Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Types of Agaricus mushrooms: field, wood, horse and cultivated

By Valeriia·Updated ·6 min read

Agaricus isn’t just the supermarket mushroom: several edible species grow wild, from the field mushroom to the wood mushroom. But there are dangerous lookalikes among them. Here are the main types of Agaricus.

Field mushroom (Agaricus campestris): two white caps in grass, the overturned one showing brown gills
Photo: Lazaregagnidze · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

Agaricus mushrooms are the "true mushrooms": the supermarket button mushroom plus dozens of wild species, including the field mushroom of pastures, the aniseed-scented horse mushroom, the wood mushroom, The Prince and the blushing wood mushroom. Several are excellent to eat, but the yellow stainer and the inky mushroom are poisonous.

Let's go through the main types of Agaricus and the reliable features that keep you safe.

Common field mushrooms

A common mushroom of fields is the field mushroom (Agaricus campestris). It grows among grass in pastures, playing fields and parks from early summer to autumn.

The horse mushroom (Agaricus arvensis) is the other edible field mushroom you are likely to meet. It is fairly frequent in manured meadows and beside bridle paths from late summer to late autumn. The pavement mushroom (Agaricus bitorquis) is uncommon to rare and comes up on dry, trodden soil beside footpaths, sometimes even through tarmac.

The same grassy places, especially hedgerows and park edges, also grow the poisonous yellow stainer. So check every grassland Agaricus with the yellow stainer test further down.

  • Field mushroom: a classic of meadows and pastures, with a white cap, pink gills that turn brown with age, and a pleasant mushroomy smell. The most common wild Agaricus.
  • Horse mushroom: bigger, with a ring on the stem and a smell of aniseed and almond. It grows in meadows, along forest edges and in gardens.

Both are excellent edible mushrooms.

Blushing wood mushroom

It grows mainly in conifer woods, especially under spruce, from late summer to late autumn. The cap has brown scales, and the flesh turns slightly red when broken, though other species redden too, so this alone proves nothing. It's tasty, but woodland Agaricus species are exactly the ones that need the most care to identify.

Other woodland Agaricus species

Besides the blushing wood mushroom, two edible woodland species are worth knowing. The wood mushroom (Agaricus sylvicola) grows in all kinds of woodland from late summer to late autumn. It smells of aniseed, its smooth white cap slowly turns ochre where bruised, and its gills are white at first, which is why it is the one most easily confused with deadly white amanitas.

The Prince (Agaricus augustus) is a big mushroom, with a cap of 10 to 25 cm covered in brown scales. Young ones smell strongly of bitter almonds. It is far from common, turning up in open woodland and under parkland trees, especially conifers, from summer to late autumn. It is rated a fine edible, though a few people have reacted badly to it.

The commonest woodland Agaricus of all is not edible: the inky mushroom (Agaricus moelleri) of deciduous woods and hedgerows. It is described with the yellow stainer below.

Cultivated Agaricus

The store-bought mushroom (button mushroom) is a domesticated relative of the wild species. It's grown indoors, so there's no chance of a mix-up, which makes it the safest way to eat Agaricus.

What is Agaricus blazei?

"Agaricus blazei" is a mistaken name for Agaricus subrufescens, the almond mushroom, a cultivated species that is mostly sold as a health supplement. Its health claims are unproven. It may cause allergic reactions, and liver problems have been reported, mostly with extracts, though the evidence is mixed.

How to recognise an Agaricus mushroom

An Agaricus has free, crowded gills that are whitish or pink at first and turn chocolate brown, then almost black, as it matures. It leaves a chocolate-brown spore print, has a ring (or the remains of one) on the stem, and has no volva at the base.

There are hundreds of Agaricus species worldwide, many more than the field mushroom and the cultivated mushroom. Many are hard to tell apart, so learn the few common ones well and leave the rest.

Deadly lookalikes: death cap and destroying angel

Two deadly amanitas can be picked by mistake for a white Agaricus. The death cap (Amanita phalloides) grows under broadleaved trees, especially oaks, from summer to late autumn, and an all-white form exists. A single mushroom can be enough to kill an adult. The first symptoms usually appear 8 to 12 hours after the meal, but anywhere from 4 to 36 hours, and often fade for a while, which can fool people into thinking they are recovering. Earlier symptoms after a mixed mushroom dish do not rule out a death cap.

The destroying angel (Amanita virosa) is pure white. It grows in damp woods, often coniferous, on acid soil, from late summer to late autumn; it is rare in the lowlands and more frequent in hilly country. Young caps can be mistaken for the wood mushroom, and it can also grow by fields bordered with trees, where people look for field mushrooms. Its volva is often buried deep in the soil, so always lift the whole stem base out of the ground before you decide.

A young white Agaricus is most easily confused with the death cap. The key differences:

  • Agaricus gills turn pink, then brown; in the death cap they are white to cream, never brown.
  • An Agaricus has no volva at the base of the stem, though some species have a swollen base; the death cap has a bulb wrapped in a sac-like volva.

Our separate article explains how to tell Agaricus from the death cap in more detail. Also steer clear of Agaricus mushrooms that turn chrome yellow at the cut stem base and smell of ink or phenol: that is the poisonous yellow stainer, described below.

How to recognise the poisonous yellow stainer

The yellow stainer (Agaricus xanthodermus) is the poisonous Agaricus most often mistaken for a field or horse mushroom. It occurs from early summer to autumn, mostly under hedgerows and at the edges of parks, gardens and other disturbed ground.

Scratch the cap and cut the stem right at the base. In a yellow stainer the flesh turns chrome yellow within moments, most strongly at the stem base, and the mushroom smells of ink, phenol or iodine. The edible horse and wood mushrooms also turn yellowish, but slowly and only slightly, and they smell of aniseed. The field mushroom does not turn yellow at all.

The inky mushroom (Agaricus moelleri) gives the same quick yellowing at the stem base and an inky, carbolic smell. It grows in deciduous woods and under hedgerows from summer to late autumn, and it can upset the stomach even after thorough cooking.

Eating a yellow stainer can cause stomach cramps, nausea, vomiting, sweating and diarrhoea. If you suspect any mushroom poisoning, call emergency services on 112 (999 in the UK) or your local poison centre straight away, and keep a piece of the mushroom to show the doctors.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

What types of Agaricus are there?

Wild ones (the field, horse and wood mushrooms) plus the cultivated one, the button mushroom you buy in stores. Not all are edible: the yellow stainer and the inky mushroom, which turn chrome yellow at the cut stem base, are poisonous, and wild ones must be told apart from their deadly lookalikes.

Which Agaricus is the most common?

The field mushroom, a meadow and pasture classic with a white cap and pink gills that turn brown with age.

How do you tell Agaricus from the death cap?

Agaricus gills turn pink, then brown, and there's no volva at the base of the stem; the death cap's gills are white to cream and never turn brown, and it has a volva with a bulb.

Are all Agaricus mushrooms edible?

No. The yellow stainer and the inky mushroom are poisonous: their stem base turns chrome yellow as soon as it is cut, and they smell of ink or phenol. The edible horse and wood mushrooms yellow only slowly and slightly, and smell of aniseed.

Where do wild Agaricus mushrooms grow?

Field and horse mushrooms grow in meadows, pastures, along forest edges and in gardens; the wood mushroom grows in all kinds of woodland, and the blushing wood mushroom mainly in conifer woods, especially under spruce.

How is the store-bought mushroom different from wild ones?

It's a domesticated species (the button mushroom) grown indoors, so there's no risk of confusing it with a poisonous mushroom.

Why do wood Agaricus mushrooms need more care?

Because young white ones are easier to mistake for the death cap, and poisonous lookalikes grow nearby in the forest. Always check the gills and the base of the stem.

What does it mean if an Agaricus turns yellow when broken?

Quick chrome-yellow staining, strongest at the cut stem base, plus a smell of ink, phenol or iodine points to the poisonous yellow stainer or inky mushroom. The edible horse mushroom also yellows, but slowly and only slightly, and it smells of aniseed. If in doubt, leave it.

Related articles