Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Bay bolete vs. porcini: what's the difference?

By Valeriia·Updated ·4 min read

The bay bolete is often sold as porcini, but it's a different species. Here's how to tell them apart by one simple feature, and why the mix-up is no mistake, just something worth knowing.

Bay bolete (Imleria badia): a chestnut-brown cap on a brown stem among reindeer lichen
Photo: Włodzimierz Wysocki · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

At the market you'll often hear someone calling, “Porcini, get your porcini!” Yet in the basket, next to the classic boletes, sit mushrooms with dark chestnut caps and a slightly different look. That's the bay bolete (Boletus badius, now Imleria badia, listed in our catalogue as the bay bolete), a close relative of porcini that's often sold under the same name.

It's not a scam or a mistake: the bay bolete really is tasty and well liked. But as a forager it's worth knowing that it's a separate species with its own telltale feature. Let's settle the question once and for all.

Is the bay bolete a porcini or not?

The short answer is no. They're different species, though close relatives. True porcini (ceps) have white flesh that doesn't change colour when cut. The bay bolete belongs to the same bolete family, but it has been split off into its own genus, Imleria, and its pores turn blue quickly when pressed.

So why do people mix them up? Both are tasty and aromatic, with a spongy underside to the cap and a thick stem. On the plate you'd barely notice the difference, so cooks often treat them as equals. In the forest, though, it pays to tell them apart so you can name your finds with confidence.

Is porcini a bolete?

Yes. Porcini is the name for Boletus edulis and its close group, so every porcini is a bolete, but not every bolete is a porcini. The pine bolete (Boletus pinophilus) belongs to that group and was split from Boletus edulis: it has a dark red-brown cap and grows almost only with pine.

The main difference: bluing when cut

Remember just one thing and you'll never mix these two up: press a finger on the pores under the cap, or cut the mushroom open.

  • Porcini. The flesh stays white, and the pores (white when young, yellow to olive with age) don't change colour when pressed. At most, pine bolete pores may turn faintly blue-green.
  • Bay bolete. The pores quickly turn blue where you press them, sometimes almost blue-green. The cut flesh may turn slightly blue too.

This bluing is completely harmless; the bay bolete is edible and tasty. But it's exactly what sets it apart from true porcini. If a mushroom turns clearly blue, it's very unlikely to be a porcini, though in this case there's nothing to worry about.

Other differences worth a look

Besides the bluing, a few more details help tell the two apart.

  • Cap. The bay bolete's is an even dark chestnut, smooth, and greasy in wet weather. Porcini caps are warmer in tone, from hazel to chestnut, depending on the variety.
  • Stem. The bay bolete has a slender, brownish stem with no distinct net pattern. Porcini have a thick, barrel-shaped stem with a pale net.
  • Pores. White or yellow on porcini; greenish yellow on the bay bolete, turning blue when touched.

A stem with no net plus bluing make a reliable pair of features. To see the difference clearly, check out our side-by-side comparison of porcini and the bay bolete.

Where and when they overlap

The bay bolete favours conifer and mixed forests, so the mushroom you'll most often find beside it is the pine bolete.

Look for it in the same places as porcini:

  • old mossy pine forests;
  • patches of mixed forest where pine grows alongside birch;
  • sunny edges of conifer forest and sun-warmed sandy hills.

The bay bolete's season starts later and lasts longer: it fruits from July into late autumn, sometimes right up to the first frosts. The best time to go out is roughly one and a half to three weeks after a warm rain. To keep track of these windows, try our mushroom radar: it shows when moisture and warmth line up just right for boletes to appear.

Is the bay bolete worth picking?

Absolutely. It's tasty and aromatic, and great for drying, pickling and frying. Many foragers rate it as highly as porcini, and to them the bluing isn't a flaw, just a trait of the species.

Just don't confuse the bay bolete's harmless bluing with the bluing of boletes that are poisonous raw and not for beginners, such as the lurid bolete. When in doubt, go by the colour of the pores and stem, and if you're not sure, leave the mushroom in the forest.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Is the bay bolete a porcini?

No. It's a close relative of porcini, but a separate species. The main difference: the bay bolete's flesh and pores turn blue when cut or pressed, while those of true porcini don't change: the flesh stays white, and the pores, white at first and yellow to olive with age, don't turn blue when pressed.

How does the bay bolete differ from porcini?

The bay bolete turns blue when cut, has a slender stem with no distinct net pattern and an evenly dark chestnut cap. Porcini flesh doesn't turn blue, and the stem is thick with a pale net pattern.

Why does the bay bolete turn blue when cut?

It's a natural, completely harmless reaction of the flesh to air: special compounds in it oxidise where it's cut. For the bay bolete it's a normal trait of the species, not a sign of spoilage.

Is the bay bolete edible?

Yes, it's tasty and well regarded. People dry it, pickle it and fry it, and many foragers rank it alongside porcini. Bluing when cut doesn't affect taste or safety.

Can the bay bolete be confused with a dangerous mushroom?

The bay bolete itself is a good edible mushroom, but other boletes turn blue too, such as the lurid bolete, which is poisonous raw and not for beginners, and the poisonous devil's bolete. So go by the colour of the pores and stem, and if in doubt, don't pick the mushroom.

Where does the bay bolete grow?

Mostly in conifer and mixed forests under pine, less often under spruce and broadleaf trees. It loves old mossy pine forests and sun-warmed sandy hills.

When should you pick the bay bolete?

The season runs from July into late autumn, sometimes until the first frosts, which makes it one of the latest boletes. Go out roughly one and a half to three weeks after a warm rain, using the mushroom forecast as your guide.

Is porcini tastier than the bay bolete?

That's a matter of taste. Porcini have a more delicate, classic aroma; the bay bolete's is a little richer. Both are wonderful in the kitchen, which is why many foragers pick them together.

How can you quickly tell the bay bolete from porcini in the forest?

Press the underside of the cap. If yellow pores turn blue and the stem is brown with no net, it's most likely a bay bolete; but other boletes turn blue too, so the pore colour and the stem count as much as the bluing. If the colour doesn't change and the stem has a pale net pattern, you're looking at true porcini.

Related articles