Porcini is every forager’s dream, which is exactly why its impostors are so frustrating. Several boletes look like porcini in shape and colour, but one will ruin a dish with its unbearable bitterness and another can poison you. Luckily, they’re easy to tell apart once you know where to look.
Let’s go over the main poisonous and inedible porcini lookalikes and the reliable signs of a true porcini.
The bitter bolete: the most common lookalike
The bitter bolete is inedible. It isn’t deadly, though some sources call it slightly poisonous, and it’s so bitter that even one mushroom spoils a whole pan.
- The tube layer gradually turns pink with age (in porcini it’s white, then yellowish-green).
- The net on the stem is dark and coarse (in porcini it is pale and fine).
- The flesh often turns slightly pink when cut, and the taste is bitter.

There’s more on the bitter bolete in our separate article.
The devil’s bolete: a poisonous lookalike
A rare but dangerous visitor to warm oak woods.
- The cap is whitish-grey.
- The pores are reddish, though the tubes behind them are yellowish.
- The stem is thick, with a red net pattern.
- The flesh bruises blue when cut.
The devil’s bolete causes severe digestive upset, so it’s best to leave any bolete with red pores and a red stem.
How to recognise a true porcini
- The tube layer is white, later yellowish-green, and never pink or red. But a young bitter bolete has white tubes too, and some poisonous boletes have yellow ones, so this sign only works together with the stem.
- The flesh is white and doesn’t change colour when cut (no blue, no pink).
- No taste test is needed: the stem and the tube layer are enough.
- The net on the stem is pale and fine; on the bitter bolete it’s dark and coarse. This is the most reliable sign.

See also our article on how a true porcini differs from its lookalikes.
The main rule
- Look at the tube layer and the stem together: pink tubes or a dark, coarse net mean bitter bolete, red pores or a red stem mean devil’s bolete. White or yellowish pores alone don’t prove porcini.
- Check the cut: white flesh that doesn’t change colour sets porcini apart from blueing boletes, but not from the bitter bolete.
- If in doubt, leave it: better to walk away from a mushroom than to ruin a dish or get poisoned.
Mushrooms in this article
Frequently asked questions
Which poisonous mushrooms look like porcini?
The most common lookalike is the bitter bolete (Tylopilus felleus), which is very bitter and inedible, though not deadly. The rare devil’s bolete is more dangerous: it can poison you.
How do you tell porcini from the bitter bolete?
The stem net is the most reliable difference: pale and fine on porcini, dark and coarse on the bitter bolete. The bitter bolete’s tubes turn pink with age, though in young ones they are white. Don’t taste a mushroom to check it.
How do you tell porcini from the devil’s bolete?
The devil’s bolete has reddish pores and a red net on the stem, and its flesh bruises blue when cut. Porcini has pale pores, and its flesh doesn’t change colour.
Why does the bitter bolete ruin a dish?
It’s so bitter that a single mushroom makes a whole pan inedible, and cooking doesn’t get rid of the bitterness.
Can you get poisoned by the devil’s bolete?
Yes, it causes severe digestive upset. Never take a bolete with red pores and a red stem.
What should you look at first to recognise porcini?
The tube layer and the stem net together. In porcini the tubes are white or yellowish-green and the net is pale. Pore colour alone proves nothing: a young bitter bolete has white tubes, and some poisonous boletes have yellow ones.
Does porcini turn blue when cut?
No, the flesh of a true porcini doesn’t change colour. Blue bruising points to the bay bolete or the lurid bolete, and red pores to the devil’s bolete.
What should you do if you’re not sure about a bolete?
Don’t take it. No bitter or poisonous lookalike is worth risking a ruined dish or your health.
Related articles
SafetyMushrooms in your lawn and garden: why they appear, are they dangerous and what to do
Mushrooms in a lawn rarely harm the grass, but a few lawn species are deadly. Why they pop up, which ones you'…
November 14, 2026·9 min
Growing mushroomsCan you grow porcini and chanterelles at home? The honest answer
Nobody has yet shown a reliable way to grow porcini in a garden, and chanterelles have only fruited in experim…
November 6, 2026·7 min
Recipes & cookingDried mushrooms: how to store, rehydrate and cook them
How to store dried mushrooms, how long they last, what to do if they go soft or mouldy, how long to soak them…
November 14, 2026·5 min
Sources
- Tylopilus felleus on Wikipedia.
Bitter bolete
Devil's bolete
Porcini