Genus
Elfin saddles (Helvella)
Mushrooms in the taxonomic group “Helvella”. 5 species in the database.
Elfin saddles (Helvella) are a genus of ascomycete fungi whose caps bend into a saddle or a few loose lobes, on a stem that is either deeply ribbed or quite smooth. They are related to morels and false morels and often mistaken for both. The best known is Helvella crispa, the white saddle, a creamy white fungus of autumn broadleaf woods. Whether elfin saddles are edible is disputed, so our advice is to leave them in the woods. Five species from this genus are on our site.

Elastic saddle
Helvella elastica
Inedible
Elfin saddle
Helvella lacunosa
Inedible
Helvella monachella
Inedible
Vinegar cup
Helvella acetabulum
Inedible
White saddle
Helvella crispa
Inedible
What Helvella mushrooms are
Helvella belongs to the Pezizales, the ascomycete order of morels, false morels and cup fungi, in a family of its own, the Helvellaceae. Most species look like a small saddle or a crumpled handkerchief on a stalk; a few form a deep cup on a short, ribbed base.
Our species and how to tell them apart
Helvella crispa is creamy white and 6–13 cm tall. Its cap is 2–6 cm across with irregular lobes, and the white stem is deeply ribbed and furrowed. It fruits from late summer to late autumn in grass and damp broadleaf woods, especially beech; in Ukraine, from July to November in broadleaf and mixed woods. Pale forms of Helvella lacunosa look similar, but H. crispa has a downy underside to the cap and, when young, an inrolled margin.
Helvella lacunosa, called the elfin saddle in Britain, is the dark one: a folded, waxy-looking cap 2–5 cm across, slate grey to black, on a chambered stem 3–15 cm tall. It often grows on burnt ground, from late summer into autumn. It is really a cluster of similar species, already split into several in North America.
The elastic saddle (Helvella elastica) is a small grey to olive-brown saddle up to 3.5 cm across on a smooth white stem up to 8 cm tall. It appears in summer and autumn.
The vinegar cup (Helvella acetabulum) is no saddle but a deep cup up to 8 cm across, with ribs running from the base almost to the rim, and it grows in spring and summer, often on sandy soil.
Helvella monachella is rare; more on it under protection below.
Are elfin saddles edible?
We treat every Helvella as inedible and advise against eating them, although expert sources disagree.
The German Mycological Society's list of edible fungi (2026) contains no Helvella, and neither does Poland's list of mushrooms allowed for sale. Norway's 2024 list accepts just one, Helvella lacunosa; none of the three lists accepts Helvella crispa, the elastic saddle or the vinegar cup. The US Food and Drug Administration groups Helvella with Gyromitra among the toxic false morels. On the other hand, the Ukrainian guide by Wasser (1990) calls H. crispa conditionally edible and of low quality.
Raw Helvella crispa and Helvella lacunosa cause stomach upsets. Whether elfin saddles contain gyromitrin, the poison of false morels, is not known for certain. Many sources say they contain it or may do, but nobody has done thorough chemical analysis of Helvella, so for now it is a suspicion, not a measured fact. Nor is there evidence that cooking removes it. The elastic saddle is described as not recommended, and the vinegar cup as of unknown edibility by some authors and poisonous by others.
How Helvella differs from false morels and true morels
A true morel's cap is covered in pits like a honeycomb. Cut one lengthwise: in a true morel the cap and stem form one continuous hollow (the steppe morel is the exception, with a stem that can be chambered). Morels are spring fungi, mostly found in April and May across Europe.
A false morel has no honeycomb. Its cap is wrinkled like a brain, and in section it is divided into chambers. It is a spring fungus too, and no cooking method makes it safe.
An elfin saddle has neither a honeycomb nor a brain: its cap is bent into a saddle, folds or lobes. The stem of H. crispa is deeply ribbed and that of H. lacunosa is chambered inside, so a single cut won't settle it; look at the cap. Most elfin saddles also appear in autumn, not spring. If you aren't sure you are holding a true morel, leave it.
Where and when elfin saddles grow across Europe
GBIF holds almost 95,000 European records of Helvella, mostly from the Netherlands, Britain, Sweden, Denmark and Germany, where more people record fungi. Nearly half are Helvella crispa. Two thirds of records fall between September and November, peaking in October, with a smaller wave in April and May. The Netherlands, Britain, Denmark, Germany, France and Switzerland peak in October; Sweden and Finland earlier, in September; Norway as early as August. In Spain records spread from autumn to spring, with the most in April.
Of about 500 Ukrainian records, only around 65 are identified to species. The vinegar cup has 23, from May and June; H. crispa 16, from August to December; H. lacunosa 11; H. monachella 10; and the elastic saddle just 5.
Protected elfin saddles
Helvella monachella is listed in the Red Data Book of Ukraine, so please leave it where it grows. GBIF has only about 290 records of it from the whole of Europe, and 10 from Ukraine, in the Odesa, Kyiv, Cherkasy and Kharkiv regions. One was found in Kholodnyi Yar National Nature Park, the first record for the Cherkasy region. No other Helvella is protected in Ukraine. If you find it, take a photo and leave it be.
Questions and answers
The short answers
Are elfin saddles edible?
We treat all elfin saddles as inedible and advise against eating them. The German and Polish lists of edible mushrooms include no Helvella, Norway's accepts only Helvella lacunosa, and raw Helvella crispa and H. lacunosa cause stomach upsets.
Is Helvella crispa poisonous?
Helvella crispa causes stomach upsets when raw, and it is suspected, though not proven by chemical analysis, of containing gyromitrin, the false morel toxin. No edible-mushroom list we checked accepts it, so we advise against eating it.
How do elfin saddles differ from false morels and true morels?
An elfin saddle's cap is bent into a saddle, folds or lobes, with neither the honeycomb pits of a true morel nor the brain-like wrinkles of a false morel. Morels and false morels fruit in spring, most elfin saddles in autumn.
Where and when do elfin saddles grow?
Most elfin saddles appear in autumn: two thirds of European records fall between September and November, peaking in October. Helvella crispa grows in grass and damp broadleaf woods, especially beech, while the vinegar cup appears in spring and summer.
Can you pick Helvella monachella?
Not in Ukraine: Helvella monachella is listed in the Red Data Book of Ukraine so please leave it where it grows. If you find it, take a photo and leave it be.
Sources
Normlisten 2024 (Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund); DGfM Positivliste der Speisepilze (2026); Polish Minister of Health regulation on mushrooms admitted to trade (2026): lists of edible mushrooms.
Lagrange E., Vernoux J.-P. (Toxins, 2020, vol. 12, no. 8): Helvella among the false morels in the FDA grouping.
Dirks A.C. et al. (Mycologia, 2023, vol. 115, no. 1): which fungi have been tested for gyromitrin and where it was found.
Ruokavirasto, Finnish Food Authority (2025): false morel toxin after boiling.
Order No. 111 of the Ministry of Environment of Ukraine, 15.02.2021: the Red Data Book of Ukraine.
Pluzhnyk A., Dzhahan V. (Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, Biology, 2024, no. 97(2)): Helvella monachella in Kholodnyi Yar National Nature Park.
First Nature, morel page: the lengthwise cut and the hollow.
English Wikipedia articles on Helvella crispa, Helvella lacunosa, Helvella elastica, Helvella acetabulum, the Pezizales, morels, Morchella steppicola and Gyromitra esculenta; Ukrainian Wikipedia article on Helvella crispa (after Wasser, 1990).
GBIF: records of Helvella in Europe and Ukraine by country, species and month.