Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Which brittlegills are poisonous, and how to tell them from edible ones

By Valeriia·Updated ·3 min read

Most brittlegills are edible, but some are acrid and dangerous. Here's which ones to leave behind and which features help you tell them apart.

The sickener (Russula emetica): a red cap and the white gills of a second mushroom on moss
Photo: Bob (Bobzimmer) (Mushroom Observer) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

Brittlegills are the most common mushrooms in European forests, and most of them are edible. But this colourful family also has hot, acrid species that are best avoided. Here's which brittlegills to leave, how to tell them apart, and why the bright red ones deserve extra care.

Are there poisonous brittlegills?

No deadly poisonous brittlegills are known in Europe, but there are acrid, peppery species that upset the stomach, causing nausea, pain and vomiting. They're called poisonous, and fairly so: they cause digestive upset, and cooking can't be relied on to make them safe. Deaths are rare, but small children and frail people are most at risk. The best known is the sickener.

What field guides say about a burning taste

Field guides describe the flesh of edible brittlegills as mild, bland or nutty, and that of the acrid ones as hot and sharp, like pepper. This is a description from the books, not a test for you to do.

Experienced foragers know the acrid species by their features. Don't taste a brittlegill to check it: go by the full set of features, and if you're not sure, leave it in the forest.

What to pay attention to

  • Cap colour. Hot species are more common among the bright red brittlegills, so take extra care with those. No colour tells you a brittlegill is edible, and a green cap needs the death cap check first.
  • Flesh. Brittle, as in all brittlegills. Smell doesn't separate them either: the sickener smells fruity.
  • Habitat. Hot brittlegills often grow in damp, mossy places.

These are only rough guides: brittlegill colours vary a lot, so colour alone is not enough.

Don't confuse them with more dangerous mushrooms

Far more important is not to confuse a brittlegill with truly poisonous gilled mushrooms such as the death cap and other amanitas. Unlike brittlegills, they have a ring on the stem and a bulb with a sac (volva) at the base. The ring can fall off, and the sac can stay in the soil if the mushroom is snapped off, so lift the whole mushroom and look at its base. Read more in the death cap, Europe's most dangerous mushroom, and for the brittlegill family itself, see brittlegills, the forest's most common mushroom.

The general rule: brittlegills are only for people who can identify them confidently. They're not eaten raw; more on that in which mushrooms you can eat raw.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Are there poisonous brittlegills?

No deadly poisonous brittlegills are known in Europe, but there are hot, acrid species (such as the sickener) that upset the stomach. Cooking can't be relied on to make them safe, and small children and frail people are most at risk.

How do you tell an edible brittlegill from a dangerous one?

By the full set of features, not by taste. Field guides describe edible brittlegills as mild and the acrid ones as hot and peppery, but don't check this with your tongue. Look at the cap, gills, stem, flesh and habitat together, and if you're not sure, leave the mushroom in the forest.

Which brittlegill is the most dangerous?

The best-known acrid one is the sickener, with its bright red cap. Deaths from it are rare, but it causes nausea and vomiting. Hot species are more common among the bright red brittlegills.

Can you identify a brittlegill by its colour?

Not reliably. Bright red ones are more often hot, but no colour tells you a brittlegill is edible, and brittlegill colours vary a lot. Check a green cap for the death cap first: a ring on the stem and a sac (volva) at the base.

Can a brittlegill be confused with the death cap?

Yes, the greencracked brittlegill gets mistaken for the death cap. The key difference: the death cap has a ring on the stem and a bulb with a sac (volva) at the base, and a brittlegill has neither. This difference is critical, but the ring can fall off and the sac can stay in the soil, so lift the whole mushroom and check its base.

What happens if you eat a hot brittlegill?

You may get an upset stomach with nausea, pain and vomiting. Fatal cases are rare, but small children and frail people are most at risk. That's why hot brittlegills are left in the forest.

Do brittlegills need to be boiled?

Many brittlegills are boiled before frying, and local tradition salts the hot species after soaking and boiling. We don't recommend that: the sickener and other acrid species are poisonous, and soaking guarantees nothing. Brittlegills aren't eaten raw. Beginners are better off taking only species they can identify with certainty by their features.

Related articles