Nobody has yet shown a reliable way to grow porcini (Boletus edulis) in a garden. Scientists have been putting the fungus onto tree seedlings for decades, but no one has reported mushrooms from those plantings. Chanterelles (Cantharellus cibarius) have fruited in a pot with a pine, but that was an experiment, not something you can repeat outdoors.
So why are these two so stubborn, what do we know about soaked caps and packets of spawn, and what can you actually raise on your own ground?
Why porcini aren't grown like oyster mushrooms
Porcini need a living tree. The fungus wraps around the fine root tips, passes water and minerals to the tree and takes sugars in return. That partnership is called mycorrhiza. Oyster mushrooms and shiitake work differently: they feed on dead wood, which is why a log, straw or sawdust is enough.
It shows in their genes too, as mycorrhizal fungi carry far fewer wood-digging enzymes. A bag of sawdust that suits an oyster mushroom gives porcini nothing like what a tree gives it.
Planting a tree isn't enough either. Porcini are regarded as a fungus of mature woodland and seem to need a large supply of sugar from a grown tree. They have plenty of partners, including spruce, pine, oak and chestnut, so the choice of tree isn't the main barrier. Chanterelles also fruit only with trees, and in forest plantations they start when the trees are 10 to 40 years old.
What the porcini experiments show
Researchers have established the root partnership on seedlings many times: on oak in 1980, pine in 1982, chestnut in 1999 and rockrose in 2008. The chestnuts kept it for six years in the field. A Japanese team summed up the position in 2014: no artificial fruiting has been achieved.
The longest planting we know of was in New Zealand. Pines were colonised under oaks already producing porcini, then planted out in 2007. The fungus was still on the roots in 2010, but a review from 2021 says no porcini had appeared. Often it goes worse than that: on ordinary soil, other fungi push porcini out and the partnership disappears.
We looked for newer reports in English, Ukrainian and Russian and found none of mushrooms from such plantings. That doesn't make it impossible. A farmer-led project in the US is now comparing ways of inoculating chestnuts, including a spore solution, with no results yet. The fair way to put it: nobody has shown it so far.
Chanterelles: one success in a pot
Chanterelles have done slightly better. In an experiment published in Nature in 1997, Eric Danell and Francisco Camacho got fruit bodies in a greenhouse: they came out of the drainage holes of a pot holding a 16-month-old pine seedling, and DNA confirmed they were the strain put in. It took sterile chambers and computer-controlled feeding, which no garden bed can offer.
It went no further. In 1998, 600 inoculated pines were planted at 24 sites in Sweden, but we couldn't find the outcome, and the 2021 review says the work led to no commercial use. In Japan, in 2019, the related Cantharellus anzutake fruited repeatedly in 4-litre pots with pine, at 20 to 24 °C under constant light.
Does the soaked-caps trick work?
There's no proof that it does. The recipe does the rounds online: chop the caps, soak them for a day, pour the water under a tree and pick your crop a year later. We found no controlled test confirming this for porcini or chanterelles in any of three languages. A US Forest Service review of chanterelles is blunt: people scatter old mushrooms hoping for new patches, but it's unconfirmed that this does any good.
Spores can infect roots. With pine bolete, a close relative of porcini, this has worked on seedlings given millions of spores each. But a root partnership on a seedling is a long way from a basket of mushrooms, and no one has made that journey yet.
There's another trap too. A porcino that appears under an old oak a few years later proves nothing, because the fungus may have been there already or arrived by itself as spores. To say "that's the one I sowed", you'd need to compare DNA. So glowing stories in the comments aren't evidence, however sincere the person is.
What's in a packet of porcini mycelium?
We don't know. We found no independent test showing what's inside such packets or whether mushrooms grow from them. We won't call them all a con, as we have no grounds for that. But two things are worth remembering before you buy a porcini or chanterelle growing kit: pure porcini culture is hard to keep even in a laboratory, and no one has shown fruiting from pure mycelium.
Porcini in a cellar or greenhouse
They won't grow in a cellar, as there's no living tree with roots. In a greenhouse, only the chanterelle has worked, in a pot with a seedling and under laboratory conditions. Porcini fared worse: in the Japanese experiment the partnership vanished once seedlings moved to the greenhouse. Button mushrooms, on the other hand, suit a cellar very well.
Why truffles are farmed but porcini aren't
Truffles live with trees too, and they are farmed. The first black truffles from a controlled planting were picked in France in 1977, under hazels planted four and a half years earlier, and man-made orchards now provide up to 90% of Europe's black truffles. In New Zealand, saffron milk caps fruit in pine plantings.
The method is the same each time: a nursery colonises the seedlings, the roots are checked, the soil is chosen and then you wait for years. Nobody pours anything under a mature apple tree. So far this route hasn't worked for porcini or chanterelles. The large-scale bolete growing in China is another species, Phlebopus portentosus, and proves nothing about porcini.
What you can do in your own garden
If you already have old oaks, pines or spruces, look after them. Don't put nitrogen fertiliser underneath, as excess nitrogen is thought to harm chanterelles. Porcini may turn up by themselves under such trees, but nobody can promise that. Whatever appears on its own stays out of the kitchen until an experienced forager has checked it in person. The photo identifier can suggest what it might be, but a photo is never grounds for eating a mushroom. If someone has eaten a doubtful mushroom, call 112 (999 in the UK) straight away, and see our article on mushroom poisoning.
What really grows outdoors
The mushrooms with a good record outdoors are the ones that feed on dead matter:
- oyster mushrooms on logs and stumps, in shade, often in the first year;
- shiitake on oak or hornbeam logs, about a year after inoculation, always cooked through;
- wine caps (Stropharia rugosoannulata) on wood-chip mulch or straw, fruiting 2 to 6 months later if it's warm and lasting several seasons (the German Mycological Society notes they often cause stomach upsets, so start with a small portion);
- lion's mane on beech stumps, first fruiting in about the second year.
You'll find the steps in our guide to growing mushrooms on logs and stumps. If you'd rather start indoors, see how to grow mushrooms at home.
Mushrooms in this article
Frequently asked questions
Can you grow porcini at home?
Nobody has yet shown a reliable way. Scientists colonise seedling roots with porcini, but no mushrooms have been reported from those plantings. They may appear by themselves under mature trees, but no one can promise that.
Do soaked caps poured under a tree work?
We found no controlled test that confirms it. If a mushroom appears later, only DNA could link the two, since the fungus may have been there already.
Do porcini growing kits work?
We found no independent test of what's in them. No one has shown porcini fruiting from pure mycelium, so don't count on a crop.
Why aren't porcini grown like oyster mushrooms?
Because they live with a living tree and take sugars from it. Oyster mushrooms eat dead wood, so a log or straw is enough. Sawdust in a bag isn't enough for porcini.
Will porcini grow in a cellar or greenhouse?
Not in a cellar, as there's no living tree. In a greenhouse there's only a laboratory-style experiment with a chanterelle in a pot with a pine, and no such result for porcini.
Has anyone ever grown chanterelles?
Yes, in a greenhouse: an experiment published in 1997 produced them in a pot with a pine. It led to no commercial use, which is why chanterelles still aren't farmed. A related species has fruited in pots in Japan.
Which trees do porcini grow under?
Spruce, pine, oak, chestnut and others. No tree guarantees them, and they usually fruit in mature woodland.
Why are truffles farmed but not porcini?
Truffles took on seedlings that are checked and then planted on chosen soil, and the first crop from a controlled planting came in 1977. The same route hasn't yet produced porcini.
What mushrooms can you really grow in a garden?
Oyster mushrooms and shiitake on logs, wine caps on mulch, and lion's mane on beech stumps. All of them feed on dead matter, not on a living tree. The German Mycological Society notes that wine caps often cause stomach upsets, so try a small portion first.
Related articles
Growing mushroomsMushroom logs and stumps: growing oyster and shiitake outdoors
Oyster mushrooms on logs and stumps are easier than you'd think, often fruiting in the first autumn. Shiitake…
November 6, 2026·8 min
Growing mushroomsHow to grow oyster mushrooms at home: block, bag and straw
You can grow oyster mushrooms at home from a ready block, or in a bag of straw heated in hot water. Step by st…
November 6, 2026·7 min
Growing mushroomsHow to grow button mushrooms at home and in a cellar
Button mushrooms are easiest to grow at home from ready-colonised compost, as making the compost yourself is v…
November 6, 2026·6 min
Sources
- Guerin-Laguette A. "Successes and challenges in the sustainable cultivation of edible mycorrhizal fungi: furthering the dream" (Mycoscience, 2021): state of porcini, chanterelle, truffle and saffron milk cap work.
- Endo N. et al. "Synthesis of Japanese Boletus edulis ectomycorrhizae with Japanese red pine" (Mycoscience, 2014): history of the experiments, "no artificial fruiting".
- Pilz D., Norvell L., Danell E., Molina R. "Ecology and Management of Commercially Harvested Chanterelle Mushrooms" (USDA Forest Service, 2003): the chanterelle experiment, tree age, nitrogen, scattering old mushrooms.
- Agueda B. et al. "Mycorrhizal synthesis between Boletus edulis species complex and rockroses" (Mycorrhiza, 2008, abstract): rockrose work.
- Ogawa W. et al. "Repeated fruiting of Japanese golden chanterelle in pot culture with host seedlings" (Mycorrhiza, 2019, abstract): fruiting in pots.
- Wan J.-N. et al. Phlebopus portentosus genome (Frontiers in Microbiology, 2021): cultivation of this species, enzyme genes.
- Johnson B. "Chinese chestnut seedling mycorrhization with porcini" (Association for Temperate Agroforestry, 2026): project in progress.
- Cornell Small Farms, "Outdoor Production", and Bonito Lab (Michigan State University) on Stropharia rugosoannulata: what grows outdoors.
- Mudge K. "Lion's Mane: a new candidate for profitable forest mushroom cultivation" (Cornell, 2015): lion's mane timings.
Porcini
Chanterelle
Oyster mushroom
Shiitake_(40828913842).webp)