Support MycoNote →

MycoNote
Want to find

Photo: Ron Pastorino (Ronpast) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

Inedible✓ Checked by an expert

Menthol brittlegillRussula albonigra

SeasonJuly – October

Passport

Hymenophore
Gilled
Cap colour
White
Size
Medium (5–15 cm)

Inedible

Most often confused with: Blackening brittlegill (conditionally edible).

Quick answers

When does it appear? Europe

Jul — Oct

Active months: July, August, September, October.

How to recognise it? Three signs

Description

The menthol brittlegill (Russula albonigra) is a stout, whitish brittlegill of beech and conifer woods whose flesh goes grey-black when cut, usually with no noticeable red stage. We advise against eating it. The Latin name simply means "white-black", and old caps turn completely black. The English name comes from a menthol-like note recorded in older books. It isn't found in every collection, so it's no reason to try one.

Is the menthol brittlegill edible?

We treat it as inedible. Some Eastern European sources list it as edible but bland, while Polish, Dutch and North American guides advise against picking it. We found no reported poisonings, but there is no solid basis for eating it either. DNA work adds one more reason: what people called R. albonigra is at least five European species that look almost the same, so nobody picking one can say which it is.

Menthol brittlegill or blackening brittlegill?

Check more than one sign, because neither is perfect alone.

  1. Gills: moderately crowded to moderately distant here, thick and very distant in the blackening brittlegill.
  2. Cut flesh: grey, then black here, though it sometimes browns first or darkens only after a few hours. The blackening brittlegill reddens first, then blackens.
  3. Age: old caps of both go black, so judge from younger ones. A weak red stage can also occur here and vanish quickly.

The blackening brittlegill is edible only with caution, and the winecork brittlegill is another close neighbour. Our guide to brittlegills sets them side by side.

Where it grows

It grows with beech, hornbeam, fir and spruce, in broadleaved, mixed and conifer woods, from summer to autumn. Its look-alike relatives go with oak, pine and birch, which may be why East European sources mention birch and pine too. Records under this name run from Scandinavia to Iberia, though some belong to those relatives.

Young white mushrooms need care

A brittlegill never has a ring or a sac at the base. The deadly death cap can have both, so lift the whole mushroom and look. If someone may have eaten a deadly mushroom, call 112 (999 in the UK) at once. See brittlegill lookalikes.

Cap

The cap is 5-15 cm across, hemispherical to flat with an inrolled margin when young, later becoming funnel-shaped. It's whitish when young, turning grey, ash-grey, then blackish with age. The surface is smooth and slightly sticky in wet weather.

Hymenophore

The gills are attached to the stem, running down it slightly, and moderately crowded to moderately distant (in R. nigricans they're thick and very distant). They're whitish when young and blacken, usually with no red stage when damaged. The spore print is white.

Stem

The stem is 3-7 cm tall and 1.5-3 cm thick, stout and cylindrical. It's white when young, grey to blackish with age. The surface is smooth, with no ring.

Flesh

The flesh is firm, fleshy and white when young. When cut, it usually blackens to grey-black, with no noticeable red stage, which is the main, though not absolute, difference from R. nigricans. The smell is weak.

Smell

Weak, with nothing distinctive.

Don’t mix them up

Menthol brittlegill lookalikes and comparison

FeatureMenthol brittlegillBlackening brittlegill
HymenophoreGilledGilled
Cap colourWhite, Grey, BlackWhite, Grey, Black
Smell—Pleasant
EdibilityInedibleConditionally edible
Full comparison: Menthol brittlegill vs Blackening brittlegill →

Other lookalikes

Compare with another mushroom

Readers’ finds · 0

Readers’ photos aren’t checked by an expert. “Confirmed” means foragers in the feed agree — not a guarantee. When in doubt, leave it.

Your find

Menthol brittlegillchange

…

Mushrooms of the same genus and habitat — to study side by side and never mix up.

Related reading

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to eat?

No, we advise against eating it. Some Eastern European sources list it as edible but bland, while Polish, Dutch and North American guides advise against picking it. We found no reported poisonings, but there is no solid basis for eating it either, so on our site it is inedible.

How do you tell it from the blackening brittlegill?

By how the flesh reacts when cut. The menthol brittlegill (R. albonigra) usually blackens to grey-black, with no noticeable red stage. The blackening brittlegill (R. nigricans) first reddens to wine-red, then blackens. There's a second clue too: the menthol brittlegill has closer gills, the blackening one distant, thick ones. The blackening brittlegill is edible only with caution, and we advise against eating the menthol brittlegill, so it is worth telling them apart.

Does it have dangerous lookalikes?

None in its own group in Europe, but any young white mushroom needs care. Deadly amanitas have white gills too, with a ring and a sac at the base, which a brittlegill never has. Lift the whole mushroom and check the base. If someone may have eaten a deadly mushroom, call 112 (999 in the UK).

Where should you look for it?

In broadleaved, mixed and conifer woods with beech, hornbeam, fir and spruce.

Where in Europe is it found?

Records under this name run from Scandinavia to Iberia. The name once covered several look-alike species, so some of those records belong to its relatives.

When should you look for it?

Summer to autumn, peaking in late summer and early autumn.

What mushrooms is it confused with?

Most often with the blackening brittlegill (R. nigricans) (see above). Also with the milk-white brittlegill (R. delica), which is white too, but they don't blacken when cut. And with milk caps (Lactarius), which ooze milky latex when cut.

Can you cook it?

We don't give recipes, because we advise against eating it. Some East European sources list it as edible, but Western guides don't recommend it.

Why is it called the menthol brittlegill?

Older books record a menthol-like note in this mushroom. Researchers found it isn't there in every collection, so it can't be used to name the mushroom, and we never ask you to try one.

Is Russula albonigra one species or several?

Several. A 2021 DNA study split the old concept into at least five European species that look almost the same. True R. albonigra grows with beech, hornbeam, fir and spruce, while its relatives go with trees such as oak, pine and birch.

Sources

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]De Lange et al. 2021: species delimitation in the Russula albonigra complex
  • [8]Naturalis, Mushrooms of the Netherlands: Russula albonigra