Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Brittlegills, among the most common mushrooms in the forest

By Valeriia·Updated ·4 min read

Brittlegills turn up almost everywhere you step, but you need to pick them wisely. Here's how to recognise a good brittlegill, which colours spell danger and why they're so fragile.

The flirt (Russula vesca): pink cap and nibbled gills on the forest floor
Photo: Nina Filippova · CC BY 4.0 · source

Brittlegills, or brittle gills (the genus Russula), are among the most common mushrooms in European forests, with around 750 species worldwide. From early summer to late autumn their bright red, green, yellow or purple caps turn up practically at every step. Are brittlegills edible? Some are, and a few rank among the finest wild mushrooms, while others are acrid and poisonous. So pick them wisely.

Let's look at how to recognise a good brittlegill, which colours should put you on your guard and why these mushrooms are so fragile.

How to recognise a brittlegill

Brittlegills make up a large genus, but they share traits that make them easy to tell apart from other mushrooms.

  • Cap. Rounded, flattening or even becoming sunken with age, with smooth, often shiny skin.
  • Gills. White or cream, even, brittle.
  • Stem. White, cylindrical, with no ring and no sac at the base.
  • Flesh. White, very fragile, crumbles easily.

Most importantly, a brittlegill has neither a skirt on the stem nor a sac at the base. These are exactly the details that set it apart from dangerous mushrooms such as the death cap.

Which brittlegills are edible

There are plenty of tasty brittlegills.

Field guides often describe the edible species as mild, but a mild taste does not make a brittlegill edible. Among the best are the flirt (Russula vesca), greencracked brittlegill and other species with a mild, nutty taste. Colour is no guide to edibility either: cap colour varies within a species, and telling brittlegills apart can take a microscope.

Once you are sure it is a brittlegill (no ring and no sac at the base, flesh that crumbles like chalk), learn the species by its cap colour and other features. Field guides describe many edible brittlegills as mild and the ones to avoid as burning and bitter, but a mild taste does not make a mushroom edible. Don't taste a mushroom to check it. Never pick an unfamiliar gilled mushroom.

Which brittlegills are dangerous

Not all brittlegills are safe, so a few rules are worth remembering.

  • Hot and bitter. Bright red acrid brittlegills, such as the sickener, cause sickness, stomach pains and vomiting.
  • Bright red with a blood-red tinge. Most of the acrid species come in these colours, so beginners are better off leaving them alone.

And most importantly: a young greenish brittlegill can be mistaken for the death cap. We show in detail how to tell them apart in our comparison of the death cap and the greencracked brittlegill.

Are brittlegills poisonous?

Some are. The sickener (Russula emetica), found mainly under conifers, and the beechwood sickener (Russula nobilis) are poisonous, and Germany's mycological society lists the sickener group among mushrooms that cause stomach and gut poisoning. Norway's Normlisten doesn't rate the sickener as food. We found no deadly European brittlegill in the lists we read, which isn't proof that none exists. The deadly risk is taking a death cap for a green brittlegill.

Why brittlegills are so fragile

This remarkable fragility is the brittlegill's signature trait, and it has both upsides and downsides.

Brittlegill flesh is made up of rounded cells, so it crumbles easily and the gills break at the slightest touch. That's why brittlegills are hard to get home in one piece, and they often go on top of the basket.

But this same fragility helps you recognise the mushroom: if the gills and flesh are brittle as chalk, you're most likely looking at a brittlegill. In the kitchen, edible brittlegills are fried, boiled and salted. Bitter or acrid ones stay in the forest: some of them are poisonous. Unsure about a mushroom? Check it against our safe foraging rules.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

How do you recognise a brittlegill?

Look for a rounded, smooth cap, white brittle gills and a white, fragile stem with no ring and no sac. The flesh is very fragile and crumbles easily. Cap colours vary enormously.

Are brittlegills edible?

Not all of them. Many species are edible, but there are bitter and acrid brittlegills, such as the sickener, that cause digestive upset.

How can you check whether a brittlegill is edible?

First make sure it is a brittlegill: no ring, no sac, crumbly flesh. Then name the species by its features. A mild taste does not make a brittlegill edible, so taste is no test: don't put a mushroom on your tongue to check it.

Can a brittlegill be mistaken for a death cap?

Yes, a young greenish brittlegill can be mistaken for the death cap. What saves you is that a brittlegill has neither a skirt nor a sac at the base. Details in our comparison.

Why are brittlegills so fragile?

Because their flesh is made up of rounded cells, so it crumbles easily and the gills break at a touch. At the same time, this fragility helps you recognise a brittlegill.

Which brittlegills taste best?

A few well-known species that you must recognise by all their features, including the flirt (Russula vesca) and the greencracked brittlegill. Colour alone is no guide, but bright red acrid species are best avoided.

Can you eat brittlegills raw?

Better not. Some species are bitter or acrid, and one, Russula olivacea, is known to cause stomach upsets if it isn't heated enough. So edible brittlegills are always cooked: fried, boiled or salted. Leave bitter or acrid ones in the forest.

Why shouldn't you pick bright red brittlegills?

Bright red species include the most acrid and bitter ones, which cause digestive upset. But a muted colour is no guarantee either: greenish brittlegills can be confused with the death cap, so beginners should pick only species they know for certain.

Related articles

Sources