Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Myths about spotting poisonous mushrooms

By Valeriia·Updated ·4 min read

There's no easy test for a poisonous mushroom: silver, onions and slugs all pass the deadly death cap. These myths have cost lives; here's what actually keeps you safe.

Panther cap (Amanita pantherina): a brown cap dotted with white warts on a white stem in grass
Photo: inyucho from Holland · CC BY 2.0 · source

Is there an easy way to tell if a mushroom is poisonous? No. Silver spoons, onions and garlic prove nothing, and slugs happily eat the deadly death cap, which passes every such test. Here are the main myths, and what actually protects you from poisoning.

Let's debunk the main myths about identifying poisonous mushrooms and look at what actually protects you from poisoning.

Myth 1. Silver turns black from poison

The most widespread legend: if you drop a silver spoon or coin in with the mushrooms and it darkens, the mushrooms are poisonous.

In reality, the Swiss poisons centre Tox Info Suisse calls the belief in this test simply wishful thinking, and silver won't warn you about the deadly death cap. There's no connection to poison here at all.

Myth 2. Onion or garlic darkens next to a poisonous mushroom

A similar legend claims that an onion or garlic cooked with mushrooms turns brown if there's a poisonous one among them.

This isn't true either. Tox Info Suisse puts the onion in the same category as the silver spoon, and the Catalan government calls the garlic test an old wives' tale with no scientific foundation. The test shows nothing.

Myth 3. Insects and snails don't eat poisonous mushrooms

Many people are convinced that if a mushroom is wormy or has been nibbled by snails, it's definitely edible.

In fact, insect larvae and slugs happily eat mushrooms that are deadly to humans, including the death cap. Their bodies work differently. So snail marks prove nothing, and worms only spoil the mushroom.

Myth 4. Boiling or vinegar neutralises the toxin

This one is very dangerous: the idea that any mushroom can be made safe if you boil it long enough, pour off the water or add vinegar.

The toxins of the most dangerous mushrooms are heat-stable. Neither long boiling, nor drying, nor salting, nor pickling in vinegar destroys them. The brown rollrim remains dangerous despite soaking and boiling, and the death cap's toxin doesn't go away at all. There's more on the brown rollrim in a separate article.

Myth 5. Poisonous mushrooms are bitter or brightly coloured

Many people believe that taste or colour gives danger away: bitter and bright means poisonous, while pleasant and plain means safe.

This is false too. The death cap tastes pleasant, and the panther cap is a modest brown, not bright. Meanwhile, the bright red fly agaric is poisonous, but so is the plain white destroying angel, while bright yellow chanterelles are edible. So neither taste nor colour is a reliable signal.

Myth 6. If you can peel it, it’s safe

Some people believe a mushroom that peels is edible. But the deadly death cap can be peeled, so the skin tells you nothing.

Myth 7. Mushrooms on wood are safe

Plenty of edible mushrooms grow on trees and stumps, but so does the deadly funeral bell, in clusters on bark and stumps. Where a mushroom grows narrows the choice. It doesn't prove anything about safety.

Myth 8. A small test bite is enough

Never test a mushroom this way. The most dangerous toxins act late: death cap symptoms usually take 8 to 12 hours, but anywhere from 4 to 36, and with deadly webcaps you can feel fine for days before kidney failure follows. Feeling well after a small piece proves nothing about the rest of your find.

What actually works

Telling poisonous mushrooms from edible ones is hard even for experts, and folk rules are unreliable. Here's what actually helps.

  1. Accurate species identification. The only reliable way is to identify the mushroom with certainty. If you know it, pick it; if in doubt, leave it.
  2. Checking the key features. A skirt on the stem and a sac at the base, white gills on an unfamiliar mushroom, and other morphological details.
  3. Picking only species you know. Expand your list gradually, learning one mushroom at a time. If your country has mushroom inspection points, use them.
  4. No on-the-spot “tests.” Silver, onions, tasting raw mushrooms: all of this is useless and dangerous.

The full set of guidelines is in our safe foraging rules, and an overview of dangerous species is in our guide to the poisonous mushrooms of Europe. If you suspect poisoning, call 112 (999 in the UK) immediately and follow our first aid instructions.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Is it true that a silver spoon turns black from poisonous mushrooms?

No. Poison specialists call this test a fallacy, and silver won't warn you about the deadly death cap.

Can you test mushrooms with onion or garlic?

No. Poison specialists class it with the silver spoon as a fallacy. The test shows nothing, and relying on it is dangerous.

If a mushroom is wormy, is it definitely edible?

No. Insect larvae and snails happily eat mushrooms that are deadly to humans, including the death cap. Worms prove nothing; they only spoil the mushroom.

Does long boiling neutralise the toxin?

No. The toxins of the most dangerous mushrooms are heat-stable. Neither boiling, nor drying, nor salting, nor pickling in vinegar destroys them. A deadly mushroom stays deadly.

Are all poisonous mushrooms bitter or brightly coloured?

No. The death cap tastes pleasant, and the panther cap is a modest brown. Neither taste nor colour is a reliable sign of toxicity.

Why are folk testing methods so dangerous?

Because they create a false sense of security. A person “tests” a mushroom with silver or onion, gets a reassuring result and eats a deadly mushroom. These methods simply don't work, period.

How can you actually tell a poisonous mushroom apart?

Only by accurate species identification and checking the key features (skirt, sac at the base, gill colour). There's no universal “poison test.” If in doubt, leave it out.

What should you do if you trusted a myth and got poisoned?

Call 112 (999 in the UK) immediately, keep any leftover mushrooms and don't wait until you feel worse. Treating yourself, or trying yet more “folk remedies,” is dangerous. There's more in our article on first aid.

Related articles

Sources