Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Which mushrooms can you eat raw (and why almost none)

By Valeriia·Updated ·4 min read

Can you eat raw mushrooms? Fresh shop-bought button mushrooms, usually yes, in small amounts. Wild mushrooms, no: many are toxic until thoroughly cooked. Here's which is which.

Field mushroom (Agaricus campestris): a vintage illustration of white caps with pink gills
Photo: Anna Maria Hussey · CC0 · source

Can you eat raw mushrooms? Fresh shop-bought button mushrooms, yes: the British Heart Foundation lists raw as one way to eat them. Wild mushrooms, no: the German Mycological Society warns that many species that are edible cooked are poisonous raw. Let's look at why, which mushrooms people do eat raw, and which you should never eat raw.

Why wild mushrooms shouldn't be eaten raw

There are several reasons, and all of them serious:

  • Natural toxins. Many mushrooms contain toxins that only thorough heating destroys: the German Mycological Society gives 15 minutes of boiling or frying. Honey fungus is on its list of mushrooms poisonous raw, along with parasols, blushers and Leccinum boletes. Even cooked honey fungus disagrees with some people.
  • Hard-to-digest cell walls. Mushroom fibre (chitin) is poorly digested even when cooked, and raw it's worse still, which is why raw mushrooms sit heavy and upset the stomach.
  • Dirt and parasites. Wild mushrooms pick up bacteria, soil particles and larvae. Thorough cooking deals with most of that.

So the main safety rule is simple: wild mushrooms must be thoroughly boiled or fried. But cooking only helps with edible species: death cap toxins survive boiling, frying and drying.

Which mushrooms are still eaten raw

Only a few mushrooms are eaten raw (and only in small amounts), and they're usually cultivated rather than wild:

  • button mushrooms: young store-bought button mushrooms are sometimes thinly sliced into salads;
  • truffle: it's added in thin shavings for its aroma;
  • young porcini: in some cuisines it's thinly shaved into carpaccio, but we advise against it, because porcini count as edible only after thorough heating.

Even here, though, there's a caveat: this only applies to perfectly fresh, definitely edible mushrooms from a reliable source, in small portions. Wild mushrooms “from the basket” are best never eaten raw.

Which mushrooms should not be eaten raw?

Morels are poisonous raw or undercooked, so they must always be cooked well, and even cooked, large portions of fresh morels have caused nerve symptoms. False morels are deadly poisonous, raw or cooked. Enoki must be cooked thoroughly because they can carry listeria. Raw or undercooked shiitake can, rarely, cause a streaky itchy rash. And then there's every wild mushroom on the German Mycological Society's list, from honey fungus to parasols.

Are shop-bought mushrooms safe raw?

Button, chestnut and portobello mushrooms are all the same species, and they contain agaritine. In high laboratory doses it's an experimental carcinogen, but there's inadequate evidence that the amounts in mushrooms cause cancer in people, and a large study of two US cohorts found no link between eating mushrooms and cancer. Cooking cuts agaritine by up to 90% and freezing by up to 75%.

So can you eat mushrooms straight from the pack? Fresh button or chestnut mushrooms, yes: give them a wipe first, and keep the amounts small. If you'd rather be cautious, cook them. We found no good evidence that raw mushrooms are better for you than cooked ones.

Why eating mushrooms raw is dangerous

Raw wild mushrooms can cause nausea, stomach pain and real poisoning, from mild to severe. This is especially risky for children and people with weak digestion. For the signs of poisoning and what to do, see mushroom poisoning: signs and first aid.

And once more, the key point: tasting is not a way to test a mushroom. Don't put unfamiliar raw mushrooms on your tongue to “check” them. Why folk “tests” don't work is explained in myths about identifying poisonous mushrooms.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Which mushrooms can you eat raw?

Mostly cultivated mushrooms, and only in small amounts: young button mushrooms in a salad, shavings of truffle, and in some cuisines young porcini, which we advise against because it's a wild mushroom. Wild mushrooms “from the basket” must not be eaten raw.

Why can't you eat raw mushrooms?

You can eat some: fresh shop-bought button mushrooms are often eaten raw. Wild mushrooms are the problem, because many contain toxins that break down only when thoroughly heated, and they carry dirt and larvae.

Can you eat button mushrooms raw?

Young, perfectly fresh store-bought button mushrooms are sometimes thinly sliced raw into salads. Cooking reduces the agaritine they contain, though, and wild Agaricus mushrooms shouldn't be eaten raw.

What does heat treatment destroy in mushrooms?

Thorough boiling or frying breaks down the heat-sensitive toxins in many edible mushrooms, as well as most bacteria and larvae. It doesn't make a poisonous mushroom safe: death cap toxins survive cooking.

Is it dangerous to eat a raw wild mushroom?

Yes, it can cause nausea, stomach pain and even genuine poisoning. It's especially risky for children and people with weak digestion. Always cook wild mushrooms.

Can you taste a mushroom to identify it?

No. Tasting isn't a test: a sharp or bitter taste turns up in both edible and poisonous mushrooms. Identify a mushroom by its features, not by putting it raw on your tongue.

Why are raw mushrooms hard on the stomach?

Because their cell walls contain chitin, which is hard to digest. Even cooked mushrooms are on the heavy side, and raw ones leave you feeling heavy and can cause an upset stomach.

Related articles

Sources