MycoNote

This English version was machine-translated from Ukrainian, so a few things may read a little off.

"Pecherytsia" or champignon: are they the same thing?

·2 min read

The store-bought champignon and the wild forest *pecherytsia* — relatives or different mushrooms? We explain where the two names come from, how wild Agaricus differs from cultivated, and why it's the wild one you need

Field mushroom in the grass
Photo: Lazaregagnidze · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

When buying “champignons” at the store, few people remember that they're simply *pecherytsia* — the same genus of mushrooms (Agaricus), only domesticated. Two names, one mushroom.

Where the two names come from

  • *Pecherytsia* is the native Ukrainian name for the whole genus Agaricus, both wild and cultivated species.
  • *Shampinion* is a borrowing from French (*champignon* simply means “mushroom”), which in Ukraine stuck to the cultivated, store-bought kind.

So the correct Ukrainian word is *pecherytsia*. *Shampinion* is the same *pecherytsia*, just grown in a greenhouse.

Wild Agaricus vs store-bought

The store-bought kind is mostly the button mushroom, grown under controlled conditions. In the wild there's a whole family of wild Agaricus species: the field mushroom, the horse mushroom, the blushing wood mushroom. They're tastier and more fragrant, but you need to know how to identify them. For a full overview, see our piece on Agaricus species.

The main danger of wild Agaricus

You can't mistake the store-bought kind for anything — it's safe. But **a young white wild Agaricus is easy to confuse with the deadly death cap**. Two features will save you:

  • Agaricus gills turn pink, then brown; in the death cap they're always white;
  • at the base of an Agaricus stem there is no volva and no bulb, while the death cap has them.

We've written in detail about how to tell Agaricus from the death cap in a separate article. Also avoid any Agaricus that turns sharply yellow when broken and smells unpleasant.

Sources

  • “Identification Guide to the Fungi of Ukraine” (Kyiv, Naukova Dumka publishing house).
  • Agaricus bisporus and Agaricus campestris in GBIF, the global biodiversity database.
  • Agaricus on Wikipedia.

Frequently asked questions

Pecherytsia or champignon — which is correct?

In Ukrainian, the correct word is *pecherytsia*. *Shampinion* is a French borrowing that stuck to the store-bought kind of the same mushroom.

Are they the same thing?

Yes, it's the same genus of mushrooms (Agaricus). The store-bought champignon is a domesticated button mushroom.

How does wild Agaricus differ from store-bought?

The wild kind grows in nature (field, horse, wood mushrooms); it's more fragrant, but you need to know how to identify it. The store-bought kind is greenhouse-grown and safe.

Are all wild Agaricus edible?

Most are, but there are poisonous species that turn sharply yellow when broken and smell unpleasant. Leave those mushrooms alone.

How not to confuse Agaricus with the death cap?

Agaricus gills turn pink and then brown, and there's no volva at the base of the stem. The death cap's gills are always white, and it has a sac-like volva.

Why is the champignon called that?

The French *champignon* simply means “mushroom”. In Ukraine the word stuck to the cultivated Agaricus.

Mushrooms in this article

Related articles