Among the moss boletes and their close kin, two often get mentioned in the same breath: Xerocomus ferrugineus (Xerocomus ferrugineus) and the bay bolete (Boletus badius). Both have brown-chestnut caps and love coniferous forests.
But they're noticeably different, especially in taste. Here's how to tell them apart, why the bay bolete is valued so much more highly and where to find both.
Xerocomus ferrugineus
Xerocomus ferrugineus is a close relative of the suede bolete, and the two are easy to mix up.
- Cap brownish chestnut, rusty brown, dry and velvety.
- Tube layer yellowish, with large pores.
- Stem even, thinner than the cap, often ribbed and sometimes with a net-like pattern.
- Flesh whitish or yellowish; when cut, it turns blue only faintly, if at all.
Its darker, chestnut-coloured cap helps tell it from the suede bolete, but its whitish flesh, which barely changes colour when cut, is a more reliable sign. It's edible, but like all moss boletes it has softer, more watery flesh.
Bay bolete
The bay bolete is noticeably more substantial. Many foragers don't count it as a moss bolete at all, since its taste and firmness are closer to porcini.
- Cap chestnut-brown, dark brown, slightly slimy in wet weather, fairly large and fleshy.
- Tube layer yellowish green, turns distinctly blue when pressed.
- Stem thicker and sturdier than in moss boletes, brownish, with no net pattern.
- Flesh firm, whitish; when cut, it blues only slightly, often barely visibly.
It's the firm, dense flesh and pores that bruise vividly blue that set the bay bolete apart from the more modest moss boletes.
How they differ
In short, the difference is in size, firmness and taste.
- Size and flesh. The bay bolete is bigger and fleshier; Xerocomus ferrugineus is smaller and softer.
- Bruising. The bay bolete's pores turn blue clearly and quickly when pressed, its flesh only slightly; Xerocomus ferrugineus barely turns blue.
- Taste. The bay bolete is fragrant and firm, close to porcini; the moss bolete is more modest.
That's why the bay bolete is valued much more highly in the basket. But both are edible, and either one is a nice find.
Where and when to look for them
Both mushrooms love coniferous and mixed forests, especially pine forests.
- in coniferous forests and pine forests on mossy patches;
- in mixed forests, where pine grows alongside birch and oak;
- sometimes in deciduous forests, on forest edges and in clearings.
Their season runs from summer to late autumn. The bay bolete is at its best in autumn: firm and clean, and it stays sound for a long time as it grows.
Lookalikes to rule out are the inedible bitter bolete (pores turning pink, a dark net on the stem), the poisonous scarlet-stemmed bolete (Caloboletus calopus: yellow pores, but a red, netted stem and a pale cap) and the inedible peppery bolete with reddish pores. To know when to head out, check our mushroom radar: it shows when moisture and warmth line up for mushrooms to appear.
Mushrooms in this article
Frequently asked questions
How does Xerocomus ferrugineus differ from the bay bolete?
Xerocomus ferrugineus is smaller, with softer flesh that barely turns blue. The bay bolete is bigger and fleshier, with firm flesh and pores that turn distinctly blue when pressed, and it tastes closer to porcini.
Is the bay bolete a moss bolete?
The bay bolete is close to the moss boletes, and some foragers include it in that group. But its firmness and taste are closer to porcini, so it's usually treated separately.
How do you recognise Xerocomus ferrugineus?
By its brownish-chestnut, dry, velvety cap, yellowish pores and even, thin stem that is often ribbed, sometimes with a net-like pattern. When cut, it barely turns blue, which sets it apart from the bay bolete.
Why is the bay bolete valued more highly than moss boletes?
Because it's fleshier, more fragrant and firmer, close to porcini. Moss boletes are more modest, with softer, watery flesh.
Where do Xerocomus ferrugineus and the bay bolete grow?
Mostly in coniferous and mixed forests, in pine forests on mossy patches. They sometimes turn up in deciduous forests.
Why does the bay bolete turn blue when cut?
It's a natural reaction: the flesh oxidises on contact with air. In the bay bolete it shows most on the pores, while the cut flesh blues only slightly; it it's completely harmless and disappears with cooking.
When should you pick the bay bolete?
The season runs from summer to late autumn. The bay bolete is at its best in autumn, when it's firm and clean and stays sound for a long time as it grows.
Do these mushrooms have poisonous lookalikes?
Yes, a few. The inedible peppery bolete has reddish pores. The bitter bolete, inedible and known for stomach upsets, has pores that turn pink and a dark net on the stem. The poisonous scarlet-stemmed bolete (Caloboletus calopus) has yellow pores too, but a red, netted stem. Identify by the pores, the stem and the cap, never by taste.
Related articles
SafetyMushrooms in your lawn and garden: why they appear, are they dangerous and what to do
Mushrooms in a lawn rarely harm the grass, but a few lawn species are deadly. Why they pop up, which ones you'…
November 14, 2026·9 min
Growing mushroomsMushroom logs and stumps: growing oyster and shiitake outdoors
Oyster mushrooms on logs and stumps are easier than you'd think, often fruiting in the first autumn. Shiitake…
November 6, 2026·8 min
Growing mushroomsHow to grow oyster mushrooms at home: block, bag and straw
You can grow oyster mushrooms at home from a ready block, or in a bag of straw heated in hot water. Step by st…
November 6, 2026·7 min
Xerocomus ferrugineus
Bay bolete
Suede bolete