Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Why slippery jacks have slimy caps, and should you peel them?

By Valeriia·Updated ·3 min read

The slimy film gave the slippery jack its name, but it often puzzles cooks. Here's why the slippery jack needs this slime and whether you really have to peel it before cooking.

Slippery jack (Suillus luteus): a shiny, slimy brown cap among grass and leaves
Photo: George Chernilevsky · CC0 · source

The slippery jack owes its name to exactly this: a slimy, glossy cap that looks as if it's been brushed with oil. The film is both its main hallmark and the cause of kitchen debates: peel it or not?

Let's sort it out calmly: first why the slippery jack has this slime at all, then when the skin really should come off, and how to do it quickly without turning cleaning into a chore.

Why the slippery jack has a slimy cap

Our sources don't say exactly what the slime is for. A common guess is that it helps the young cap hold on to moisture in a sunny pine wood, but that has not been proven.

In wet weather the cap is especially shiny because the slime swells. In dry weather it dries out and the cap turns tacky, almost gluey. Pine needles, grains of sand and leaves stick easily to this film, which is why freshly picked slippery jacks often look "dirty."

That dirt, stuck fast to the slime, is the main reason people peel the skin. It's not a whim but a practical need: otherwise sand and needles end up in your dish.

Should you peel the skin?

We recommend always peeling slippery jacks, and there are several good reasons for it.

  • Dirt. Needles and sand stick to the slime and are hard to wash off with water.
  • A slightly bitter taste. The skin of some slippery jacks tastes a little bitter, especially in mature mushrooms.
  • Slimy texture. In a finished dish the skin makes it overly slimy, which not everyone enjoys.
  • Your stomach. In some people unpeeled caps cause diarrhoea, which can start soon after the meal.

For all these reasons, most foragers peel their slippery jacks. We suggest peeling them every time, even young, clean ones and even for drying.

How to peel the skin quickly and without sticky hands

The main trick is to peel slippery jacks dry, before washing. Wet skin gets even slimier, and your hands and knife get sticky.

A few tips from experience:

  1. Don't wash the mushrooms first; peel them dry as soon as you get back from the woods.
  2. Catch the edge of the skin with a knife near the cap margin and pull toward the centre; it will come off in strips.
  3. Wear gloves or wipe your hands with a dry cloth from time to time, because the slime stains your fingers brown.
  4. Young mushrooms peel more easily, so don't leave them for long.

Some relatives behave differently. In the bovine bolete the cap is slimy in wet weather, but the skin barely peels, so wipe it carefully. The velvet bolete has a dry, felty cap with hardly any slime, so dirt brushes off more easily.

Why even young ones are worth peeling

Even young, clean slippery jacks picked in dry weather, when there's little slime, are best peeled, whether you plan to dry them, fry them or make soup: the skin is what upsets some people's stomachs. Young ones peel quickly, so it takes only a few minutes.

The best time to pick slippery jacks is roughly one to three weeks after a warm rain in coniferous and mixed forests. Our mushroom radar makes it easy to catch good windows: it shows when moisture and warmth line up for mushrooms to appear.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Why does the slippery jack have a slimy cap?

Our sources don't say exactly; a common guess is that the slimy film helps the cap hold on to moisture, but that has not been proven. It's exactly what gave the slippery jack its name. In wet weather the slime swells; in dry weather it dries and turns sticky.

Should you peel a slippery jack?

Yes, we recommend it. Needles and sand stick to the slime, the skin can be slightly bitter, it makes a dish slimy, and in some people unpeeled caps cause diarrhoea. That's why most foragers peel it.

How do you peel slippery jacks quickly?

Peel the mushrooms dry, before washing. Catch the edge of the skin with a knife near the cap margin and pull toward the centre; it will come off in strips. Wear gloves, because the slime stains your fingers.

Why shouldn't you wash slippery jacks before peeling?

Because wet skin gets even slimier, and your hands and knife get sticky. A dry mushroom is much easier to peel, so leave the washing until afterward.

Do you have to peel young slippery jacks?

Yes, we recommend it. Even young, clean caps can cause diarrhoea in some people if they're left unpeeled, whether you fry, boil or dry them. The good news is that young slippery jacks peel easily and quickly.

Why do your fingers turn dark when you peel slippery jacks?

The slime and the pigments in the cap skin stain your skin brown. It's harmless, but the stains are hard to wash off, so gloves make the job easier.

Do all slippery jacks need peeling?

Not every relative peels easily. The bovine bolete is slimy in wet weather, but its skin barely comes off, so it is wiped carefully instead. The velvet bolete has a dry, felty cap with hardly any slime. The classic slippery jack should always be peeled.

Is it safe to eat a slippery jack with the skin on?

We don't recommend it: in some people unpeeled caps cause diarrhoea, and the skin makes a dish slimy. Peel it off whatever you plan to cook, and heat the mushrooms through thoroughly.

Related articles