Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

How to tell Ugly milk cap from Brown rollrim

Brown rollrim is deadly poisonous

Ugly milk cap and Brown rollrim look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Ugly milk cap is poisonous, while Brown rollrim is deadly poisonous. The main visible difference: size: Ugly milk cap — large (over 15 cm), Brown rollrim — medium (5–15 cm). If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Ugly milk capBrown rollrim
Comparison of characteristics: Ugly milk cap and Brown rollrim
Edibility classUgly milk cap: PoisonousBrown rollrim: Deadly poisonous
SizeUgly milk cap: Large (over 15 cm)Brown rollrim: Medium (5–15 cm)
Cap colourUgly milk cap: Olive, Black, Dark brownBrown rollrim: Brown, Olive
Cap shapeUgly milk cap: Funnel-shapedBrown rollrim: Concave, Funnel-shaped
Cap surfaceUgly milk cap: SlimyBrown rollrim: Dry, Velvety, Slimy
TasteUgly milk cap: AcridBrown rollrim: Unknown
StemUgly milk cap: CentralBrown rollrim: Central, Solid
Partner treesUgly milk cap: BirchBrown rollrim: Birch, Aspen, Oak, Spruce, Pine
Growth habitUgly milk cap: In groups, SolitaryBrown rollrim: In groups

Same in both: season, use, smell, flesh colour change, hymenophore, substrate, nutrition type.

When and where they meet

Together: August–November

Their seasons overlap: August–November. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: deciduous forest, mixed forest.

Ugly milk cap

Fruiting season

August – November

Brown rollrim

Fruiting season

August – November

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Ugly milk cap

The cap is 6–15 (up to 20) cm across, making this a large, fleshy milk cap. It starts convex with an inrolled, fuzzy margin, then flattens and finally becomes funnel-shaped with a sunken centre. The colour is dark olive, olive-black or brownish-black; young caps have a yellow-green tinge, old ones are almost black. In wet weather the surface is very sticky and slimy; in dry weather it's shiny, with darker concentric zones. In young mushrooms the margin is densely downy.

Brown rollrim

Cap 4–15 cm across, convex when young, then depressed and funnel-shaped. Yellow brown, ochre brown, rusty or olive brown, felty at first, smoother with age, sticky in wet weather. The felty margin stays rolled under for a long time, which is where the name comes from.

Hymenophore

Ugly milk cap

The gills are crowded, narrow, adnate or slightly decurrent, pale yellow to cream, taking on a dark olive tinge with age. Where damaged they darken to brown or black, a characteristic reaction. They exude white milk. The spore print is cream.

Brown rollrim

Gills crowded and thin, pale ochre to yellowish brown, running down the stem. They turn rusty brown almost at once when pressed and peel away from the cap easily. Spore print brown, from rusty to olive brown.

Stem

Ugly milk cap

The stem is 3–8 cm tall and 1–3 cm thick, cylindrical or thickening toward the base, solid when young and often hollow later. It's paler than the cap, olive-yellow to dingy olive, often with characteristic dark “scrobicules” (sunken pits). It's also sticky in wet weather. There's no ring and no volva.

Brown rollrim

Stem 4–10 cm tall, 1–2.5 cm thick, short, firm and central, cylindrical or tapering downward, the colour of the cap or a little paler. It darkens when bruised. No ring and no volva.

Flesh

Ugly milk cap

The flesh is whitish to yellowish and firm, slowly darkening to grey-brown when cut. Any damage releases plenty of white milk that doesn't change colour in the air but leaves dark stains on the mushroom. With alkali (KOH) it turns violet-black, another diagnostic feature.

Brown rollrim

Flesh pale yellowish to brownish, firm in young mushrooms and softer later, turning reddish brown when cut. There's no milk, which helps separate it from milkcaps.

Smell

Ugly milk cap

The smell is faint, neutral, slightly resinous; old mushrooms can smell dirty and earthy. Raw, the flesh and milk taste extremely acrid, bitter and hot. Do not taste it raw.

Brown rollrim

No distinctive smell, at most a mild mushroomy one. Nothing about it warns you of the danger.

Related comparisons

Sources · 18

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund: Normlisten 2024 (2024)
  • [8]von Wright A., Suortti T. et al. 1983: mutagenicity of necatorin (Mutation Research)
  • [9]Suortti T. 1984: Stability of necatorin, a highly mutagenic compound from Lactarius necator (Food Chem Toxicol 22: 579)
  • [10]DGfM: Liste der Giftpilze nach Taxa (Stand 01.05.2026)
  • [11]first-nature: Paxillus involutus
  • [12]Mushrooms traded as food, Nordic Council of Ministers
  • [13]Funga Nordica: Paxillus (Knudsen & Taylor 2008)
  • [14]Stöver A. et al. Fatal Immunohaemolysis after the Consumption of the Poison Pax Mushroom. Diagnostics, 2019, 9(4): 130, Stöver A., Haberl B., Helmreich C. et al. (2019)
  • [15]Winkelmann M. et al. Severe hemolysis caused by antibodies against the mushroom Paxillus involutus and its therapy by plasma exchange. Klinische Wochenschrift, 1986, Winkelmann M., Stangel W., Schedel I., Grabensee B. (1986)
  • [16]Winkelmann M. et al. Fatal immunohaemolytic anaemia after eating the mushroom Paxillus involutus. Dtsch Med Wochenschr, 1982, Winkelmann M., Borchard F., Stangel W., Grabensee B. (1982)
  • [17]Foraging guide: brown rollrim
  • [18]Winkelmann M. et al. 1982: Fatal immunohaemolytic anaemia after eating the mushroom Paxillus involutus