Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Why mushrooms turn blue when cut, and is it dangerous?

By Valeriia·Updated ·5 min read

Many boletes turn blue when cut, from the edible bay bolete to the poisonous devil's bolete. The bluing is a harmless chemical reaction, but it tells you nothing about whether a mushroom is safe.

Inkstain bolete (Cyanoboletus pulverulentus): bright yellow pores and stems darkening near the base
Photo: Björn S... · CC BY-SA 2.0 · source

Bluing when cut is a normal chemical reaction in Xerocomus boletes and in many other boletes. It is not a sign of poison, and it is not a sign of safety either: the edible bay bolete turns blue, and so does the poisonous devil's bolete. Here's why it happens, which mushrooms do it, and which features really tell them apart.

Bluing in a Xerocomus bolete when cut is a normal reaction. It doesn't tell you whether a mushroom is poisonous or safe. Let's look at why it happens and which features matter more than the colour of the cut.

Why boletes turn blue when cut

Boletes turn blue when cut or bruised because of a pigment called variegatic acid. Once the flesh is broken, an enzyme and the oxygen in the air turn it into blue compounds, often within seconds. The pigment is made in the mushroom from a related one, xerocomic acid, and it causes the bluing in many boletes, not only in Xerocomus.

In Xerocomus boletes the pores or the flesh turn blue or greenish in the same way, depending on the species: in the suede bolete it is mostly the pores.

It's the same chemistry as a cut apple or potato going brown, only the colour is different. It has nothing to do with poison.

How fast and how vividly the flesh blues depends on the species. Some Xerocomus boletes barely show any blue, while others, such as the inkstain bolete, darken almost instantly and very intensely. Its bluing is just as harmless, but the mushroom itself is best not eaten for a different reason: it accumulates arsenic. In a 2018 study the median was 160 mg per kilogram of dry weight, with a maximum of 1,300 mg. The researchers advise against eating it, and so do we.

Which mushrooms turn blue when cut?

The best-known mushrooms that turn blue when cut are boletes, the ones with a spongy layer of pores under the cap instead of gills. You are most likely to see it in the bay bolete, whose pale yellow pores turn blue-green when bruised, and in the scarletina bolete (Neoboletus luridiformis), whose yellow flesh turns dark blue almost at once. The scarletina bolete is edible only when well cooked: raw or undercooked it can cause gastroenteritis, and some people react to it even when cooked.

Some species blue very strongly. The inkstain bolete stains bluish black wherever you handle it, and the pores of the lurid bolete turn blue-black before fading to pale blue. The cornflower bolete (Gyroporus cyanescens) turns bright blue or blue-green the moment it is cut. If you do find it, please leave it where it grows.

Bluing also shows up in boletes you should never eat. The devil's bolete (Rubroboletus satanas) is seriously poisonous, and its cut flesh slowly turns pale blue. It is mostly found on chalky soil. The rooting bolete (Caloboletus radicans) has lemon-yellow pores that turn blue when touched. It is bitter and can cause severe vomiting and diarrhoea.

Does bluing mean poison?

No. This is the most important thing to remember: bluing on its own does not mean a mushroom is poisonous.

Among the boletes, some good edible species turn blue too: Xerocomus boletes, bay bolete, and some other boletes. How the colour behaves in cooking depends on the species (the lurid bolete, for example, turns black with heat), but bluing has no effect on the taste or safety of a correctly identified mushroom.

So if a mushroom you have confidently identified as a Xerocomus bolete turns blue where you cut it, there's no need to throw it out. But bluing is no proof that it is a Xerocomus bolete: other boletes blue too, including inedible ones.

Where the “blue mushroom” myth came from

The fear of bluing comes from a few genuinely dangerous boletes that also turn blue, such as the devil's bolete, which has red pores, and the rooting bolete, which has yellow ones.

But what gives them away isn't the bluing but other features: red or orange pores, a pale whitish cap, a strong unpleasant smell. Pore colour alone is not enough, because the rooting bolete has yellow pores. Bluing by itself has nothing to do with it, since both edible and inedible mushrooms turn blue.

That's why you can't go by the colour of the cut alone. A mushroom is identified by a combination of features: shape, the colour of the cap and pores, the stem, the smell and where it grows.

What to look at instead of the colour of the cut

To identify an edible Xerocomus bolete with confidence, check several things together.

  • Pores. In edible Xerocomus boletes they are yellow or greenish-yellow, not bright red or orange.
  • Not the taste. Don't taste wild mushrooms to identify them. As a property, edible Xerocomus boletes are mild, while hot, peppery flesh belongs to the inedible peppery bolete.
  • Cap. Dry, velvety, in brown or greenish shades.
  • Smell. A mild smell, with no chemical or rotten notes.

If all the features match, bluing on the cut shouldn't worry you. To know exactly when to head to the forest for Xerocomus boletes, check our mushroom radar: it shows when moisture and warmth line up well for mushrooms to appear.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Why does a Xerocomus bolete turn blue when cut?

Because a pigment in its flesh, variegatic acid, is oxidised by an enzyme once the flesh meets the air, and turns blue or greenish. It's an ordinary chemical reaction, similar to a cut apple going brown.

Does bluing mean a Xerocomus bolete is poisonous?

No. Bluing on its own is not a sign of poison. Many edible mushrooms, including Xerocomus boletes and the bay bolete, turn blue when cut. It is not a sign of safety either: the poisonous devil's bolete turns blue too.

Can you eat a Xerocomus bolete that has turned blue?

Bluing on its own is harmless. If every other feature fits a Xerocomus bolete, the blue is no reason to throw it out. The exception is the inkstain bolete, which turns almost black: it's best not eaten because of its high arsenic content.

Why do some Xerocomus boletes turn so intensely blue?

It depends on the species. For example, the inkstain bolete turns blue almost instantly and very intensely. How strongly it blues has no bearing on safety, but this particular mushroom is best not eaten: it accumulates a lot of arsenic.

Which dangerous mushrooms also turn blue?

The devil's bolete, which is seriously poisonous, and the rooting bolete, which can cause severe vomiting and diarrhoea, both turn blue. The devil's bolete has red pores, but the rooting bolete has yellow ones, so no single feature is enough. Check the pores, cap, stem, smell and habitat together.

How do you tell an edible Xerocomus bolete from a dangerous mushroom?

Look at the combination of features: yellow pores, a dry velvety cap and a mild smell. Red or orange pores, a pale whitish cap or a strong unpleasant smell are reasons to pass it by. Yellow pores alone prove nothing: the rooting bolete has them too.

Does the blue disappear during cooking?

Not always, it depends on the species. The lurid bolete, for example, doesn't fade when cooked but turns black. The colour has no effect on the taste or safety of a correctly identified mushroom.

Should you be afraid of bluing when picking mushrooms?

There's no need to fear bluing itself. It's far more important to check the pores, cap, stem and smell, and never by tasting. If you have any doubt about the species, it's better not to pick the mushroom.

Related articles