Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Horn of plenty or Elfin saddle

Horn of plenty and Elfin saddle are similar species: Horn of plenty is edible, while Elfin saddle is inedible. The main visible difference: smell: Horn of plenty — fruity, pleasant, mushroomy, Elfin saddle — odourless. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: cap shape.

Not sure? Identify by photo

Side by side

Horn of plentyElfin saddle
Comparison of characteristics: Horn of plenty and Elfin saddle
Edibility classHorn of plenty: EdibleElfin saddle: Inedible
SeasonHorn of plenty: Summer, AutumnElfin saddle: Autumn
UseHorn of plenty: Culinary, DryingElfin saddle: Not eaten
Cap colourHorn of plenty: Black, Dark greyElfin saddle: Grey, Black, Dark brown
Cap shapeHorn of plenty: Funnel-shapedElfin saddle: Irregular
TasteHorn of plenty: MildElfin saddle: Unknown
SmellHorn of plenty: Fruity, Pleasant, mushroomyElfin saddle: Odourless
HymenophoreHorn of plenty: SmoothElfin saddle: —
StemHorn of plenty: Central, HollowElfin saddle: Central
SubstrateHorn of plenty: Soil, Forest litterElfin saddle: Soil
Nutrition typeHorn of plenty: MycorrhizalElfin saddle: —
Partner treesHorn of plenty: Beech, Oak, HornbeamElfin saddle: —
Growth habitHorn of plenty: In groups, In clusters from one baseElfin saddle: In groups, Solitary

Same in both: size, cap surface, flesh colour change.

When and where they meet

Together: August–November

Their seasons overlap: August–November. At that time you can find both in the same woods. Shared habitats: deciduous forest.

Horn of plenty

Fruiting season

August – November

Elfin saddle

Fruiting season

June – November

What they look like

Cap, Hymenophore, Stem, Flesh, Smell

Cap

Horn of plenty

The fruit body is a funnel or trumpet, usually 5–10 cm tall, exceptionally 15 cm, and 2–8 cm across, with no clear boundary between cap and stem. The inner (upper) surface is dark grey to black or blackish brown and finely scaly. The margin is wavy, often torn or irregularly lobed.

Elfin saddle

The cap is usually 2–5 cm across, irregularly saddle-shaped, with 2–4 lobes. It's dark grey to graphite, almost black in old ones. The surface is smooth, with a silky sheen in wet weather, and the margins are wavy and contorted. At the top it's partly fused to the stem.

Hymenophore

Horn of plenty

The spore-bearing surface is on the outside of the funnel: smooth or shallowly wrinkled, with no true gills and none of the gill-like folds of true chanterelles. It's grey with a pale, powdery bloom. Spore print white to cream.

Elfin saddle

The smooth hymenium covers the upper (outer) surface of the cap lobes. As in all ascomycetes, the spores form in asci. Spore print white. Spores ellipsoid, smooth, 17-20 × 10-13 µm.

Stem

Horn of plenty

There's no separate stem: the funnel narrows into a tube that stays hollow right down to the base. It's grey to brownish black, darkest at the bottom.

Elfin saddle

The stem is 3–10 cm tall, sometimes more, and 1–3 cm thick. It's pale grey, darkening towards the base, with prominent lengthwise ribs and deep pits (lacunae), hence the name. Inside it's hollow and divided into chambers. The ribbing is like that of the white saddle, but the colour is completely different.

Flesh

Horn of plenty

The flesh is very thin, grey to blackish, and doesn't change colour. It's mild when fresh. Drying concentrates the flavour into something rich, intense and truffle-like.

Elfin saddle

The flesh is thin, waxy, brittle and greyish white, and doesn't change colour when cut. It's fragile.

Smell

Horn of plenty

Mild and pleasant when fresh, often lightly fruity, though some guides find it indistinct. When dried, the aroma grows much stronger and turns deep, earthy and truffle-like, which is what makes dried horn of plenty so valuable in the kitchen.

Elfin saddle

A faint mushroomy smell with no sharp notes. We don't taste it, since it's potentially toxic.

Related comparisons

Sources · 23

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]First Nature: Helvella lacunosa
  • [8]Wikipedia (en): Helvella lacunosa
  • [9]Norges sopp- og nyttevekstforbund: Normlisten 2024 (2024)
  • [10]DGfM: Positivliste der Speisepilze (Stand 01.05.2026) (2026)
  • [11]Rozporządzenie Ministra Zdrowia: grzyby dopuszczone do obrotu (Dz.U. 2026 poz. 258) (2026)
  • [12]Not all bad: Gyromitrin has a limited distribution in the false morels as determined by a new ultra high-performance liquid chromatography method, Dirks A.C. et al. (2023)
  • [13]Gyromitrin poisoning: more questions than answers, Benjamin D.R. (2020)
  • [14]First Nature: Craterellus cornucopioides, Horn of Plenty
  • [15]Kuo M., MushroomExpert: Craterellus cornucopioides
  • [16]Wikipedia (en): Craterellus cornucopioides
  • [17]Wikipedia (fr): Craterellus cornucopioides
  • [18]Stadt Wien, Pilzberatung: Herbsttrompete
  • [19]Wikipedia (en): Pseudocraterellus undulatus
  • [20]Mushroom Appreciation: How to clean and cook black trumpet mushrooms
  • [21]Mushrooms traded as food, Nordic Council of Ministers
  • [22]Mushrooms traded as food. Vol II sec. 1, Nordic Council of Ministers
  • [23]Activity concentration of Cs-137 and K-40 in wild edible Craterellus cornucopioides mushroom, Dospatliev L., Lacheva M., Ivanova M., Radoukova T. (2019)