Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Summer vs. autumn honey mushrooms: what's the difference?

By Valeriia·Updated ·4 min read

Summer and autumn “honey mushrooms” are different species, not two forms of one. Both are eaten, honey fungus only well cooked, and the sheathed woodtuft has a dangerous lookalike. How to tell them apart.

Sheathed woodtuft: cluster of small capped mushrooms with gills on a mossy stump
Photo: Strobilomyces · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

The word “openky” covers several different mushrooms that grow in clusters on wood. The two most often confused are the sheathed woodtuft and honey fungus. The sheathed woodtuft is edible, and honey fungus is conditionally edible: poisonous raw, fine only when well cooked. Their seasons overlap, but they look a little different. Most importantly, the sheathed woodtuft has a lookalike you need to know by sight.

If you've found a cluster on a stump and want to check it step by step, including the deadly Galerina, the features side by side are in our summer vs autumn honey fungus comparison.

Here's how the sheathed woodtuft differs from honey fungus and how to tell them apart with confidence.

When they grow

Season gives only a hint: the two overlap for much of the year, and the sheathed woodtuft's autumn flush comes at the same time as the deadly funeral bell. Judge by the features below, not by the date.

  • Sheathed woodtuft appears as early as June and keeps going all summer into autumn, as long as it's warm and damp. It's one of the few summer mushrooms that grow in clusters on wood.
  • Honey fungus can appear from early summer but mostly fruits from late summer through autumn. We have a separate article on when the honey fungus season starts.

So from late summer you can find both: the sheathed woodtuft is still fruiting, and the first honey fungus is already appearing.

What they look like

At first glance they look alike, but look closer and you'll see the difference.

  • Sheathed woodtuft. The cap is honey-brown, paler in the centre, with distinctive translucent, water-soaked zones toward the margin. The ring on the stem is thin; below it the stem is dark with fine scales. The gills turn brown with age.
  • Honey fungus. The cap is honey-yellow or brown, covered in small dark scales, especially in the centre. The ring on the stem is prominent and membranous, like a “skirt.” The gills are creamy white.

Both grow in dense clusters, fused at the base of the stems.

Honey fungi are only some of the mushrooms that live on wood. Which other edible species grow on trunks and stumps, see our article on edible mushrooms that grow on trees.

Are they edible?

The sheathed woodtuft is a good edible mushroom; cook it thoroughly. Honey fungus is conditionally edible: raw or undercooked it causes stomach upset, so boil it first for at least 20 minutes, pour the water away and only then cook it further. They taste similar and are used the same way: fried, pickled or frozen.

But there's an important caveat about the sheathed woodtuft: it has a dangerous lookalike.

The sheathed woodtuft's dangerous lookalike

The sheathed woodtuft is easy to confuse with poisonous species that grow on wood at the same time, above all the funeral bell (Galerina marginata). This deadly poisonous mushroom has a similar honey-brown cap and also grows on rotting stumps.

Key precautions:

  • Don't pick sheathed woodtufts unless you're 100% sure.
  • Avoid small “honey mushrooms” with a smooth, scaleless stem below the ring, on conifer and broadleaf wood alike: the funeral bell grows on both.
  • Look closely at the gills and the ring, and check them against the identification features.

We've gathered the general rules for identifying honey mushrooms and their lookalikes separately: how to tell true honey mushrooms from false ones. And for a full overview of the species, see our guide to honey mushrooms of Europe.

In short: a comparison table

  • Season: overlaps, so it won't tell them apart: sheathed woodtuft from early summer into autumn, honey fungus mostly from late summer through autumn.
  • Cap: sheathed woodtuft — honey-brown with a water-soaked margin; honey fungus — with dark scales.
  • Stem: sheathed woodtuft — dark with fine scales; honey fungus — with a membranous ring.
  • Risk: sheathed woodtuft has a deadly lookalike (Galerina); honey fungus is harder to confuse, but check the ring too.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

How does the sheathed woodtuft differ from honey fungus?

By their features, not the season, which overlaps. The sheathed woodtuft has a water-soaked cap margin and a dark scaly stem; honey fungus has dark scales on the cap and a membranous ring.

Are the sheathed woodtuft and honey fungus the same mushroom?

No, they're different species that both grow in clusters on wood, in seasons that overlap. They taste similar and have the same uses, but they look different.

Is the sheathed woodtuft edible?

Yes, the sheathed woodtuft is edible and tasty; it must always be boiled before cooking. But because of its dangerous lookalike, pick it only when you're completely sure.

What is the sheathed woodtuft's lookalike?

The deadly poisonous funeral bell (Galerina marginata) — a mushroom with a similar honey-brown cap that grows on rotting wood at the same time. It's the main reason to be careful.

Can you find both at the same time?

Yes. In late summer the sheathed woodtuft is still growing and the first honey fungus is already appearing, so you can find both in the forest.

How do you tell a true honey mushroom from a false one?

A ring is not enough: honey fungus has one, but so does the deadly funeral bell, and the sheathed woodtuft has brown gills, not white ones. Check several features together: scales on the stem below the ring, the spore print (white in honey fungus, rusty brown in the funeral bell) and gills that are not greenish or yellow, as they are in sulphur tuft. If anything doesn't fit, leave the cluster in the forest.

When is the best time to pick honey mushrooms?

Sheathed woodtuft: all through a warm, damp summer. Honey fungus: mostly from late summer through autumn. Both come up in flushes after rain.

Where does the sheathed woodtuft grow?

On rotting hardwood — stumps, fallen trunks, around roots — in damp deciduous and mixed forests.

Related articles

Sources

  • Sheathed woodtuft on Wikipedia.