Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Chanterelle lookalikes: the true and the false chanterelle

By Valeriia·Updated ·3 min read

The chanterelle is hard to confuse with anything, but it does have one lookalike. Here's how the false chanterelle differs from the true one and what to check in your basket.

Chanterelle (Cantharellus cibarius): three yellow funnel-shaped mushrooms in green moss
Photo: Andreas Kunze · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

The chanterelle is rightly considered one of the safest mushrooms for beginners: it's bright, fragrant and has almost no dangerous lookalikes. Almost, because similar mushrooms do exist: the false chanterelle and, less often, the poisonous jack-o'-lantern (Omphalotus olearius), which has true gills and grows in clusters on wood. Luckily, they're easy to tell apart, and neither is deadly.

Let's look at how the true chanterelle differs from the false one, which other mushrooms resemble it, and why it's still a great choice for beginners.

What makes the true chanterelle stand out

The true chanterelle has several traits that make it easy to recognise.

  • Colour. An even egg-yolk yellow or light orange, the same on cap and stem.
  • Ridges instead of gills. Under the cap there are no true gills, just thick, forked ridges that run down the stem.
  • Shape. The cap is funnel-shaped, with a wavy, uneven edge.
  • Flesh and smell. Firm, springy, with a pleasant fruity aroma. Chanterelles get wormy less often than boletes, though it does happen.

It's the combination of an even yellow colour, ridges and springy flesh that sets the true chanterelle apart from all its lookalikes.

How the false chanterelle differs

The false chanterelle really does look like the true one, but it has its own telltale signs.

  • Brighter, uneven colour. More often a deep orange, reddish, with a darker centre and a paler edge.
  • True thin gills. Underneath, instead of thick ridges, there are crowded thin gills, as on ordinary gilled mushrooms.
  • Thinner flesh. Softer and less springy than the true chanterelle's.
  • Grows differently. Often on rotting wood, decaying stumps, cones and conifer litter, though it can also grow on bare soil.

The false chanterelle isn't deadly, but it can cause digestive upset in sensitive people, so it doesn't go in the basket. We've gathered all the differences in our true vs. false chanterelle comparison.

Other similar mushrooms

Besides the false chanterelle, there are a few related chanterelles, and all of them are safe.

  • Ashen chanterelle. Dark grey, even blackish, but also edible. With that colour, you won't mistake it for the true one.

No deadly mushroom truly looks like a chanterelle, but there's one danger worth knowing about. In conifer woods, among moss and often right beside trumpet chanterelles, grows the deadly webcap. It's fox-orange, so it ends up in baskets through haste and its colour, and its toxin destroys the kidneys, with the first symptoms appearing only days later. It's easy to tell apart if you take your time: it has thin, true gills under the cap, not ridges, and yellow bands on the stem. So the chanterelle is still a good mushroom for beginners, as long as you pick each one individually and check it.

How not to go wrong with chanterelles

A few simple checks will clear up any doubt.

  1. Look under the cap. Thick, forked ridges mean a true chanterelle; crowded thin gills mean the lookalike.
  2. Judge the colour. Even egg-yolk yellow is the true one; bright orange with a dark centre is the false one.
  3. Check the flesh. Springy flesh that doesn't crumble is a sign of the true chanterelle.
  4. See where it grows. On rotting wood it's more likely the lookalike than a good chanterelle.

Chanterelles love damp forests and are among the first mushrooms to appear, as early as the start of summer. For when to go looking, see our piece on the first chanterelles of June, and to catch the right moment, check the mushroom radar.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Does the chanterelle have poisonous lookalikes?

No deadly mushroom really looks like it. The usual lookalike is the false chanterelle, which isn't deadly but can cause digestive upset. But in conifer woods, especially near trumpet chanterelles, you can find the deadly webcap: it has thin gills instead of ridges and yellow bands on the stem.

How does the false chanterelle differ from the true one?

The true one has thick, forked ridges underneath and an even egg-yolk yellow colour. The false one has crowded thin gills, a bright orange colour with a darker centre and softer, thinner flesh.

Is the false chanterelle poisonous?

Not dangerously. We list it as inedible: some sources call it edible with reservations, but it can upset the stomach in sensitive people. That's why it stays out of the basket.

How do you tell a chanterelle by the underside of the cap?

The true chanterelle has thick, forked ridges underneath that run down the stem. The false one, like ordinary gilled mushrooms, has crowded thin gills there. This is the most reliable sign.

Do chanterelles get wormy?

Yes, though less often than boletes, especially once a mushroom is old. So check each chanterelle when you cut it.

Is the ashen chanterelle edible?

Yes. The ashen chanterelle is dark, almost blackish, but edible. With such an unusual colour, it isn't confused with the true chanterelle.

Where does the false chanterelle grow most often?

Often on rotting wood, decaying stumps and conifer litter, but also on bare soil, so where it grows is only a supporting sign. The true chanterelle grows from the soil, among moss in damp forests.

Is the chanterelle good for beginners?

Yes, it's one of the safest mushrooms: bright, easy to recognise, and no deadly mushroom really looks like it. Just check the ridges under the cap and the even colour, and pick each mushroom individually, because a deadly webcap with thin gills can grow nearby.

Related articles