Support MycoNote →

MycoNote
Want to find

Photo: Dan Molter (shroomydan) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

Edible✓ Checked by an expert

CharbonnierTricholoma portentosum

Also known as: sooty-headed tricholoma

SeasonAugust – November

Passport

Hymenophore
Gilled
Cap colour
Grey
Size
Medium (5–15 cm)

✓ Edible

Most often confused with: Tiger tricholoma (poisonous).

Quick answers

When does it appear? Europe

Aug — Nov

Active months: August, September, October, November.

How to recognise it? Three signs

Description

The charbonnier, or streaked knight (Tricholoma portentosum), is a tasty late-autumn mushroom with a distinctive grey-violet cap decorated with dark radial streaks of fibres (hence its second name, "streaked knight"). The Latin epithet portentosum means "marvelous, remarkable", a nod to its striking looks. The cap is 5-12 cm across and fleshy, convex to flattened with a low bump in the centre, grey with a distinct violet or greenish tinge and dark radial fibrous streaks.

Edible, with excellent culinary quality: the flesh is firm and white with a slight yellowish tinge, with a pleasant mealy-cucumber smell and taste. There's no bitterness, no soapy smell and no toxic compounds. It's one of the few grey knights worth picking. Older books list it as "edible, 2nd category"; today it's valued even more highly, because it fruits late, when most other mushrooms are already gone.

The key to identifying it is a combination of: (1) a grey-violet or grey-greenish cap with distinct dark radial streaks, (2) a yellowish tone in the gills and flesh, (3) a pleasant mealy-cucumber smell, (4) growth in pine and mixed forests in late autumn (often after the first light frosts), and (5) flesh that does not turn pink or change colour when cut.

The main risk is confusing it with the poisonous Tricholoma pardinum (tiger tricholoma), which is often stockier, with a 5-12 cm cap that is distinctly scaly (scaly rather than streaked) and fleshier. Its gills can also turn yellowish with age, and it smells mealy too, so neither gill colour nor smell separates them: look at streaks versus scales, and if in doubt, leave it. T. portentosum is slimmer and smaller, with fine radial streaks. It can also be confused with T. saponaceum (the soapy knight), which has a distinct soapy smell and flesh that turns pink. Two more dangerous lookalikes: the poisonous yellow knight (Tricholoma equestre), with sulphur-yellow gills, and the poisonous pinkgills (Entoloma sinuatum and relatives), whose gills turn pink with age and whose spore print is pink.

In Europe, Tricholoma portentosum is common in pine and spruce-pine forests: in the mountains and foothills, in the lowlands on sandy soil, and in parts of the forest-steppe. It forms mycorrhiza with pine and spruce. Season: mid to late autumn, right up to the first frosts, which makes it one of the latest mushrooms of the season.

Across Europe

Occurs across northern and central mainland Europe, mainly with pines on sandy soil, and remains common in France, Italy and Germany, though it is now rare in the Netherlands. The French know it as tricholome prétentieux, Swedes as streckmusseron.

Cap

The cap is 5-12 cm across, bell-shaped or convex-conical when young, becoming flat-convex with a low, broad bump in the centre. The skin is smooth, slightly slimy in wet weather, dry and matte in dry weather. Its colour is grey-violet, grey-greenish, olive-grey, darker in the centre, with distinct fine dark radial fibrous streaks, a key identifying feature. The margin is even, inrolled in young caps and slightly wavy in old ones.

Hymenophore

The gills are notched (sinuate) where they meet the stem, moderately crowded and fleshy. They're whitish with a faint yellowish tinge when young, turning creamy-yellowish with age, especially toward the edge. The poisonous tiger tricholoma can show the same yellowish tone, so on its own it proves nothing. The spore print is white.

Stem

The stem is 5-10 cm tall and 1.5-2.5 cm thick, firm, fleshy and cylindrical, whitish with a characteristic yellowish tinge, especially toward the base. The surface is smooth with fine lengthwise fibres. There's no ring.

Flesh

The flesh is firm, white in the cap and white with a yellowish tinge in the stem. It doesn't change colour when cut: it doesn't turn pink (unlike T. saponaceum) and doesn't darken. The smell is distinctly mealy-cucumber, the taste mild and pleasantly mushroomy with a hint of flour, with no bitterness.

Smell

A distinct, pleasant mealy-cucumber smell, like freshly ground flour with a note of fresh cucumber. It can be faint. The poisonous tiger tricholoma smells mealy too, so smell doesn't tell them apart.

›Scientific synonyms (4)

Agaricus portentosus Fr. (1821), Gyrophila portentosa (Fr.) Quél. (1886), Gyrophila sejuncta var. portentosa (Fr.) Quél. (1896), Melanoleuca portentosa (Fr.) Murrill (1914)

Don’t mix them up

Charbonnier lookalikes and comparison

FeatureCharbonnierTiger tricholoma
HymenophoreGilledGilled
Cap colourGrey, Violet, OliveGrey, White
SmellFloury, PleasantFloury
EdibilityEdiblePoisonous
Full comparison: Charbonnier vs Tiger tricholoma →
Compare with another mushroom

Readers’ finds · 0

Readers’ photos aren’t checked by an expert. “Confirmed” means foragers in the feed agree — not a guarantee. When in doubt, leave it.

Your find

Charbonnierchange

…

Mushrooms of the same genus and habitat — to study side by side and never mix up.

Related reading

Frequently asked questions

How do you tell it from the poisonous tiger tricholoma (T. pardinum)?

Key differences. T. portentosum is slimmer (5-12 cm), with a cap with fine radial streaks (not scales), yellowish flesh in the stem, and a mealy-cucumber smell. T. pardinum is often stockier (5-12 cm), with distinct greyish-white scales on a grey cap, fleshier, with gills that can also turn yellowish with age, and a mealy smell. If the cap has scales rather than fine streaks, or you're not sure, DO NOT pick it: it may be the poisonous tiger tricholoma. Gill colour and smell won't help here.

How do you tell it from the soapy knight (T. saponaceum)?

By smell and flesh. T. portentosum has a mealy-cucumber smell, and its flesh does not turn pink when cut. T. saponaceum has a distinct soapy smell (like soap), and its flesh turns pink when the stem is cut. These are two completely different sets of features, so you won't mix them up if you look carefully.

How do you cook it?

No boiling needed first (fresh caps aren't bitter). Fry young ones with onion and cream, stew them with potatoes, add them to soups or pickle them. It's good mixed with saffron milk caps and slippery jacks. It dries excellently: the aroma is kept and even intensifies. Young ones are especially tasty.

Where do you look for it?

On the forest floor in pine and spruce-pine forests, among moss and grass, on sandy and acidic soils. It loves dry, sunny pine woods and often grows in groups of 5-15 or in rings.

Where in Europe does it occur?

Common in the forest zone with conifers: mountain and foothill forests, lowland pine forests on sandy soil, and parts of the forest-steppe in pine stands.

When do you look for it?

Mid to late autumn, peaking in late autumn: one of the latest mushrooms of the season. It often fruits after the first light frosts, when other mushrooms are already gone, and that's what makes it valuable in the "empty" part of the season.

What mushrooms is it confused with?

With T. pardinum (tiger tricholoma, poisonous), which is larger and scaly. With T. saponaceum (soapy knight), which smells of soap and has flesh that turns pink. With T. terreum (grey knight), which has a downy, unstreaked cap and is smaller. And with T. virgatum, also streaked and grey but distinctly acrid-bitter (inedible), with no yellowish tone. Look closely for streaks (not scales). It's also confused with the poisonous yellow knight (sulphur-yellow gills) and poisonous pinkgills (gills turn pink, pink spore print).

Is Charbonnier edible or poisonous?
Charbonnier is edible. Before eating any wild mushroom, always double-check current information in reliable sources and consult an expert.
Does Charbonnier have gills or pores?
The spore-bearing surface (hymenophore) of Charbonnier: gilled.
What does the cap of Charbonnier look like?
The cap is 5-12 cm across, bell-shaped or convex-conical when young, becoming flat-convex with a low, broad bump in the centre. The skin is smooth, slightly slimy in wet weather, dry and matte in dry weather.
What does the stem of Charbonnier look like?
The stem is 5-10 cm tall and 1.5-2.5 cm thick, firm, fleshy and cylindrical, whitish with a characteristic yellowish tinge, especially toward the base. The surface is smooth with fine lengthwise fibres. There's no ring.
What do Charbonnier smell and taste like?
A distinct, pleasant mealy-cucumber smell, like freshly ground flour with a note of fresh cucumber. It can be faint. Taste: mild.

Sources

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]Wikipedia (de): Tigerritterling
  • [8]First Nature: Tricholoma portentosum, Charbonnier