Support MycoNote →

MycoNote
Want to find

Photo: Alan Rockefeller · CC BY-SA 2.5 · source

Edible✓ Checked by an expert

Crab brittlegillRussula xerampelina

SeasonJuly – October

Passport

Hymenophore
Gilled
Cap colour
Red
Size
Medium (5–15 cm)

✓ Edible

Most often confused with: Bloody brittlegill (inedible).

Quick answers

When does it appear? Europe

Jul — Oct

Active months: July, August, September, October.

How to recognise it? Three signs

Description

The crab brittlegill (Russula xerampelina), also called the "herring brittlegill" or the "shrimp brittlegill", is one of the most distinctive and tastiest edible brittlegills, with a clear smell of shrimp, smoked herring or fish. The Latin epithet xerampelina comes from the Greek for "dried-wine coloured", a nod to the wine-red cap. The Ukrainian folk name "vonyucha" ("stinky") can be misleading: the smell isn't unpleasant, just characteristically "fishy and briny", and experienced foragers actually look for it, because it points unmistakably to the crab brittlegill group. Strictly speaking, this isn't one species but several close ones (mycologists call them subsection Xerampelinae), and they're almost impossible to tell apart by eye.

The cap is 5-15 cm across and fleshy, convex at first, then flattening out with a slightly depressed centre. It's wine-red, purple-violet, richer and burgundy in the centre, paler toward the edge, pinkish-grey with an ochre tint. The cap skin is matte and dry, slightly sticky in wet weather, and peels about a quarter of the way in. The smell is distinctly fishy — like smoked herring or cooked shrimp, especially in mature mushrooms. This is the key diagnostic feature, and cooking doesn't get rid of it: it fades, but you can still recognise it.

An excellent edible mushroom, outstanding in the kitchen: the flesh is tender, with a mild nutty flavour and a fishy, briny aftertaste. Cook it as you would porcini, fried or stewed. It's especially good in sauces and paired with fish or seafood, where it brings out their flavour. Folk tradition ranks it alongside the best brittlegills, as a "mushroom for gourmets".

The second distinctive feature: the stem flesh slowly turns yellow to rusty brown when damaged, and turns almost brown after longer exposure to air. That's typical of the whole group. Iron sulfate (FeSO₄) gives it away too: iron salts turn the flesh dark green, grey-green or olive, a well-tested check among mycologists.

The main risk is confusing it with other wine-red brittlegills (R. queletii, R. integra, R. olivacea). Check two things: the fishy smell and yellow-brown discolouration of the stem flesh after cutting. the poisonous R. queletii smells fruity, not fishy; R. integra is mild and sweetish, and its flesh doesn't yellow; R. olivacea causes stomach upsets when undercooked.

Russula xerampelina is common across Europe in pine, spruce, mixed and broadleaf forests. The species itself partners pine and spruce, while a close relative from the same group, R. graveolens, grows with oak. Season: late summer to autumn, with most finds in early autumn.

Across Europe

Mainly a mushroom of pine and mixed conifer forests on the European mainland, and reported now and then from broadleaf woods. Herring gives it the German name Roter Herings-Täubling and the Swedish sillkremla, while the French say russule écrevisse.

Cap

The cap is 5-15 cm across, hemispherical when young, becoming flat and spreading with a slightly depressed centre with age. The cap skin is matte, slightly sticky in wet weather, dry and matte in dry weather, and peels about a quarter of the way to the centre. It's wine-red, purple-violet, burgundy in the centre, paler toward the edge, fading to pinkish-grey and ochre. Mature caps have fine radial grooves at the edge.

Hymenophore

The gills are attached or free from the stem, moderately crowded, fleshy and brittle. They're cream-white when young, becoming ochre-yellow to yellow-brown with age as the spores mature. Spore print yellow-ochre to yellow-brown.

Stem

Stem 5-10 cm tall, 1.5-3 cm thick, firm, fleshy, cylindrical, hollow inside in old mushrooms. It's white when young, with a characteristic pink or wine-coloured tint, and where pressed or cut it slowly turns yellow, then brown, a diagnostic feature. Surface smooth with fine lengthwise wrinkles. No ring.

Flesh

Flesh firm, brittle, white; it slowly turns yellow when cut, then brownish over time (especially in the stem), a characteristic reaction of the species. The smell is distinctly fishy and briny (smoked herring, shrimp, fish) and is the main diagnostic. Taste mild, nutty, with no bitterness or acridity.

Smell

Distinctly fishy and briny: smoked herring, cooked shrimp, fish. A diagnostic feature of the species, easy to notice when you cut it and still there in the finished dish.

›Scientific synonyms (7)

Agaricus xerampelina Schaeff. (1774), Agaricus rubellus Batsch, Agaricus esculentus var. xerampelinus (Schaeff.) Pers., Russula xerampelina var. xerampelina, Russula atrorosea Schwalb, Russula borealis Kauffman, Russula atrosanguinea Velen.

Don’t mix them up

Crab brittlegill lookalikes and comparison

FeatureCrab brittlegillBloody brittlegill
HymenophoreGilledGilled
Cap colourRed, VioletRed, Pink
SmellFishyFruity
EdibilityEdibleInedible
Full comparison: Crab brittlegill vs Bloody brittlegill →
Compare with another mushroom

Readers’ finds · 0

Readers’ photos aren’t checked by an expert. “Confirmed” means foragers in the feed agree — not a guarantee. When in doubt, leave it.

Your find

Crab brittlegillchange

…

Mushrooms of the same genus and habitat — to study side by side and never mix up.

Related reading

Frequently asked questions

Isn't it poisonous because of the "smell"?

No, quite the opposite: it's a very tasty edible mushroom. The fishy, briny smell (like smoked herring or cooked shrimp) is NOT unpleasant, just characteristic. The Ukrainian folk name "vonyucha" ("stinky") is a historical misjudgment; in the literature and among experienced foragers it's a prized species that's easy to identify with confidence. Don't confuse it with rotting mushrooms, which smell completely different (musty, sour).

How do you tell it apart from other wine-red brittlegills?

Key features of R. xerampelina: (1) Distinctly fishy smell (smoked herring, shrimp). (2) Stem flesh slowly yellows and then browns when damaged. (3) No need to taste it: points 1 and 2 separate it from the poisonous R. queletii. (4) Spore print yellow-ochre to yellow-brown. (5) Grows in conifer, mixed and broadleaf forests.

How do you cook it?

No pre-boiling needed: just clean it and fry or stew it straight away. It's especially tasty fried with cream, stewed with potatoes, in sauces for fish (it brings out the fishy flavour), and in soups. Pickling works, as with other edible brittlegills. Drying works fine too, though some of the smell is lost. The classic dish is a brittlegill pan roast with onions and cream.

Is the fishy smell normal?

Yes, perfectly normal: it's a trait of the species, not a sign of spoilage. The mushroom contains trimethylamine and related compounds (the same ones that give rotten fish its "fishy" smell), but in a healthy fresh mushroom they're just a normal metabolite. If the mushroom is old and also smells sour or musty, it's spoiled; don't eat it.

Where should you look for it?

In pine and spruce-pine forests, and also in mixed and broadleaf woods, including under oaks, on the forest floor among moss and grass. It likes sandy, slightly acidic soils and often grows in groups of 5-15.

Where in Europe is it found?

In Europe it is found in forests with pine, spruce or oak. For Ukraine, we found no reliable data on its regional distribution: the international GBIF database holds only a few dozen Ukrainian records of this group.

When should you look for it?

Late summer to autumn, peaking in early autumn. It likes a warm autumn with moderate rain.

Which brittlegills is it confused with?

With R. queletii (fruity brittlegill), which is burning-acrid, with no fishy smell and a thinner stem. With R. integra, which is mild and sweetish, with flesh that doesn't yellow, and grows in spruce-beech forests. With R. paludosa (hintapink), which is more orange-red, has no fishy smell and grows on sphagnum. The essential check is the fishy smell and the yellowing of the stem flesh.

Sources

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine