How to tell Agrocybe arvalis from Deadly fibrecap
Agrocybe arvalis and Deadly fibrecap look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Agrocybe arvalis is unknown, while Deadly fibrecap is deadly poisonous. The main visible difference: flesh colour change: Agrocybe arvalis — no change, Deadly fibrecap — reddening. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: stem, cap surface, cap colour. If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.
Not sure? Identify by photoSide by side
| Characteristic | Agrocybe arvalis | Deadly fibrecap |
|---|---|---|
| Edibility class | Agrocybe arvalis: Unknown | Deadly fibrecap: Deadly poisonous |
| Season | Agrocybe arvalis: Summer, Autumn | Deadly fibrecap: Spring, Summer |
| Size | Agrocybe arvalis: Very small (<3 cm) | Deadly fibrecap: Medium (5–15 cm) |
| Cap colour | Agrocybe arvalis: Brown | Deadly fibrecap: White, Cream, Red, Pink |
| Cap surface | Agrocybe arvalis: Smooth | Deadly fibrecap: Fibrous |
| Taste | Agrocybe arvalis: Unknown | Deadly fibrecap: Mild |
| Smell | Agrocybe arvalis: Odourless | Deadly fibrecap: Fruity, Pleasant |
| Flesh colour change | Agrocybe arvalis: No change | Deadly fibrecap: Reddening |
| Stem | Agrocybe arvalis: Rooting | Deadly fibrecap: Central |
| Substrate | Agrocybe arvalis: Soil, On wood | Deadly fibrecap: Soil |
| Nutrition type | Agrocybe arvalis: Saprotroph | Deadly fibrecap: Mycorrhizal |
| Partner trees | Agrocybe arvalis: — | Deadly fibrecap: Oak, Beech, Hornbeam, Hazel |
| Growth habit | Agrocybe arvalis: Solitary, In groups | Deadly fibrecap: In groups |
Same in both: use, cap shape, hymenophore.
DEADLY POISONOUS
Eating it can cause death. Do not pick it and do not taste it.
Toxin: muscarine, in an exceptionally high concentration, many times more than in the fly agaric. Symptoms start 15 minutes to 2 hours after eating. It's a severe form of the classic muscarine syndrome: heavy salivation, profuse sweating (clothes soaked through), tearing, runny nose, constricted pupils (miosis), bronchospasm with a feeling of suffocation, bradycardia (slow heartbeat) down to about 30-35 bpm in severe cases, a drop in blood pressure, nausea, vomiting, intestinal cramps, diarrhoea. Severe cases bring collapse, pulmonary oedema and cardiac arrest. Fatal cases have been documented among healthy adults. The antidote is atropine (intravenously in hospital, with ECG and blood pressure monitoring). If you suspect poisoning, call 112 (999 in the UK) immediately. Keep any leftover mushrooms and vomit. The sooner the antidote is given, the better the outlook. Without help within 2-4 hours there is a real risk of death.
If you suspect poisoning, call your local emergency number (112 in the EU, 999 in the UK) immediately
When and where they meet
Together: July–October
What they look like
Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell
Cap
Agrocybe arvalis
Small, 1–4 cm across, bell-shaped when young, then flat with a broad, low bump. Ochre-brown, drying to pale yellow-brown and almost white at the edge. The surface is smooth to slightly wrinkled and shiny, a little greasy in wet weather, when faint lines show at the margin.
Deadly fibrecap
The cap is 2.5-8 cm across, hemispherical to convex when young, with a broad central umbo, and opens out with age. The surface is silky and shiny, with fine radial fibres and flattened scales. It starts out whitish, cream or ivory, and with age and handling it slowly turns red: pinkish at first, then brick-carmine or cinnamon-red. The reddening shows most along the margin and wherever the mushroom is damaged. This is the key identification feature.
Hymenophore
Agrocybe arvalis
The gills are attached to the stem, white to yellowish at first, then with lilac tones, and finally dark greyish-brown. The spore print is rusty brown.
Deadly fibrecap
The gills are fairly crowded and notched where they meet the stem. They're whitish-pinkish when young, turning olive-brown to brick-brown with age. The spore print is olive-brown or tobacco-coloured, typical of the whole genus Inocybe.
Stem
Agrocybe arvalis
Slender, usually 3–10 cm tall and 1.5–5 mm thick, fibrous, paler at the top and covered in a fine whitish powder. It roots into the soil, where long whitish cords lead to a sclerotium, a firm, tuber-like knot that's brown-black outside and white inside. No ring, no volva.
Deadly fibrecap
The stem is 3-10 cm tall and 0.5-1.5 cm thick, cylindrical or slightly widening toward the base. It's whitish to cream, with a pink or reddish-brick tinge (especially lower down). Like the cap, it turns red with age and handling. The surface has lengthwise fibres, and there's no ring. The flesh of the stem is firm.
Flesh
Agrocybe arvalis
The flesh is thin and brittle, cream, and shows no characteristic change when cut.
Deadly fibrecap
The flesh is thick and white; when cut, it slowly turns red (not right away, and not in every mushroom), especially in the lower part of the stem. This is an important way to tell it from most Agaricus mushrooms, whose flesh either doesn't change colour or turns yellow (though some wood mushrooms, such as Agaricus silvaticus, also redden, so check the gills and spore print too). The fresh flesh smells and tastes pleasant, fruity and sweetish, and that's exactly what makes it so treacherous.
Smell
Agrocybe arvalis
Faint, sometimes mealy.
Deadly fibrecap
Sweet and fruity, with notes of ripe pears or apples. That's unusual for the genus Inocybe, which usually smells spermatic or musty. An appealing aroma, plus a reddening white cap, plus the very season when edible white mushrooms are being picked: the perfect trap for a beginner forager. Never rely on smell to identify this species.
Related comparisons
Sources · 12
- [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
- [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
- [3]MycoBank Database
- [4]Index Fungorum
- [5]GBIF
- [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
- [7]Sánchez L., Rubio Casas L. Agrocybe arvalis, una interesante especie localizada en el Montseny. Revista Catalana de Micologia 37, 2016
- [8]Mycocharentes (Tanchaud 2022): Agrocybe arvalis
- [9]Wikipedia: Agrocybe arvalis
- [10]Commanster: Agrocybe arvalis
- [11]Bioinfo (UK): Agrocybe arvalis
- [12]Tox Info Suisse: Muscarin-Syndrom