Field mushroom: Reddening | Weeping widow: No change |
| Stem | Field mushroom: Central, Solid | Weeping widow: Central, Hollow |
| Ring (veil) | Field mushroom: Ring present | Weeping widow: Cobweb-like, Ring remnants |
| Growth habit | Field mushroom: In groups, In rings | Weeping widow: Solitary, In groups, In clusters from one base |
Same in both: size, hymenophore, substrate, nutrition type.
When and where they meet
Together: July–November
What they look like
Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell
Cap
Field mushroom
Cap 5–15 cm across, spherical when young, then flat or slightly umbonate. White or slightly creamy, cracking in dry weather; fibrous scales may appear as it matures. The margin is inrolled at first, then straight.
Weeping widow
The cap is 3 to 10 cm across, occasionally 12 cm. It starts bell-shaped or hemispherical with an inrolled margin, then becomes convex to almost flat, usually with a low, broad bump.
The surface is dry and densely fibrous, woolly or finely scaly, with fibres radiating from the centre. It's tawny, ochre or yellow-brown, darker in the centre. A pale, ragged fringe of veil hangs from the edge and wears off with age.
Hymenophore
Field mushroom
Gills free (not reaching the stem) and crowded: soft pink at first, then bright pink, and chocolate-brown or blackish in mature mushrooms. Pink gills are a key safety feature that sets the field mushroom apart from poisonous species with white gills.
Weeping widow
The gills are attached and crowded, pale yellow-brown at first, then dark brown, mottled and almost black, with white edges. In damp weather droplets form along the edges, turn black with spores and leave dark spots. On young caps a cobweb-like veil covers the gills.
The spore print is black or blackish brown.
Stem
Field mushroom
Stem 4–8 cm tall, 1–2 cm thick, cylindrical, solid and straight. White. A firm membranous ring sits in the middle of the stem, a characteristic feature. No volva.
Weeping widow
The stem is 5 to 12 cm tall and 0.5 to 1.5 cm thick, whitish at the top and browner below, fibrous or scaly, hollow and brittle.
There's no true ring: near the top the veil leaves a fibrous ring zone that turns black with spores, like a pen line round the stem.
Flesh
Field mushroom
Flesh firm and white; it turns slightly pink when cut or stays unchanged. It doesn’t turn yellow (yellowing is a sign of poisonous species). The taste is pleasant and richly mushroomy.
Weeping widow
The flesh is thin, whitish to watery brown, browner at the stem base, and doesn't change colour when cut.
Smell
Field mushroom
A pronounced smell of anise and almond with mushroomy notes, making it one of the most aromatic wild mushrooms. Cooking intensifies the aroma, and it can dominate the dish.
Weeping widow
The smell is indistinct.
Related comparisons
Sources · 17
- [1]Index Fungorum
- [2]Species Fungorum
- [3]GBIF
- [4]Wikipedia (English)
- [5]Вікіпедія (українська)
- [6]Википедия (русская)
- [7]First Nature: Lacrymaria lacrymabunda, Weeping Widow
- [8]First Nature: Hebeloma crustuliniforme, Poisonpie
- [9]Kuo M., MushroomExpert: Lacrymaria velutina
- [10]Wild Food UK: Weeping Widow
- [11]The Foraging Course Company: Foraging guide, Weeping Widow
- [12]Mushroom Appreciation: Weeping Widow Mushroom
- [13]Watling R. Studies in the genera Lacrymaria and Panaeolus. Notes from the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh, 1979, 37(2), Watling R. (1979)
- [14]Wikipedia (de): Tränender Saumpilz
- [15]Шульга В. М. Світ грибів України: Лакримарія бархатиста
- [16]GBIF: знахідки Lacrymaria lacrymabunda в Україні
- [17]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)