Yellow stagshorn or Scarlet caterpillarclub
Yellow stagshorn and Scarlet caterpillarclub are similar species that can be mixed up while foraging. The main visible difference: stem: Yellow stagshorn — rooting, Scarlet caterpillarclub — central. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: substrate.
Not sure? Identify by photoSide by side
| Characteristic | Yellow stagshorn | Scarlet caterpillarclub |
|---|---|---|
| Use | Yellow stagshorn: Not eaten | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Medicinal |
| Size | Yellow stagshorn: Small (up to 5 cm) | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Very small (<3 cm), Small (up to 5 cm) |
| Colour | Yellow stagshorn: Yellow, Orange | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Orange, Red |
| Cap shape | Yellow stagshorn: — | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Cylindrical |
| Cap surface | Yellow stagshorn: — | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Dry |
| Flesh colour change | Yellow stagshorn: No change | Scarlet caterpillarclub: — |
| Hymenophore | Yellow stagshorn: — | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Smooth |
| Stem | Yellow stagshorn: Rooting | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Central |
| Substrate | Yellow stagshorn: Dead wood, On wood | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Soil, Moss, Forest litter |
| Nutrition type | Yellow stagshorn: Saprotroph | Scarlet caterpillarclub: Parasite |
| Partner trees | Yellow stagshorn: Spruce, Pine, Fir | Scarlet caterpillarclub: — |
Same in both: edibility class, season, smell, growth habit.
When and where they meet
Together: August–November
Their seasons overlap: August–November. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: conifer forest, mixed forest.
What they look like
Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell
Cap
Yellow stagshorn
There's no cap. The fruit body is bushy: from a short base it forks into slender branches a few millimetres thick, with pointed, often forked tips, 3 to 6 cm tall and occasionally 10 cm. Small specimens can be simple spikes forked at the top.
The colour ranges from egg-yolk yellow to orange-yellow, with a paler, whitish-yellow base. It reddens as it dries. In wet weather the surface is greasy and sticky.
Scarlet caterpillarclub
There is no cap. Its place is taken by the head, the fertile upper part of the club: 0.5–4 cm long and a few millimetres up to 1 cm thick. It's slightly swollen, cylindrical or a little flattened, and only rarely forked.
The colour is bright orange, scarlet orange or orange yellow. The surface is dry and finely pimply: each pimple is the opening of a tiny fruiting chamber. This rough head is what separates it from the smooth orange clubs of Clavulinopsis.
Hymenophore
Yellow stagshorn
There are no gills or pores: the spores form over almost the whole surface of the branches except the base.
The spore print is whitish to pale yellow.
Scarlet caterpillarclub
There are no gills, tubes or spines. The spores ripen in tiny flask-shaped chambers (perithecia) sunk into the surface of the head and escape through their openings, which is why the head looks pimply.
The spores are thread-like with many cross walls and break into small part-spores 2–4.5 × 1–1.5 µm. The spore print is white. You don't need a microscope in the field: the pimply head and the pupa at the base are enough.
Stem
Yellow stagshorn
There's no separate stem. The short, paler base roots deep into the wood.
Scarlet caterpillarclub
The stem is 1–3 cm long and about 1–1.5 mm thick, often slightly wavy, paler than the head, pale orange and smooth. There is no ring and no volva.
At the bottom the stem narrows and runs down into soil or moss to a moth pupa, more rarely a caterpillar. The pupa is mummified, filled with the fungus and wrapped in white mycelium. To see it, gently loosen the soil around the base with your fingers rather than pulling the club out.
Flesh
Yellow stagshorn
The flesh is springy, rubbery-gelatinous and cartilaginous, bending rather than snapping. It turns hard when dry.
Scarlet caterpillarclub
The flesh is thin, whitish to pale orange and watery, with a thin firmer outer layer. There is no milk. Colour change on cutting isn't described in the sources.
Smell
Yellow stagshorn
The smell and taste aren't distinctive.
Scarlet caterpillarclub
The smell is faint and indistinct, and field guides don't give one. It doesn't help with identification: look for the pimply head and the pupa in the soil instead.
Related comparisons
Sources · 32
- [1]Index Fungorum
- [2]Species Fungorum
- [3]GBIF
- [4]Wikipedia (English)
- [5]Вікіпедія (українська)
- [6]Википедия (русская)
- [7]First Nature: Calocera viscosa, Yellow Stagshorn
- [8]First Nature: Calocera cornea, Small Stagshorn
- [9]First Nature: Clavulinopsis corniculata, Meadow Coral
- [10]First Nature: Ramaria stricta, Upright Coral
- [11]Wikipedia (de): Klebriger Hörnling
- [12]Shirouzu T., Hirose D., Tokumasu S. Taxonomic study of the Japanese Dacrymycetes. Persoonia, 2009, 23: 16–34, Shirouzu T., Hirose D., Tokumasu S. (2009)
- [13]Світ грибів України (gribi.net.ua): Калоцера клейка
- [14]GBIF: знахідки Calocera viscosa в Україні
- [15]Wikigrib: Калоцера клейкая
- [16]iNaturalist Ukraine
- [17]Вікіпедія: Офіційний перелік регіонально рідкісних рослин Київської області
- [18]First Nature: Cordyceps militaris, Scarlet Caterpillarclub
- [19]MushroomExpert: Cordyceps militaris
- [20]Naturalis, Linnaeus NG: Cordyceps militaris
- [21]NatureSpot: Yellow Club (Clavulinopsis helvola)
- [22]Wikipedia (English): Ophiocordyceps sinensis
- [23]Фокшей С.І. Знахідка Cordyceps militaris (Cordycipitaceae) у Національному природному парку «Гуцульщина». Український ботанічний журнал, 2017, 74(3): 284–287, Фокшей С.І. (2017)
- [24]Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, About Herbs: Cordyceps
- [25]Zhang H.W. et al. Cordyceps sinensis (a traditional Chinese medicine) for treating chronic kidney disease. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2014, CD008353, Zhang H.W. et al. (2014)
- [26]Kang H.J. et al. Cordyceps militaris enhances cell-mediated immunity in healthy Korean men. Journal of Medicinal Food, 2015, 18(10): 1164–1172, Kang H.J. et al. (2015)
- [27]Hirsch K.R. et al. Cordyceps militaris improves tolerance to high-intensity exercise after acute and chronic supplementation. Journal of Dietary Supplements, 2017, 14(1): 42–53, Hirsch K.R., Smith-Ryan A.E., Roelofs E.J., Trexler E.T., Mock M.G. (2017)
- [28]Wu T.N. et al. Lead poisoning caused by contaminated Cordyceps, a Chinese herbal medicine: two case reports. Science of the Total Environment, 1996, 182: 193–195, Wu T.N. et al. (1996)
- [29]Zhou L. et al. Bioaccessibility and risk assessment of heavy metals, and analysis of arsenic speciation in Cordyceps sinensis. Chinese Medicine, 2018, 13: 40, Zhou L. et al. (2018)
- [30]Jędrejko K. et al. Cordyceps militaris: fruiting bodies, mycelium, and supplements: valuable component of daily diet. Antioxidants, 2022, 11(10): 1861, Jędrejko K. et al. (2022)
- [31]NutraIngredients: Cordyceps ‘boom’ on the horizon as novel food status of S. hepiali clarified (29.08.2025)
- [32]ZHAW: EU: Mycelium und Fruchtkörper von Cordyceps militaris (L.) als neuartiges Lebensmittel eingestuft (07.03.2025)