How to tell Stubble rosegill from Destroying angel
Stubble rosegill and Destroying angel look alike, so they're easy to mix up — but Stubble rosegill is conditionally edible, while Destroying angel is deadly poisonous. The main visible difference: ring (veil): Stubble rosegill — no ring, Destroying angel — ring present. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: stem, smell. If you have even the slightest doubt, leave the mushroom be.
Not sure? Identify by photoSide by side
| Characteristic | Stubble rosegill | Destroying angel |
|---|---|---|
| Edibility class | Stubble rosegill: Conditionally edible | Destroying angel: Deadly poisonous |
| Use | Stubble rosegill: Cook fresh | Destroying angel: Not eaten |
| Cap colour | Stubble rosegill: White, Grey, Brown | Destroying angel: White, Cream |
| Cap shape | Stubble rosegill: Convex | Destroying angel: Convex, Umbonate |
| Cap surface | Stubble rosegill: Smooth, Slimy | Destroying angel: Smooth |
| Taste | Stubble rosegill: Mild | Destroying angel: Unknown |
| Smell | Stubble rosegill: Odourless, Radish-like | Destroying angel: Chemical, Unpleasant |
| Stem | Stubble rosegill: Central | Destroying angel: Bulbous |
| Ring (veil) | Stubble rosegill: No ring | Destroying angel: Ring present |
| Nutrition type | Stubble rosegill: Saprotroph | Destroying angel: Mycorrhizal |
| Partner trees | Stubble rosegill: — | Destroying angel: Spruce, Pine, Birch |
| Growth habit | Stubble rosegill: Solitary, In groups | Destroying angel: Solitary |
Same in both: season, size, flesh colour change, hymenophore, volva, substrate.
DEADLY POISONOUS
Eating it can cause death. Do not pick it and do not taste it.
It contains amatoxins (including α-amanitin) and phallotoxins, the most powerful natural liver toxins known. A single mushroom contains a lethal dose for an adult. Poisoning unfolds in three phases:
Phase 1 (usually 8-12 hours after eating, anywhere from 4 to 36) — acute gastroenteritis: severe nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, watery or bloody diarrhoea, dehydration. This phase lasts until roughly 36 hours after the meal.
Phase 2 (36-72 h after eating): the "deceptive improvement." The gastroenteritis subsides, the person feels better and often leaves the hospital. This is the most dangerous moment, because the toxins are meanwhile destroying liver cells.
Phase 3 (from day three) — acute liver and kidney failure: jaundice, bleeding, encephalopathy, coma. It can end in death from liver failure or require a liver transplant.
What to do if you suspect poisoning: call an ambulance immediately and don't wait for symptoms. The best results come from treatment started within the first 36 hours after eating, but still go if more time has passed: late does not mean pointless. Treatment: silibinin (intravenous), intensive care, activated charcoal (repeated doses), hemodialysis, IV fluids. Keep the mushroom remains (bits of the cap, soil from where it was found): this is critical for identifying the toxin.
Prevention: no white gilled mushroom with a ring and a volva goes into the basket. No exceptions. Agaricus mushrooms and parasols have quite different features.
If you suspect poisoning, call your local emergency number (112 in the EU, 999 in the UK) immediately
When and where they meet
Together: August–October
What they look like
Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell
Cap
Stubble rosegill
Cap 5–15 cm across, bell-shaped at first, then opening out to flat with a small umbo. White to grey or greyish brown, often darker in the centre, ageing to cream or ochre. Smooth, sticky when wet, shiny and silky when dry. A pale cap doesn't separate it from a deadly amanita.
Destroying angel
The cap is 5-12 cm across, egg-shaped when young, then bell-shaped or conical, often slightly lopsided, and finally spreading with a boss. It is entirely white or creamy white, slightly yellowish in the centre in old mushrooms. The surface is smooth and slightly sticky in wet weather. The mature cap has no scales, no warts and no veil remnants (unlike the fly agaric or Caesar's mushroom).
Hymenophore
Stubble rosegill
Gills free (not attached to the stem), crowded and broad. White in young mushrooms, then pink to salmon or brownish pink as the spores ripen. Spore print pink to pinkish brown. While the gills are white, it can't be told from a deadly amanita.
Destroying angel
The gills are white and free (not attached to the stem) and moderately crowded. The spore print is white. As in the rest of Amanita section Phalloideae, to which this species belongs, the gills stay white to cream and free even in mature mushrooms, unlike those of Agaricus.
Stem
Stubble rosegill
Stem 5–20 cm tall and 1–2.5 cm thick, white to pale grey, slightly thicker towards the base, smooth or finely silky. No ring. At the base there's a white, pouch-like volva that cups the stem, so lift out the whole mushroom to see it.
Destroying angel
The stem is 8-15 cm tall and 1-2 cm thick, cylindrical, long and slender, with a sac-like volva at the base (a remnant of the universal veil that looks like an eggshell). It is entirely white. Near the top is a white membranous ring, firm in young mushrooms and sometimes gone in old ones. The stem surface often has thin white flaky scales and fibres.
Flesh
Stubble rosegill
The flesh is white, thin and watery, and doesn't change colour in the air. It's soft rather than firm and doesn't keep: it breaks down quickly.
Destroying angel
The flesh is firm and entirely white and doesn't change colour when cut, like many edible mushrooms, so that tells you nothing. The smell is like radish in a very young mushroom, then turns unpleasant and sickly sweet, sometimes with a hint of chlorine, hence the epithet "stinking" in its Ukrainian name. In young mushrooms the smell is still faint, so don't rely on it as the only sign.
Smell
Stubble rosegill
A faint smell, often compared to radish or raw potato and sometimes not distinctive at all. The taste is bland, with nothing pronounced.
Destroying angel
Faint, unpleasant and sickly sweet, sometimes with a hint of chlorine, especially in old mushrooms and when the flesh is damaged. It tells you nothing about safety: the smell develops only with time, and a young mushroom with no distinct smell can still end up in the basket and cause fatal poisoning.
Related comparisons
Sources · 11
- [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
- [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
- [3]MycoBank Database
- [4]Index Fungorum
- [5]GBIF
- [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
- [7]First Nature: Volvopluteus gloiocephalus, Stubble Rosegill
- [8]Wikipedia (en): Volvopluteus gloiocephalus
- [9]MushroomExpert: Volvopluteus gloiocephalus
- [10]California Fungi (MykoWeb): Volvopluteus gloiocephalus
- [11]Svampguiden: Stubble Rosegill (Volvopluteus gloiocephalus)