Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

How to tell Chanterelle from Brown rollrim

Brown rollrim is deadly poisonous

Chanterelle and Brown rollrim look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Chanterelle is edible, while Brown rollrim is deadly poisonous. The main visible difference: hymenophore: Chanterelle — ridged, Brown rollrim — gilled. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: flesh colour change, cap surface, cap colour. If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

ChanterelleBrown rollrim
Comparison of characteristics: Chanterelle and Brown rollrim
Edibility classChanterelle: EdibleBrown rollrim: Deadly poisonous
UseChanterelle: Culinary, Cook fresh, Freezing, SaltingBrown rollrim: Not eaten
Cap colourChanterelle: Yellow, OrangeBrown rollrim: Brown, Olive
Cap surfaceChanterelle: SmoothBrown rollrim: Dry, Velvety, Slimy
TasteChanterelle: Peppery, MildBrown rollrim: Unknown
SmellChanterelle: FruityBrown rollrim: Odourless
Flesh colour changeChanterelle: No changeBrown rollrim: Darkens
HymenophoreChanterelle: RidgedBrown rollrim: Gilled
SubstrateChanterelle: Soil, Forest litterBrown rollrim: Soil
Partner treesChanterelle: Beech, Oak, PineBrown rollrim: Birch, Aspen, Oak, Spruce, Pine

Same in both: season, size, cap shape, stem, nutrition type, growth habit.

When and where they meet

Together: August–October

Their seasons overlap: August–October. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: deciduous forest, mixed forest, conifer forest.

Chanterelle

Fruiting season

June – October

Brown rollrim

Fruiting season

August – November

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Chanterelle

The cap is 3–10 cm across. Young caps are convex with an inrolled margin; with age they flatten out and become distinctly funnel-shaped, the margin turning up and going wavy.

It's bright yellow-orange or egg-yolk yellow, sometimes paler — from light ochre to almost white in shady spots. The surface is smooth and dry, faintly velvety, like apricot skin. In mature mushrooms the cap often flows into the stem with no clear transition, as if the whole thing were carved from one piece of ochre wax.

Brown rollrim

Cap 4–15 cm across, convex when young, then depressed and funnel-shaped. Yellow brown, ochre brown, rusty or olive brown, felty at first, smoother with age, sticky in wet weather. The felty margin stays rolled under for a long time, which is where the name comes from.

Hymenophore

Chanterelle

The underside is the chanterelle's key identifying feature. Instead of gills or tubes, it has forked ridges (false gills) that run a long way down the stem. They're the same colour as the cap: an even yellow-orange or egg-yolk yellow.

The ridges are thick, widely spaced and linked by cross-veins, so together they look like a three-dimensional net. They don't change colour when pressed. This is what makes the true chanterelle easy to tell from the false chanterelle, which has regular, thin gills.

Brown rollrim

Gills crowded and thin, pale ochre to yellowish brown, running down the stem. They turn rusty brown almost at once when pressed and peel away from the cap easily. Spore print brown, from rusty to olive brown.

Stem

Chanterelle

The stem is short and sturdy: 3–7 cm tall and 1–3 cm thick. It's cylindrical, often tapering toward the base, and often flattened, bent or slightly off-centre. The surface is smooth and dry, the same yellow-orange as the cap or a little lighter.

There's no ring and no volva — chanterelles belong to a family with no veils. The stem feels springy, dense and solid, with no hollows. Several mushrooms often grow from one shared base.

Brown rollrim

Stem 4–10 cm tall, 1–2.5 cm thick, short, firm and central, cylindrical or tapering downward, the colour of the cap or a little paler. It darkens when bruised. No ring and no volva.

Flesh

Chanterelle

The flesh is dense, cream or pale yellow when fresh. Cut or bruised, it barely changes colour, only yellowing slightly over time. That's an important clue: a true chanterelle doesn't turn blue or red.

Fresh flesh tastes mild, with a light peppery bite that's strongest in the cap. Older mushrooms get a bit tough and fibrous but keep their aroma.

Brown rollrim

Flesh pale yellowish to brownish, firm in young mushrooms and softer later, turning reddish brown when cut. There's no milk, which helps separate it from milkcaps.

Smell

Chanterelle

Fresh chanterelles have a faint but pleasant smell: warm, fruity and apricot-like, sometimes with notes of dried fruit and a faint hint of pepper. Some people pick up dried apricots or sun-dried cherries in it.

Cut one open and the aroma gets deeper and richer. Dried chanterelles keep a light fruity note but lose their freshness, which is why they're rarely dried and more often pickled or frozen fresh.

Brown rollrim

No distinctive smell, at most a mild mushroomy one. Nothing about it warns you of the danger.

Related comparisons

Sources · 20

  • [1]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [2]GBIF
  • [3]First Nature: Cantharellus cibarius, Chanterelle
  • [4]Wikipedia (en): Cantharellus cibarius
  • [5]Chanterelle (Cantharellus cibarius), Woodland Trust
  • [6]Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund: Normlisten 2024 (2024)
  • [7]First Nature: Cortinarius rubellus, Deadly Webcap
  • [8]Wikipedia (en): Cortinarius rubellus
  • [9]Poisonous mushrooms, Helsenorge, Norwegian Poison Information
  • [10]Omphalotus olearius, First Nature
  • [11]Nutritional, Nutraceutical, and Medicinal Potential of Cantharellus cibarius Fr.: A Comprehensive Review, Food Science & Nutrition
  • [12]Repeated fruiting of Japanese golden chanterelle in pot culture with host seedlings (Ogawa et al., Mycorrhiza 2019), PubMed (2019)
  • [13]first-nature: Paxillus involutus
  • [14]Mushrooms traded as food, Nordic Council of Ministers
  • [15]Funga Nordica: Paxillus (Knudsen & Taylor 2008)
  • [16]Stöver A. et al. Fatal Immunohaemolysis after the Consumption of the Poison Pax Mushroom. Diagnostics, 2019, 9(4): 130, Stöver A., Haberl B., Helmreich C. et al. (2019)
  • [17]Winkelmann M. et al. Severe hemolysis caused by antibodies against the mushroom Paxillus involutus and its therapy by plasma exchange. Klinische Wochenschrift, 1986, Winkelmann M., Stangel W., Schedel I., Grabensee B. (1986)
  • [18]Winkelmann M. et al. Fatal immunohaemolytic anaemia after eating the mushroom Paxillus involutus. Dtsch Med Wochenschr, 1982, Winkelmann M., Borchard F., Stangel W., Grabensee B. (1982)
  • [19]Foraging guide: brown rollrim
  • [20]Winkelmann M. et al. 1982: Fatal immunohaemolytic anaemia after eating the mushroom Paxillus involutus