Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Russula mushrooms, known in Britain as brittlegills, are easiest to sort by cap colour: green, red and purple, yellow, brown and white. Most are edible, a few acrid species upset the stomach, and the one deadly danger in this group is the death cap, picked by mistake for a green brittlegill.

Below are all the species that have a page on our site, with their name, edibility class and the features that tell them apart. How to clean and cook brittlegills, where and when to find them and which look-alikes are dangerous are covered in separate articles, linked as we go.

Russula mushroom: how to recognise the genus

The flesh gives a brittlegill away. It's brittle: the stem snaps like school chalk or a slice of apple, and the gills crumble instead of bending, hence the English name. The reason is the build of the flesh, packed with large round cells.

Four things are worth checking on every find:

  • there's no ring on the stem and no bulb in a sac (volva) at the base, so dig the mushroom up whole rather than cutting it;
  • no milk oozes from broken gills, which separates brittlegills from milkcaps (Lactarius);
  • the spore print runs from white and cream to ochre, almost orange in a few species;
  • every brittlegill grows in partnership with trees or shrubs, so they are mycorrhizal mushrooms of woods and parks.

About 750 species are described worldwide, and Ukrainian Wikipedia counts about 50 in Ukraine. Michael Kuo of MushroomExpert writes that only 20 to 30 of them can be identified fairly easily; the rest need a microscope. The Latin Russula comes from a word for reddish. Ukrainian Wikipedia explains the Ukrainian name, syroizhka, by how quickly salted brittlegills become ready to eat, and in Galicia they're called holubinky, like the Polish gołąbek.

Green brittlegill and the other green species

Four green and blue-green brittlegills have pages on our site, and all four are edible. Green brittlegills are the ones most often confused with the death cap, so they deserve twice the care.

  • Greencracked brittlegill (Russula virescens), edible. A mature cap cracks into green patches on a pale background, like crazy paving. It grows under oak and beech, and the spore print is white to cream. It's the most often recorded brittlegill in Ukraine's GBIF data.
  • Green brittlegill (Russula aeruginea), edible. The cap is pale grass green, greasy when damp and never cracked, and it grows almost always under birch. That smooth cap makes it closer to a death cap than a mature greencracked brittlegill: Norway's official list of edible mushrooms calls it the death cap's double.
  • Charcoal burner (Russula cyanoxantha), edible and well liked. The cap ranges from purple to green, and one form is entirely green. The giveaway is the gills: greasy to the touch and flexible, not brittle like other species. White spore print, under oak and beech.
  • Greasy green brittlegill (Russula heterophylla), edible and on the German list of edible mushrooms. Our sources don't give a reliable field description for it, so only identify it with an experienced forager.

Before a green brittlegill goes in the basket, dig it up whole and look at the base. A death cap has a bulb sitting in a white sac, and a skirt-like ring under the cap that can be lost with age. Colour, white gills and a white spore print won't help: the death cap has the same. We go through this in detail in yellow knight and green russula: edible or dangerous? and on the page death cap vs greencracked brittlegill.

Red, pink and purple brittlegills

This is the largest and most confusing group: red brittlegills include good edibles and acrid species that irritate the stomach, and they look very alike.

  • Sickener (Russula emetica), poisonous, causes stomach upsets. The cap is scarlet, its skin peels almost to the centre, the gills and stem are white and the spore print is white. It grows under conifers and on wet heathland.
  • Bloody brittlegill (Russula sanguinea), inedible. It grows under pines, with a cream spore print. Guides class it as inedible because its flesh is hot.
  • Rosy brittlegill (Russula rosea, syn. R. lepida), edible but of low quality. Its flesh and stem are very hard, which is why some Western guides call it inedible. Vienna's mushroom advice service suggests squeezing the stem: firm in the rosy brittlegill, soft in the emetic red species. The real risk isn't the rosy brittlegill itself but an acrid red one landing in the basket beside it.
  • Hintapink (Russula paludosa), edible. The cap is red, purplish or ochre, the spore print deep cream to dark ochre, and it grows in damp pinewoods and bogs. It's easily mistaken for the sickener. Norway's list accepts it as edible and notes that its sharpness disappears with cooking.
  • Purple brittlegill (Russula atropurpurea), edible only after thorough cooking. White spore print, under oak and pine.
  • The flirt (Russula vesca, also called the bare-toothed brittlegill), edible. The cap runs from wine red to buff, and its skin stops about a millimetre short of the margin, so the gill ends peep out. White spore print, under beech, oak and spruce. Both the Norwegian and German lists accept it.
  • Crab brittlegill (Russula xerampelina), edible; the British guide First Nature calls it one of the finest brittlegills. It smells of fish or crab, the stem browns, the spore print is ochre, and it grows under pines. More in the brittlegill that smells of herring.
  • Humpback brittlegill (Russula caerulea), edible. The cap is purplish brown with a low hump in the middle, the cap skin is bitter, the spore print dark yellow, and it grows under pines. There are no Ukrainian GBIF records for it yet.
  • Russula brunneoviolacea, listed as edible, but that class rests on a single guide, and there are no Ukrainian GBIF records.
  • Russula integra, edible and on the German list of edible mushrooms.

A violet brittlegill in the Red Data Book

The pirate brittlegill (Russula turci) is the only brittlegill in the Red Data Book of Ukraine, listed as vulnerable. Please don't pick it there. The cap is amethyst violet, the stem base smells of iodine, the spore print is ochre yellow, and it grows under pine and spruce. Russula amethystina can hardly be told from it without a microscope, so a violet brittlegill that smells of iodine under conifers is best left where it is.

Yellow brittlegills

There are several yellow brittlegills on our site, and none of them is poisonous according to our sources.

  • Yellow swamp brittlegill (Russula claroflava), edible. The cap is bright yellow, the cut flesh slowly turns grey, and the spore print is pale ochre yellow. It grows on boggy ground under birch and aspen. Germany has it on its Red List.
  • Ochre brittlegill (Russula ochroleuca), edible after cooking. Pale cream spore print, in pine and broadleaf woods. Norway lists it as plainly edible and notes that its sharpness disappears with cooking.
  • Gilded brittlegill (Russula aurea), edible. The cap is yellow, orange and red, the gill edges and stem are golden, and the spore print is deep ochre. It grows in broadleaf woods.
  • Copper brittlegill (Russula decolorans), edible on both the Norwegian and German lists.

Stinking brittlegill: the brown one with a strong smell

The stinking brittlegill (Russula foetens) is poisonous by our class: Vienna's mushroom advice service names it as poisonous, and the German Mycological Society (DGfM) counts acrid and bitter brittlegills among poisonous mushrooms. The cap is brown and slimy, the smell is of rancid oil and, in old specimens, rotting fish, and the spore print is pale to mid cream. Russula subfoetens, R. grata, which smells of bitter almonds, and R. illota look similar and usually need a microscope to separate.

Here Eastern and Western Europe part ways, and we advise against eating it. In Ukraine and neighbouring countries it's traditionally salted: young caps are peeled, then soaked, or boiled with the water thrown away, to remove the bitterness. Norway's list calls it "not a food mushroom", and First Nature advises avoiding it. On the other hand, the Russula volume of Flora Polska says it isn't poisonous, and we found no poisoning case linked to it. How it's prepared in the East is covered in is the stinking brittlegill edible.

White and blackening brittlegills

The white and blackening species are a group of their own, and the way the cut flesh darkens tells them apart.

  • Milk-white brittlegill (Russula delica), edible after cooking. A dirty white funnel with gills running down the stem and a white spore print. Unlike the milkcaps, it gives no milk at all, even when you scratch the gills. Norway's list accepts it as edible but adds that it's hard to separate from R. chloroides, while the British guide says it isn't worth collecting.
  • Blackening brittlegill (Russula nigricans), edible after cooking and mediocre. The gills are thick and very widely spaced, and the cut flesh turns red first, then black. In Eastern Europe young ones are boiled and salted, but Norway's list doesn't regard it as a food mushroom.
  • Winecork brittlegill (Russula adusta), edible after cooking. The flesh reddens and then slowly turns grey. Norway's list accepts it as edible.
  • Menthol brittlegill (Russula albonigra), inedible. The flesh turns grey and black almost at once, with little or no red stage. Some Eastern European sources list it as edible, but Polish, Dutch and North American guides advise against eating it. We found no poisonings, but no solid reason to eat it either.

For the difference between the two, see menthol brittlegill vs blackening brittlegill. One more caution: Japan, Korea and Taiwan have a deadly species, Russula subnigricans, whose flesh reddens but doesn't blacken. It hasn't been recorded in Europe, but it's a reminder that "reddens when cut" doesn't on its own mean "safe".

Is Russula emetica poisonous? Which brittlegills do harm

Poisonous brittlegills in Europe cause stomach upsets, not fatal poisoning. The German Mycological Society (DGfM) lists the sickener, the beech sickener (R. mairei) and acrid and bitter brittlegills in general under gastrointestinal poisoning.

After eating Russula emetica, nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea and cramps start within half an hour to three hours. It usually settles on its own, the substance behind it still hasn't been identified, and we found no deaths. Oddly enough, in Eastern Europe it was once eaten after parboiling and salting, but we don't recommend it.

The one deadly danger among "brittlegills" is a death cap taken for a green brittlegill. Such poisonings have been recorded in Ukraine too. The death cap destroys the liver, and cooking doesn't make it safe. If you feel unwell after eating wild mushrooms, call 112 (999 in the UK) straight away and keep any leftovers. For the dangerous species see which brittlegills are poisonous, and for mushrooms that merely look like brittlegills, brittlegill lookalikes.

Why we don't recommend tasting brittlegills

Many guides and foragers judge a brittlegill by taste: acrid means inedible, mild means fine. We don't recommend it, and here's why.

  • The rule only works once you're already sure you've got a brittlegill. It won't screen out a death cap, which, according to some accounts, tastes pleasant.
  • English Wikipedia tags the claim "mild-tasting ones are all edible" as failing verification, and people sense heat differently.
  • Norway's list of edible mushrooms doesn't use the taste rule at all, and it accepts two acrid species, the hintapink and the ochre brittlegill, as edible.

Instead, identify the brittlegill to species using features you can check without tasting:

  1. Dig it up whole: no ring on the stem and no bulb in a sac at the base.
  2. Break the gills: no milk, and the stem snaps like chalk.
  3. Take a spore print: white to ochre narrows down the group.
  4. Smell it: the stinking brittlegill smells of rancid oil, the crab brittlegill of fish, the pirate brittlegill of iodine.
  5. Cut the flesh: in the blackening species it reddens, greys or blackens.

None of these features alone tells you whether a mushroom is edible, and we found no source with a non-taste rule that separates acrid brittlegills from mild ones. So the only safe route is knowing the species. If you're not sure, leave it in the wood or post it to our photo mushroom identifier. For cleaning and cooking the ones you're sure of, see how to clean and cook brittlegills.

Where and when brittlegills grow in Europe

GBIF, the global biodiversity database, holds over 760,000 brittlegill records from Europe. Most come from Sweden (21%) and Britain (18.5%), followed by Denmark, Norway, France, Belgium, Austria, Switzerland and the Netherlands. Across Europe, records peak in early autumn, with late summer and mid-autumn close behind. The number of records shows where many keen recorders are, not where the mushrooms are most common.

Ukraine has about 3,800 records, but over 3,200 of them are soil DNA samples from a single 2023 study, not mushrooms. Counting only fruit bodies (544 records), Ukrainian records peak in high summer and continue into autumn, with the first brittlegills appearing in early summer. The species recorded most often in Ukraine are the greencracked brittlegill, the charcoal burner and the flirt (Russula vesca). We wrote about the first brittlegills of the season in the first big flush of brittlegills, and about where to look in when and where to pick brittlegills.

Attitudes to brittlegills vary across Europe. The German Mycological Society accepts 14 named species as edible, plus every other mild-tasting one. Poland allows no brittlegill to be sold at all. Norway assesses each species separately. North American guides are generally more cautious than European ones.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Are Russula mushrooms edible?

Most Russula mushrooms are edible, including the greencracked, green and crab brittlegills, the charcoal burner and the flirt (Russula vesca). A few acrid species such as the sickener cause stomach upsets, some, like the blackening brittlegill, are only eaten after soaking or boiling, and we list the stinking brittlegill as poisonous. Only eat one you've identified to species.

Is Russula emetica poisonous?

Yes, Russula emetica, the sickener, is poisonous: it causes nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea within half an hour to three hours. It usually settles on its own, and we found no deaths linked to it.

How do I tell a green brittlegill from a death cap?

Dig the mushroom up whole: a death cap has a bulb in a white sac at the base and a ring under the cap, while a brittlegill has neither. Colour, white gills and a white spore print are the same in both, so don't rely on them.

Can you taste a brittlegill to check if it's edible?

We don't recommend tasting wild mushrooms. The "mild means edible" rule won't screen out a death cap and isn't reliable even among brittlegills, so the only safe way is to identify the species by its features: ring and volva, milk, spore print, smell and the colour of the cut flesh.

What does a blackening brittlegill look like?

The blackening brittlegill (Russula nigricans) has thick, very widely spaced gills and flesh that turns red first and then black when cut. It's edible only after cooking and mediocre, and Norway doesn't regard it as a food mushroom.

Can I pick the pirate brittlegill?

Please don't pick it in Ukraine: the pirate brittlegill (Russula turci) is the only brittlegill in the Red Data Book of Ukraine, listed as vulnerable. You can recognise it by its amethyst violet cap and the iodine smell at the stem base.

When do brittlegills grow?

Brittlegills grow from early summer to late autumn. Across Europe records peak in early autumn, while Ukrainian fruit-body records peak in high summer.

Related articles

Sources

  • Wikipedia, "Russula", "Russula emetica", "Russula turci", "Russula subnigricans": the genus, number of species, symptoms after the sickener, the failed-verification tag on the taste rule.
  • Ukrainian Wikipedia, "Сироїжка": about 50 species in Ukraine, the origin of the name, holubinka.
  • Kuo M. "The genus Russula", MushroomExpert.com: how many species can be identified without a microscope, genus features.
  • First Nature, Russula species pages (aeruginea, cyanoxantha, emetica, sanguinaria, rosea, paludosa, atropurpurea, vesca, xerampelina, caerulea, claroflava, ochroleuca, aurea, foetens, delica): features, spore print, host trees, edibility.
  • Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund, Normlisten 2024 and 2026 (Norway): status of each species, remarks on sharpness and the death cap double.
  • DGfM, Positivliste der Speisepilze and Liste der Giftpilze, 2026 (Germany): edible brittlegills, acrid poisonous species, R. subnigricans not recorded in Europe.
  • Regulation of the Polish Minister of Health of 17.05.2011 (Dz.U. 2026 poz. 258), annex 1: mushrooms allowed for sale.
  • Stadt Wien, Pilzberatung, "Zinnoberroter Hart-Täubling": edibility and the hard stem of the rosy brittlegill.
  • Polish Wikipedia, "Gołąbek śmierdzący" (citing Skirgiełło A. "Gołąbek (Russula)", Flora Polska, 1998) and "Gołąbek czarny" (citing Dermek 1988): the stinking brittlegill isn't poisonous, the menthol brittlegill is inedible.
  • Russian Wikipedia, "Валуй"; Zerova M. Ya. et al. "Гриби: їстівні, умовно їстівні, неїстівні, отруйні" (Urozhai, 1979), via Ukrainian Wikipedia: how the stinking brittlegill is soaked, boiled and salted.
  • SanPiN 2.3.4.13-6-2004 (Belarus), list of mushrooms allowed for harvesting, via FAOLEX: stinking and winecork brittlegills among those allowed, boiling before salting.
  • Wikipedia, "Russula albonigra" (citing Arora D. Mushrooms Demystified, 1986); Naturalis (Netherlands), Russula albonigra page: advice against eating the menthol brittlegill.
  • Cho J. T., Han J. H. A case of mushroom poisoning with Russula subnigricans (Journal of Korean Medical Science, 2016).
  • Order of the Ministry of Environmental Protection of Ukraine No. 111 of 15.02.2021 (species in the Red Data Book of Ukraine) and the Red Data Book checklist on GBIF: the pirate brittlegill.
  • GBIF, Russula records for Europe and Ukraine, data as of 01.11.2026.
  • Wikidata and NBN Atlas: species names.
  • Our working fact sheets for the comparisons "death cap vs greencracked brittlegill" and "menthol brittlegill vs blackening brittlegill", with their sources (Ukrainian Wikipedia, ZAXID.NET 2017, Ternopil regional disease control centre 2025): death cap confusion in Ukraine.