Genus
Knights (Tricholoma)
Mushrooms in the taxonomic group “Tricholoma”. 16 species in the database.
Knights (Tricholoma) are gilled mushrooms with a white spore print that live in partnership with trees and often fruit in rows, hence their Ukrainian name, riadovka. The genus includes good edible species such as the charbonnier, others edible only after cooking, such as the poplar knight, and poisonous ones, above all the tiger tricholoma. Many look alike, so colour, smell and the tree nearby are your best clues.

Birch knight
Tricholoma fulvum
Conditionally edible
Booted knight
Tricholoma focale
Inedible
Charbonnier
Tricholoma portentosum
Edible
Giant knight
Tricholoma colossus
Edible
Grey knight
Tricholoma terreum
Conditionally edible
Matt knight
Tricholoma imbricatum
Conditionally edible
Poplar knight
Tricholoma populinum
Conditionally edibleScaly knight
Tricholoma vaccinum
Poisonous
Soapy knight
Tricholoma saponaceum
Poisonous
Sulphur knight
Tricholoma sulphureum
PoisonousTacked knight
Tricholoma pessundatum
Poisonous
Tiger tricholoma
Tricholoma pardinum
Poisonous
Tricholoma caligatum
Conditionally edible
Tricholoma orirubens
Conditionally edible
White knight
Tricholoma album
Poisonous
Yellow knight
Tricholoma equestre
Poisonous
What makes a mushroom a Tricholoma
Knights have a white, rarely cream, spore print, and their gills often have a small notch where they meet the stem. There is no volva, and a ring is rare. Many species have a noticeable smell: mealy, soapy or simply unpleasant.
Every knight is mycorrhizal, so a pine, birch or poplar nearby often tells you which one you've found.
There are about a hundred species worldwide. The grey and brown ones can be so similar that even experienced mycologists separate some of them only under the microscope. The type species of the genus is the yellow knight.
Mushrooms called knights that are not Tricholoma
Several mushrooms that Ukrainian and Russian foragers call riadovka belong to other genera. The wood blewit, Lepista nuda, has a pale pink spore print, not white. The field blewit, Lepista personata, known in Ukraine as synioniuzhka, "blue-foot", is a Lepista too and is eaten after boiling. St George's mushroom is Calocybe gambosa, once Tricholoma gambosum, and fruits in spring, in May and June.
The Ukrainian folk name holubinka adds to the muddle: it covers the tiger tricholoma, the yellow knight, the poplar knight and even the wood blewit.
Grey knights
The charbonnier has a cap 5–10 cm across, grey with darker streaks and often yellowish tints, sticky when wet. The gills are white and crowded, the smell mealy. It grows mainly under pine on sand, with a darker form under beech, from late summer often into early winter.
The grey knight, Tricholoma terreum, is smaller, with a dry, felty, mouse-grey cap covered in fine scales and no distinctive smell. The soapy knight, grey, olive or greenish, smells of soap, and its cut stem base slowly turns pink. Tricholoma orirubens is grey-brown with near-black scales, gills that redden when bruised and a bluish stem base.
The most dangerous of the group is the tiger tricholoma: large, 5–15 cm, with a silvery-grey cap covered in dark scales arranged in rings, and a mealy smell.
Yellow and green knights
The yellow knight has a yellow to greenish-yellow cap, lemon-yellow gills and no ring, and grows under pine on sandy soil. The similar sulphur knight reaches 8 cm, with thick, widely spaced gills and a strong smell often likened to coal gas. It grows under both broadleaved trees and conifers.
Brown knights: poplar, birch and others
Brown knights are the hardest group, and the tree helps most. The poplar knight, with a tan cap up to 16 cm, grows under poplars, often on sandy soil near rivers. The birch knight, sticky and red-brown, grows with birch in damp places and, unusually, has bright yellow gills that spot brown. The matt knight, brown to red-brown and often scaly, grows in conifer woods. The scaly knight has a fibrous red-brown cap with a shaggy margin when young, under pine and spruce.
The tacked knight has a sticky orange-brown cap up to 18 cm with a paler margin, spotting white gills and a sour, mealy smell. The booted knight has a 7–12 cm cap and a shaggy ring on the stem; the giant knight has very thick flesh and a cap up to 30 cm. Tricholoma caligatum is whitish with chestnut scales, a ring and a "booted" stem, smells spicy and grows under Mediterranean pines.
The white knight
The white knight has a 4–10 cm cap, white to pale yellow with an ochre centre, and a strong smell of radish. The very similar Tricholoma stiparophyllum grows under birch and smells sickly sweet; some mycologists treat the two as one species.
Which knights are edible and which are poisonous
We list the charbonnier as edible; it is on the official lists of edible mushrooms in Norway and Germany. The giant knight is edible too, but it is protected. The poplar, matt, scaly, birch and grey knights, Tricholoma orirubens and Tricholoma caligatum are edible only after proper preparation. Guides advise boiling some of them first and throwing the water away, as with the poplar knight; Norway lists the scaly knight as edible only after parboiling.
The tiger tricholoma is poisonous. In the first half of the 20th century it caused over 20% of mushroom poisonings in Switzerland. Nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea and dizziness start 15 minutes to 2 hours after the meal, sometimes with sweating, anxiety, calf cramps and liver problems. Recovery takes 4–6 days, sometimes in hospital. If you start vomiting or have diarrhoea after eating wild mushrooms, call 112 (999 in the UK) straight away and say which mushrooms you ate.
The tacked and white knights are poisonous too, causing severe stomach upsets, and cooking does not make the white knight safe. The sulphur knight is mildly poisonous and upsets the stomach, though its smell is off-putting enough. The soapy knight is inedible and can also cause stomach upset.
Is the yellow knight poisonous?
Yes, we list the yellow knight as poisonous and advise against picking it, even though older Ukrainian guides call it a good edible mushroom for salting, pickling and drying.
The view changed after France recorded 12 cases of rhabdomyolysis, a breakdown of muscle tissue, after eating it between 1992 and 2000; three people died. Similar cases were later reported in Poland and Lithuania. All followed several large meals in a row, with symptoms 24–72 hours after the last one. France banned its sale in 2004–2005 and Spain in 2006, and Norway's official 2024 list classes it as poisonous. Germany's list of edible mushrooms leaves it out.
To be fair, scientists still disagree. Poland still allows it to be sold, and Polish researchers who surveyed 1,545 foragers concluded it is edible in moderate amounts. We choose caution.
Telling grey and brown knights apart
Names add a trap for anyone reading Eastern European sources. Ukrainian books use «рядовка сіра», "grey knight", for the soapy knight, while the Russian «рядовка серая» means the charbonnier. Check the Latin name before trusting a recipe.
Field guides say the charbonnier is easily confused with mildly poisonous grey and grey-brown knights, and some authors advise not collecting it at all. It differs from the tiger tricholoma in the cap: evenly grey and streaked in the charbonnier, never scaly, but covered in dark scales in the tiger.
Among the brown knights, both the poplar knight and the matt knight resemble the poisonous tacked knight. The tree separates the poplar knight: look for poplars nearby.
Where and when knights grow in Europe and Ukraine
GBIF holds over 270,000 European records of knights: a quarter from Sweden, and over half from Sweden, Britain, Norway, Denmark and the Netherlands combined. That maps recorders more than mushrooms. September and October are the busiest months, followed by November and August. In Sweden, Norway and Finland the peak comes in September; in Britain, Denmark, the Netherlands, Switzerland, France and Austria in October; in Spain in November, and there knights often turn up in December too. The tiger tricholoma is recorded most in Switzerland, France, Slovenia and Austria, especially in the Jura.
Ukraine has 891 records, most often of the soapy, matt, poplar, yellow and sulphur knights. The yellow knight is common in Polissia and the forest-steppe from September to November. The poplar knight grows in poplar plantings across the country from August to November, the charbonnier in Polissia's pine forests from September to November.
In 2020 matsutake, Tricholoma matsutake, was found in a fir and beech forest near Kosiv in the Ivano-Frankivsk region: the first DNA-confirmed record in eastern Europe.
Protected knights
Two knights are in the Red Data Book of Ukraine. The giant knight is listed as rare. It grows in old pine forests on poor sandy soil and has declined by over a third in 50 years as those forests are felled, so the IUCN lists it as Vulnerable. The booted knight is vulnerable in Ukraine and Near Threatened in the UK.
Please don't pick them. If you find one, take a photo and leave it be.
Questions and answers
The short answers
Which Tricholoma species are edible?
We list the charbonnier (Tricholoma portentosum) as edible; it is on the official edible lists of Norway and Germany. The poplar, matt, scaly, birch and grey knights are edible only after proper preparation, some after boiling and discarding the water. The giant knight is edible too but protected in Ukraine, so leave it be.
Which knights are poisonous?
The tiger tricholoma is the most dangerous, causing severe vomiting and diarrhoea that sometimes needs hospital care. The yellow knight, tacked knight and white knight are poisonous too, and the sulphur knight is mildly poisonous. The soapy knight is inedible and can upset the stomach.
Is the yellow knight (Tricholoma equestre) poisonous?
Yes, we list it as poisonous: repeated large meals caused rhabdomyolysis in France, where three people died between 1992 and 2000. France and Spain banned its sale and Norway lists it as poisonous, although Poland still allows it to be sold and older Ukrainian guides call it a good edible.
How do you tell the tiger tricholoma from the charbonnier?
Look at the cap: the tiger tricholoma's is silvery-grey with dark scales in rings, while the charbonnier's is evenly grey with darker streaks and no scales. Some authors advise against collecting grey knights at all because of the dangerous look-alikes.
Is the grey knight edible?
The grey knight, Tricholoma terreum, is one we list as edible only after proper preparation. It has a dry, felty, mouse-grey cap with fine scales and no distinctive smell, while the soapy knight smells of soap and the poisonous tiger tricholoma is larger, with dark scales in rings.
Sources
MushroomExpert (Kuo M.), The genus Tricholoma: features of the genus and why it is hard to identify.
Wikipedia (English): species pages of knights (features, host trees, poisoning by the tiger tricholoma, sulphur knight and tacked knight).
Wikipedia (German), Gemeiner Schwefel-Ritterling: the sulphur knight.
Wikipedia (Ukrainian): "Riadovka" and species pages, after "Hryby: yistivni, umovno yistivni, neyistivni, otruini" (Zerova M.Ya. et al., 1979): names, distribution and season in Ukraine.
Wikipedia (Russian): pages on knights, the charbonnier and the poplar knight: names and preparation.
First Nature: pages on the white, booted, birch knights and the charbonnier.
Bedry R. et al. (2001): rhabdomyolysis after eating the yellow knight in France. Klimaszyk P., Rzymski P. (2018): survey of Polish foragers.
Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund, Normlisten 2024: Norway's official list of edible and poisonous fungi.
DGfM, Positivliste der Speisepilze (2026): Germany's list of edible mushrooms.
Regulation of the Polish Minister of Health of 17.05.2011 (Dz.U. 2026 poz. 258): mushrooms allowed for sale.
Order No. 111 of the Ministry of Environment of Ukraine, 15.02.2021: the Red Data Book of Ukraine.
Dahlberg A., Tricholoma colossus, IUCN Global Fungal Red List.
Aoki W. et al. (Mycoscience, 2022, vol. 63): matsutake in Ukraine.
GBIF: records of knights in Europe and Ukraine by country and month.