Support MycoNote →

MycoNote
Want to find

Photo: James Lindsey · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

Conditionally edible✓ Checked by an expert

Blackening brittlegillRussula nigricans

SeasonAugust – November

Passport

Hymenophore
Gilled
Cap colour
White
Size
Large (over 15 cm)

✓ Conditionally edible

Most often confused with: Menthol brittlegill (inedible).

Quick answers

When does it appear? Europe

Aug — Nov

Active months: August, September, October, November.

How to recognise it? Three signs

Description

The blackening brittlegill (Russula nigricans) is the most recognisable of the blackening brittlegills thanks to the remarkable way its flesh reacts: when damaged, it first turns red, then reddish-brown, and then gradually blackens to anthracite black. That makes it one of the best "textbook" mushrooms for studying fungal biochemistry, since you can watch the two-phase oxidation reaction with the naked eye. To look at, it's a fleshy brittlegill with a white cap that over time turns dirty grey, ash-grey, then blackish.

It's edible, but only conditionally. It is of mediocre quality: only young specimens are used, before the flesh turns black and tough, and they are boiled with the water thrown away before salting or frying. Norway does not regard it as a food mushroom, Polish guides disagree, and the German list of edible mushrooms does not name it. We found no recorded poisoning by it in Europe. Because it blackens in the pan, the dish looks unappetizing, with the flesh turning dark grey to black. So cooks rate it lower than other brittlegills and milk caps, but it's fine as a basket-filler in a lean season. For pickling, use young mushrooms with white flesh.

It's also an interesting host: old, fallen fruit bodies that haven't fully decomposed often carry a parasitic mushroom, the silky piggyback (Asterophora parasitica). It's one of the best-known examples of one mushroom parasitising another.

It's widespread in Europe in deciduous and mixed forests, from mountain and foothill forests to lowland woods and the forest-steppe. It forms mycorrhiza with beech, oak and spruce. The season runs from summer to autumn.

Across Europe

On mainland Europe its range runs from Scandinavia right down to the Mediterranean, and on east into temperate Asia. It lives in partnership with trees in both conifer and broadleaf woods.

Cap

The cap is 6-20 cm across, hemispherical to flat with an inrolled margin when young, later becoming funnel-shaped. It's white when young, turning dirty grey, ash-grey, then blackish to anthracite black with age. The cap darkens when pressed, unevenly in young specimens. The surface is smooth and slightly sticky in wet weather.

Hymenophore

The gills are attached to the stem, distant and thick, typical of the genus Russula. They're whitish when young, redden to brownish-black when damaged, and darken with age to grey, then black. The spore print is white.

Stem

The stem is 4-8 cm tall and 2-4 cm thick: thick, fleshy, cylindrical and relatively short. It's white when young, turning grey, then blackish with age. The surface is smooth, with no ring.

Flesh

The flesh is firm, fleshy and white when young. When cut, it goes through a two-phase reaction: first it reddens to greyish or brownish red, then it gradually blackens to anthracite black. This is the classic diagnostic feature of the species. The smell is faintly mushroomy.

Smell

Faint, pleasant, mushroomy, with no distinctive notes.

›Scientific synonyms (5)

Lactarelis nigricans (Fr.) Earle, Agaricus nigrescens Bull., Agaricus nigricans Bull., Agaricus adustus var. crassus Alb. & Schwein., Agaricus nigrescens Krombh.

Don’t mix them up

Blackening brittlegill lookalikes and comparison

FeatureBlackening brittlegillMenthol brittlegill
HymenophoreGilledGilled
Cap colourWhite, Grey, BlackWhite, Grey, Black
SmellPleasant—
EdibilityConditionally edibleInedible
Full comparison: Blackening brittlegill vs Menthol brittlegill →
Compare with another mushroom

Readers’ finds · 0

Readers’ photos aren’t checked by an expert. “Confirmed” means foragers in the feed agree — not a guarantee. When in doubt, leave it.

Your find

Blackening brittlegillchange

…

Mushrooms of the same genus and habitat — to study side by side and never mix up.

Related reading

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to eat?

With caution: only young mushrooms with white flesh are, after boiling for 10-15 min. Skip old specimens with soft, maggoty caps. The finished dish will be dark grey because the flesh blackens. That's normal and doesn't affect the taste, though it doesn't look very appetising. Culinary value is moderate; it's best for pickling. British guides rate it as mediocre at best, Norway does not regard it as a food mushroom, and Polish guides disagree. We found no recorded poisoning by it in Europe.

Why does the flesh turn black?

It's a unique two-phase oxidation reaction. In stage one, the enzyme tyrosinase oxidises phenolic compounds (tyrosine and DOPA) into red derivatives. In stage two, these polymerise into melanin, which gives the black colour. It's not poison and not spoilage. The reaction is gradual, so the dish in the pan darkens gradually too.

Does it have dangerous lookalikes?

No seriously poisonous white-fleshed brittlegill is known in Europe. The deadly Russula subnigricans grows in East Asia and has not been found in Europe; its flesh reddens but does not blacken. The key thing is to tell it apart from young amanitas (white gills + ring + volva means an amanita, not a brittlegill) and from milk caps (Lactarius), which ooze milky latex when cut. Mixing it up with other white-fleshed brittlegills is usually not critical, but acrid ones such as the sickener are poisonous: they cause stomach upsets.

Is it true that another mushroom grows on it?

Yes: the silky piggyback (Asterophora parasitica), one of the few mushrooms that parasitise other mushrooms. You'll often see its small white or grey fruit bodies on old, fallen blackening brittlegills, especially in a damp late autumn. It isn't eaten, but it's an interesting thing to watch for if you like forest ecology.

Where should you look for it?

In deciduous and mixed forests, mostly under beech, oak and hornbeam, less often in mixed forests with spruce. It likes damp, mossy spots and shady forest edges.

Where in Europe is it found?

Throughout the forest and forest-steppe zones, from mountain and foothill forests to lowland woods. In the steppe it grows in floodplain oak woods.

When should you look for it?

Summer to autumn, peaking in late summer and early autumn. It likes warm, humid weather after summer rain.

What mushrooms is it confused with?

With other white-fleshed brittlegills: the milk-white brittlegill (Russula delica) and the menthol brittlegill (R. albonigra). The milk-white brittlegill is listed as edible; for the menthol brittlegill, sources disagree. The more serious mix-ups are with young amanitas (volva + ring means amanita) and with Lactarius resimus, which is also edible but oozes white milky latex when cut.

How do you cook it?

Pickling young mushrooms works best. Boil them for 10-15 min first and drain the water (it comes out dark grey), then cover with a vinegar marinade and spices. Stewing with potatoes is fine. Fried, the flesh blackens and the dish doesn't look great, but it tastes nice. Drying isn't worth it, as the dark colour gets deeper.

Sources

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine