Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

When a summer porcini is no longer worth picking

By Valeriia·Updated ·4 min read

Not every bolete belongs in the basket. An old mushroom is watery, maggoty and hard on the stomach. Here's how to tell a ripe one from an overripe one.

Antique botanical plate of summer porcini (Boletus reticulatus) at several stages and in section
Photo: Jacob Christian Schäffer · CC0 · source

Finding a bolete is only half the job. The other half is honestly judging whether it's worth taking. The summer bolete (Boletus reticulatus, in our catalogue the summer bolete) loses flavour with age, soaks up water and is almost always maggoty. A mushroom like that gets left in the forest, and not just out of squeamishness.

Telling a young, firm bolete from an overripe one is the mark of an experienced forager. Let's look at what to check, and why an old mushroom does more good left standing than in your basket.

How to recognise an old mushroom

A few details give away a bolete's age, and the most reliable is the underside of the cap. The tube layer, or sponge, works as a handy built-in ripeness gauge.

  • white sponge: a young mushroom, the best choice;
  • yellowish sponge: mature, still perfectly good;
  • greenish-yellow, soft, swollen sponge: an old mushroom, one you no longer take.

Other signs of age: a spongy cap that has opened out wide, a stem that has gone woody or, the other way round, soft, and a mushroom that feels noticeably heavier than its size because it has soaked up water. Press it with a finger: if the flesh springs back, it's young; if the dent stays, it's already overripe.

Maggots, the main reason to walk on by

Old boletes are almost always infested with larvae. The maggots often work their way up from below, through the stem, so the mushroom may look whole on the outside but be tunneled right through inside.

The check is simple: cut the mushroom lengthwise. A few tunnels in a young mushroom are no reason to throw it out; you just trim off the damaged part. But if the flesh is riddled with tunnels like a sponge, leave the mushroom in the forest. No dish will save it, and a mushroom like that won't do much for your appetite either.

Why an old mushroom is hard on the stomach

Even if an old bolete isn't maggoty, you shouldn't eat it. As it ages, protein breakdown products build up in it, and the flesh turns limp and watery.

Mushrooms are fairly heavy food as it is, and overripe ones are even harder to digest and can cause digestive upset. The same rule applies as with doubtful mushrooms: if you're not sure it's fresh, don't take it. Your health matters more than one extra mushroom in the basket.

By the way, don't confuse an overripe bolete with the bitter bolete. An old bolete spoils because of age, while the bitter bolete is always bitter, even when young. These are different problems with the same result: an inedible dish.

Why leave old mushrooms in the forest

An overripe bolete is no use to us, but the forest really needs it: old mushrooms are the ones that scatter the spores new mycelium grows from.

A mature bolete releases huge numbers of spores. And trampling does more harm than picking: in a 30-year Swiss study, cutting or twisting mushrooms did not reduce later crops, while trampling cut them by about a quarter for a while. That's why experienced foragers deliberately leave overripe ones standing: it's an investment in next season.

A few simple habits of a considerate forager:

  1. take only young and mature mushrooms, leave old ones where they are;
  2. don't kick over or trample what you're not taking;
  3. cut or twist the mushroom out carefully, without tearing the mycelium;
  4. don't dig up the litter looking for hidden mushrooms.

That way the spot will keep producing for years. And to come back exactly when the mushrooms are young and firm, keep an eye on the weather with our mushroom radar and head out roughly 10 to 14 days after a warm rain, while the boletes in deciduous forests are still fresh.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

How can you tell a porcini is old?

The easiest way is the underside of the cap: a greenish-yellow, soft sponge is a sign of an old mushroom. Age also shows in a spongy, wide cap, a limp or woody stem, and a mushroom that's heavier than it should be because it has soaked up water.

Can you eat an old bolete?

Better not. An old mushroom is watery, almost always maggoty and harder to digest, because protein breakdown products build up in it. It can upset your stomach, so leave a mushroom like that in the forest.

Why are old mushrooms almost always maggoty?

Because larvae move into a mushroom as it ages, often from below, through the stem. The longer a bolete stands, the more tunnels there are inside. Young mushrooms are clean, and that's exactly why they're prized.

What does a green cap underside on a bolete mean?

A greenish-yellow sponge means the mushroom is old. On a young one it's white, on a mature one yellowish. A soft green sponge tells you the mushroom is overripe and not worth taking.

Why leave old mushrooms in the forest?

Old boletes scatter the spores that new mycelium and future harvests grow from. Trampling the ground around them can also cut the next crop for a while. That's why foragers deliberately leave overripe mushrooms where they are.

How do you check a bolete for maggots?

Cut the mushroom lengthwise. A few tunnels in a young mushroom are nothing to worry about; just trim off the damaged part. But if the flesh is riddled with tunnels all the way through, leave the mushroom in the forest.

How is an old bolete different from a bitter bolete?

An old bolete spoils because of age: it turns watery and maggoty. The bitter bolete, on the other hand, is always bitter, even when young and clean. They're different mushrooms, but both make a dish inedible.

How do you cut a mushroom properly without harming the mycelium?

Carefully cut the stem near the base or gently twist the mushroom out without tearing up the litter. Don't dig up the ground or kick over old mushrooms, and the spot will keep producing for years.

Related articles