Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

How to tell Charcoal burner from Death cap

How they differ, how to recognize them and which is more dangerous — a mushroom comparison

Warning: Death cap(Amanita phalloides)

The short answer

Charcoal burner and Death cap look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Charcoal burner is edible, while Death cap is deadly poisonous. The main visible difference: use: Charcoal burner — cook fresh, pickling, drying, Death cap — not eaten. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: cap color, cap shape, cap surface. If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.

Death cap (Amanita phalloides)

Death cap

Amanita phalloides

Deadly poisonousExpert-verified
Charcoal burner (Russula cyanoxantha)

Charcoal burner

Russula cyanoxantha

EdibleExpert-verified

📊 Comparing characteristics

⚠ Highlighted rows are the key differences between the edible and the dangerous mushroom

Comparison of characteristics: Death cap and Charcoal burner
⚠ Edibility class

Death cap

Deadly poisonous

Charcoal burner

Edible
Season

Death cap

SummerAutumn

Charcoal burner

SummerAutumn
⚠ Use

Death cap

Not eaten

Charcoal burner

Cook freshPicklingDrying
Size

Death cap

Medium (5–15 cm)

Charcoal burner

Medium (5–15 cm)
⚠ Cap color

Death cap

GreenOlivePale yellow

Charcoal burner

VioletOliveBrown
⚠ Cap shape

Death cap

ConvexFlat

Charcoal burner

Depressed
⚠ Cap surface

Death cap

SmoothFibrous

Charcoal burner

Smooth
⚠ Taste

Death cap

Neutral taste

Charcoal burner

Mild
⚠ Smell

Death cap

HoneyNeutral

Charcoal burner

Pleasant
Flesh color change

Death cap

No change

Charcoal burner

No change
Hymenophore

Death cap

Gilled

Charcoal burner

Gilled
⚠ Stem

Death cap

CentralBulbous

Charcoal burner

Central
⚠ Ring (veil)

Death cap

Ring present

Charcoal burner

No ring
⚠ Volva

Death cap

Volva present

Charcoal burner

No volva
Substrate

Death cap

Soil

Charcoal burner

Soil
Nutrition type

Death cap

Mycorrhizal

Charcoal burner

Mycorrhizal
⚠ Partner trees

Death cap

OakBeechBirch

Charcoal burner

BeechOakHornbeamBirchSpruce

📅 Seasonality

Death cap

Fruiting season

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec

July – October

Charcoal burner

Fruiting season

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec

July – October

🔬 Morphology

Cap

Death cap

The death cap's cap is 5–15 cm across. In young mushrooms it is hemispherical, later becoming flat and spread out.

The color varies from olive green and yellowish green to grayish and almost white — which is what makes identification tricky. The surface is smooth, slightly slimy in wet weather, with a characteristic radial pattern of darker fibers spreading from the center. The cap margin is even, without striations.

Charcoal burner

Cap 5-15 cm across, when young hemispherical, with age becoming flattened with a slightly depressed center. The cap skin is smooth, slimy in wet weather, dry and matte in dry weather, peeling 2/3 of the way to the center. Color very variable — violet-blue, green-gray, olive-violet, brownish violet with yellow patches. In a single cluster of fruiting bodies you'll often see caps in different shades. Deeper in the center, paler toward the margin, with fine radial grooves.

Hymenophore

Death cap

The hymenophore is lamellate. The gills are crowded, thin and free — not attached to the stem. In both young and mature mushrooms they stay pure white — this is a critical diagnostic feature.

Not a hint of pink, cream or ochre, as in true Agaricus mushrooms. The gap between the gills and the stem is clearly defined. The veil is white and membranous, completely covering the hymenophore in young specimens.

Charcoal burner

Gilled hymenophore — gills adnate or free from the stem, partly forked near the stem, moderately crowded. UNIQUE FEATURE: the gills are flexible and springy and don't break when pressed — run your finger over them and they bend and spring back (unlike all other brittlegills, whose gills are brittle and crumbly). Color pure white to creamy white. Spore print white.

Stem

Death cap

The stem is slender, 7–15 cm tall and 1–2 cm thick. Cylindrical, widening at the base into a characteristic club-shaped bulb wrapped in a membranous sack-like volva — the main diagnostic feature.

The color is whitish green, often with a snakeskin pattern of faint bands. In the upper third there's a well-developed, hanging white ring with remnants of the veil. The surface below the ring is faintly scaly.

Charcoal burner

Stem 5-10 cm tall, 1.5-3 cm thick, firm, fleshy, cylindrical, with a small cavity in old specimens. Color white to cream, sometimes with a faint violet tinge toward the base. Surface smooth with fine lengthwise wrinkles. No ring, no volva.

Flesh

Death cap

The flesh is white and doesn't change color when cut — and that's the treacherous part: none of the safety signs foragers are used to relying on work here. The flesh is thin and brittle in the cap, fleshy at the base of the stem.

It doesn't change color on contact with air, neither after a minute nor after an hour. No "lovely white flesh" should reassure you — it's precisely in the white flesh of the death cap that the concentration of amanitins is highest.

Charcoal burner

Flesh firm, fleshy, pure white, does not change color when cut — a characteristic of the species. Smell faint, pleasant, fruity-mushroomy, taste mild, sweetish and nutty, with no bitterness or acridity.

Smell

Death cap

The smell of a fresh mushroom is faint and hard to notice; in young specimens it's almost absent. Mature ones develop a slight sickly-sweet note, like wilted honey or stale dough.

This aroma isn't distinct enough to warn an inexperienced forager. Like other poisonous amanitas (the fly agaric, the panther cap), the death cap has only a faint, indistinct smell that gives no warning — yet another treacherous trait. A stronger odor appears only in rotting specimens.

Charcoal burner

Faint, pleasant, fruity-mushroomy, neutral.

📍 Habitats

Death cap

Deciduous forestMixed forest

Charcoal burner

Deciduous forestMixed forest

👀 Similar mushrooms — don't mix them up!

❓ Frequently asked questions

Can Charcoal burner and Death cap be mixed up?
Yes. These species look alike, and Death cap is deadly poisonous, so a mistake is dangerous. Pay attention to the use, cap color, cap shape.
How to tell Charcoal burner from Death cap?
The main differences: use: Charcoal burner — cook fresh, pickling, drying, Death cap — not eaten; cap color: Charcoal burner — violet, olive, brown, Death cap — green, olive, pale yellow; cap shape: Charcoal burner — depressed, Death cap — convex, flat. As for edibility: Charcoal burner is edible, Death cap is deadly poisonous. The full table of characteristics is higher up on this page.
Which is more dangerous — Charcoal burner or Death cap?
More dangerous: Death cap, which is deadly poisonous. Charcoal burner is edible. If you have even the slightest doubt, don't pick the mushroom.
Is Death cap edible?
Death cap — deadly poisonous. It must not be picked or eaten.
When do Charcoal burner and Death cap grow?
Charcoal burner — July–October; Death cap — July–October. Their seasons overlap, so be especially careful.

Sources

  • [1]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [2]MycoBank Database
  • [3]GBIF
  • [4]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [5]Index Fungorum
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine