Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Grey knight: how to identify it, and is it edible?

By Valeriia·Updated ·5 min read

The grey knight is a small mouse-grey Tricholoma that carpets pine woods in late autumn. Here is how to recognise it, how it differs from Tricholoma portentosum, and what is really known about its toxicity.

Grey knight (Tricholoma terreum): grey caps, white gills and stems in grass
Photo: User:Strobilomyces · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

The grey knight (Tricholoma terreum), also spelled gray knight, is a small mouse-grey mushroom that carpets the ground under pines in autumn. In our atlas it has its own species card. One of its old scientific synonyms, Tricholoma myomyces, means "mouse mushroom".

In some field guides the name "grey tricholoma" belongs to a different, larger mushroom, and the two should not be confused. Below is how to recognise the grey knight, how it differs from similar tricholomas, and what researchers have learned about its edibility over the last ten years.

How to recognise the grey knight

  • Cap 3–10 cm, mouse-grey, felty-fibrous and dry, not sticky. Conical in young mushrooms, then opening out, but a bump remains in the centre.
  • Gills white, greyish with age, notched where they meet the stem.
  • Stem white, straight, with no ring.
  • Flesh thin and brittle.
  • Smell and taste indistinct, with no mealy smell. This is an important sign: similar grey tricholomas and fibrecaps often smell of flour or earth.
  • Spore print white.

Grey knights grow in groups under pines on sandy and limestone soils, often along forest tracks and paths. The season runs through autumn, and in southern pine plantations even into early winter.

Grey knight or Tricholoma portentosum

In some field guides, "grey tricholoma" means Tricholoma portentosum (sometimes called the charbonnier); in our atlas it has its own card. It is larger than the grey knight, with dark radial fibres on the cap and a yellowish tint on the gills and stem. Both mushrooms grow in pine woods in late autumn, and people often call them by the same name. So if someone tells you about a "grey tricholoma", it is worth asking exactly which mushroom they mean.

Is the grey knight edible?

The grey knight has long been gathered as an edible mushroom. But in 2014 its reputation was shaken, and it is worth knowing how the story unfolded.

  • 2014. Chinese chemists isolated new substances, saponaceolides, from grey knights collected in France. Two of them proved toxic when given to mice in large doses and damaged their muscles. The authors suggested that the grey knight might cause rhabdomyolysis, a breakdown of muscle tissue, like the yellow knight (Tricholoma equestre).
  • 2016. Italian mycologists and toxicologists disputed these conclusions on mycological and toxicological grounds. Their position: the species should remain among the edible ones. The authors of the first study replied that these substances withstand prolonged heating. According to one recalculation, for harm to appear in half of people, a person weighing 70 kg would have to eat about 46 kg of fresh mushrooms.
  • 2024. Italian chemists tested grey knights whose identity had been confirmed by DNA analysis and did not find most of the toxins described in 2014. Only one saponaceolide remained, one known from another tricholoma, and according to their data it breaks down when heated. Their conclusion: the grey knight should be considered edible, and the differences between samples show how important it is to identify the species precisely.

We found no cases of people being poisoned by the grey knight specifically. In Italy it is on the list of mushrooms permitted for sale. Norway's Normlisten rates it edible. The British atlas First Nature nevertheless advises against picking it, and Germany's mycological society, which earlier listed it as suspected of causing muscle breakdown, now includes it in its list of edible mushrooms. We found no report that it's psychoactive.

Our verdict: in our catalogue the grey knight is conditionally edible. It is traditionally eaten and the latest data are reassuring, though European sources still differ. But eat it in moderation, well cooked, and only when you are sure it really is the grey knight.

The main danger: tiger tricholoma

The real risk with grey knights is not the mushroom itself but the tiger tricholoma (Tricholoma pardinum), which is also grey and also grows in autumn.

  • It is larger: the cap is 5–15 cm, dense and heavy.
  • The cap is whitish or greyish, covered with dark scales arranged in rings, like tiger stripes. The grey knight's cap is felty, without such scales.
  • The gills are white, then yellowish, sometimes with a greenish tint.
  • It often smells strongly of flour.
  • It grows mainly under beech, fir and spruce, often on limestone soils.

The tiger tricholoma causes severe digestive upset that begins within a few hours of eating. More in the article poisonous tricholomas: tiger tricholoma and others.

Two more similar mushrooms:

  • Ashen knight (Tricholoma virgatum): a sharp bump on the cap and dark streaks. The flesh is bitter and peppery, and the mushroom is inedible.
  • Grey fibrecaps (Inocybe): they have a brown spore print, and the smell is often earthy or unpleasant. They contain muscarine and are poisonous.

A quick rule for the grey knight

White spore print, no mealy smell, a felty grey cap without "tiger" scales, under pines: that is the grey knight. If even one sign does not match, it is better to leave the mushroom. Other tricholomas are covered in the article tricholoma species of Ukraine.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

What is the grey knight?

It is Tricholoma terreum, a small mushroom with a mouse-grey felty cap, white gills and a white stem with no ring. Grey knights grow in groups under pines in autumn.

Why is it nicknamed after mice?

Because of the mouse-grey colour of its cap. One of the species' old scientific synonyms, Tricholoma myomyces, also means "mouse mushroom".

Is the grey knight mushroom edible?

The grey knight is traditionally considered edible; in our catalogue it is conditionally edible. In 2014 a study on its toxicity in mice appeared, in 2016 its conclusions were disputed, and a 2024 study did not find most of those toxins in the grey knight. We found no cases of human poisoning. Eat it in moderation, well cooked, and only when you are confident of the identification.

Are the grey knight and Tricholoma portentosum the same mushroom?

No. In some field guides, "grey tricholoma" means Tricholoma portentosum: larger, with dark fibres on the cap and a yellowish tint on the gills. The grey knight is Tricholoma terreum: smaller, with a felty cap. People often mix them up.

How do you tell the grey knight from the tiger tricholoma?

The tiger tricholoma is larger and denser, and its whitish-grey cap is covered with dark scales arranged in rings. The grey knight's cap is felty, without such scales, and it has no mealy smell. The tiger tricholoma is poisonous.

Where and when should you look for grey knights?

Under pines on sandy and limestone soils, often along forest tracks, through autumn, and in the south even into early winter.

Related articles

Sources

  • Yin X., Feng T., Shang J.-H. et al. "Chemical and toxicological investigations of a previously unknown poisonous European mushroom Tricholoma terreum" (Chemistry – A European Journal, 2014, vol. 20): saponaceolides, experiments on mice, the rhabdomyolysis hypothesis.
  • Davoli P., Floriani M., Assisi F., Kob K., Sitta N. Comment on this study (Chemistry – A European Journal, 2016, vol. 22) and the reply by Yin X. et al. in the same journal: the dispute over the conclusions, heat stability of the substances.
  • Clericuzio M., Serra S., Vidari G. "No evidence was found for the presence of terreolides, terreumols or saponaceolides H–S in the fruiting bodies of Tricholoma terreum" (Molecules, 2024, vol. 29): testing of DNA-confirmed samples.
  • Berndt S. (Der Tintling, 2016), as summarised on Wikipedia: the dose recalculated for a person.
  • First Nature, page on Tricholoma terreum: identifying features, habitat, a cautious position on edibility.
  • ASL Rieti, list of mushrooms permitted for sale in Italy (DPR 376/1995, annex I): Tricholoma terreum among the permitted species.
  • Normlisten 2024, Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund, 2024.
  • Vergiftungssyndrome: Beschreibung, Symptome und Karenzzeiten, Deutsche Gesellschaft für Mykologie.