Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Stinking brittlegill: is it edible, and why we advise against it

By Valeriia·Updated ·2 min read

Mushrooms in this article

The stinking brittlegill, or valui (“bychok”), is a common brittlegill that people once salted in bulk. We list it as poisonous. Here's how to recognise it, where it grows and why salting does not make it safe.

Stinking brittlegill (Russula foetens): several specimens, one turned to show its gills
Photo: Nina Filippova · CC BY 4.0 · source

The stinking brittlegill (valui, or “bychok” and “kulak”, “fist”, in folk speech) is a mushroom every village forager used to know: it was salted in bulk for winter. A relative of the brittlegills, it has a distinctively round cap and a bitter taste. People pick it less often today, but this common mushroom is worth knowing.

Let's look at how to recognise the stinking brittlegill, where it grows and why we advise against eating it, even salted.

How to recognise the stinking brittlegill

  • Cap: round in young mushrooms (hence “fist”), later spreading out with a dip in the centre; yellow-brown, slimy when wet, with a grooved margin.
  • Gills whitish, yellowing with age, often with clear droplets that leave rusty-brown spots.
  • Stem white, swollen, becoming hollow and browning with age.
  • Flesh white, brittle, with a sharp unpleasant smell and a bitter, burning taste.

The sharp, unpleasant smell and the grooved cap margin are what give the stinking brittlegill away among other brittlegills.

A young brittlegill from the stinking brittlegill (Russula foetens) group in leaf litter: firm creamy-ochre cap with a grooved margin pressed to the white stem
A firm little 'fist' like this, with a grooved cap margin, is what sets the Russula foetens group apart from other brittlegills. · Photo:

Where and when it grows

The stinking brittlegill grows in broadleaf and mixed forests, under trees such as beech, spruce, oak or birch, often in damp spots. The season runs from summer into autumn, often in large groups. It's one of the most common forest mushrooms of midsummer.

Is it edible?

We advise against eating it: in our catalogue the stinking brittlegill is poisonous. Vienna's mushroom advice service names it as poisonous, and the German Mycological Society (DGfM) counts acrid and bitter brittlegills among poisonous mushrooms. In Eastern Europe it was traditionally soaked for days, boiled and salted. That reduces the bitterness but does not make it safe, so we give no recipe for it.

The same young Russula foetens group mushroom seen from slightly above: a rounded creamy-yellow cap flecked with soil among dry leaves and grass blades
The cap is still rounded and firm: if you pick these for salting, look for young ones just like this. · Photo:

What to watch out for

  • Don't eat it. It is poisonous and can upset the stomach; neither soaking, boiling nor salting makes it safe.
  • Young ones. A round, firm cap is the sign of a young stinking brittlegill.
  • Don't confuse it with the death cap. Always check young whitish mushrooms: the death cap has a bulb and a sac-like volva at the stem base, which the stinking brittlegill doesn't.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

What is valui?

It's the stinking brittlegill, a common forest mushroom of the brittlegill genus, called “bychok” or “kulak” in folk speech, with a round yellow-brown cap and a bitter taste. We list it as poisonous.

Is the stinking brittlegill edible?

We advise against eating it: we list the stinking brittlegill as poisonous, as Vienna's mushroom advice service does. Traditionally it's soaked, boiled and salted, but that does not make it safe.

Why is valui called “bychok” or “kulak” (fist)?

Because the round, tight cap of a young mushroom looks like a fist. It's the most noticeable thing about it.

Where and when does the stinking brittlegill grow?

In broadleaf and mixed forests under trees such as beech, spruce, oak or birch, in damp spots, from summer into autumn, often in large groups.

Does soaking make the stinking brittlegill safe?

No. Long soaking and boiling only reduce the bitterness, which is why they were the traditional first steps before salting. The mushroom stays poisonous, so we advise against eating it.

How do you tell the stinking brittlegill from other brittlegills?

By its round cap, sharp unpleasant smell and grooved cap margin. Most other brittlegills smell weaker. Taste is no test: don't put a wild mushroom in your mouth to check it.

Can the stinking brittlegill poison you?

Yes, it can upset your stomach, eaten fresh or after soaking and salting alike, so we advise against eating it.

Can the stinking brittlegill be made safe by cooking?

No. In Eastern Europe it was traditionally soaked, boiled and salted, but none of this makes it safe, so we give no recipe and advise against eating it.

Related articles

Sources

  • Russula foetens on Wikipedia.