Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Birch porcini, the pale companion of birches

By Valeriia·Updated ·5 min read

Birch porcini can mean a pale cep growing under birch (Boletus betulicola) or the birch bolete, a different mushroom. Here's how to tell which one you've found, and whether the birch cep is a species at all.

Porcini (Boletus edulis): wrinkled brown cap and pale stem in moss among tiny spruce seedlings
Photo: Holger Krisp · CC BY 3.0 · source

One member of the porcini family stands out with a pale, almost honey-coloured cap: the birch-loving bolete (Boletus betulicola, listed in our catalogue as Boletus betulicola), a faithful companion of birches. While other boletes hide in the shade of oak or pine woods, this one sits in plain sight on a bright forest edge.

It's often treated not as a separate species but as a pale form of the classic porcini. For a practical forager, though, the distinction is simple and useful: know your birches, and you know where to look for this bolete.

Why it sticks to birches

Porcini live in a close partnership with trees called mycorrhiza: the mycelium wraps around the fine roots and trades nutrients with the tree. Each kind of porcini favours its own trees, and Boletus betulicola, as its name (“birch-dweller”) suggests, has chosen birch.

So don't look for it just “anywhere in the forest”; look where the birches are: bright forest edges, birch groves, roads lined with young birch. That's the quickest way to a full basket.

Under the same birches you'll often find the brown birch bolete too, a completely different mushroom (Leccinum scabrum) with a dark velvety cap and a slender stem. They're hard to confuse, but they can grow very close together.

Birch porcini or birch bolete: which one have you found?

If you found a bolete under birch, it is most likely the brown birch bolete (Leccinum scabrum), not a cep. It grows nearly always beneath silver birch.

Look at the stem first. The birch bolete has a slim stem covered in dark brown woolly scales, and its flesh sometimes turns slightly pink when cut, never blue. A pale cep has a fat stem with a fine pale net near the top and white flesh that does not change colour at all.

Birch boletes are usually regarded as good to eat, but Leccinum species often cause nausea and vomiting when eaten raw or undercooked, so always cook them thoroughly.

What Boletus betulicola looks like

You recognise it by a combination of features, not just one. Check the mushroom over from top to bottom.

  • Cap. Pale: ochre, cream, honey or greyish milky brown, sometimes almost white when young. Convex, becoming cushion-shaped with age, with a smooth surface.
  • Stem. Thick, barrel-shaped, pale, almost white, with a fine pale net in the upper part.
  • Pores. The tube layer underneath is white when young, then yellowish, and olive green in old mushrooms. It is never pink.
  • Flesh. Firm, white, with a pleasant nutty smell. It does not change colour when cut.

Cut it as for the rest of the family: a true porcini stays white and does not turn blue or red. Blue or red rules out a porcini, but white flesh alone proves nothing, because the bitter bolete stays white too.

How it differs from other porcini

The easiest clues are the tree and the cap colour.

  • Summer bolete is darker, hazelnut brown, with a matte cap that cracks in the heat; it grows under oak and beech.
  • Pine bolete is the darkest, a chestnut-wine colour, and lives under pines.
  • The classic porcini is the all-rounder: it turns up everywhere and is medium in colour.
  • Boletus betulicola is the palest and sticks to birches.

Essentially it's the same wonderful porcini, just dressed in “birch” colours.

Is the birch porcini a separate species?

Most likely not. The GBIF database lists Boletus betulicola as a synonym of the cep, Boletus edulis.

The name has moved around a lot. It was first described by Vassilkov as a variety of the cep (Boletus edulis var. betulicola), was also listed as a form, was given species rank by Pilát and Dermek, and was treated as a subspecies by Hlaváček in 1994.

DNA studies now place it in a Boletus edulis species complex: a group that varies widely in look and habitat but very little genetically. For you as a forager that changes nothing: a pale cep under birch is checked exactly like any other penny bun.

Where and when to look for it

Boletus betulicola loves light and warmth. The best spots are:

  • sunny edges of broadleaf forest with young birches;
  • birch groves and grassy clearings;
  • patches of mixed forest where birch grows alongside pine;
  • the verges of old forest roads overgrown with birch.

It doesn't like dense, wet thickets; it needs warm ground and a bit of sun. The season runs from early summer to autumn, in flushes after warm rains. The best time to go is roughly one to two weeks after rain, once the soil has warmed up again. An easy way to track these windows is our mushroom radar: it shows when moisture and warmth line up just right for boletes to appear.

Found one? Don't rush off. Boletes grow in groups, and there are often a few more under the same birch.

Caution never hurts

Like all porcini, Boletus betulicola has a bitter lookalike, the bitter bolete. Young bitter boletes have white pores too, which turn pinkish later, so check the stem: the bitter bolete has a coarse dark net, the porcini a fine pale one. And remember the golden rule: if you're not sure, don't pick it.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

What is Boletus betulicola?

It's a pale kind of true porcini (Boletus betulicola) that grows alongside birches. It's often considered a pale form of the common porcini. It has an ochre-cream cap and white flesh that doesn't turn blue.

What does Boletus betulicola look like?

A pale, almost honey or cream cap, a thick pale stem with a fine net at the top, white or yellowish pores underneath and firm white flesh.

Where does Boletus betulicola grow?

On bright forest edges lined with birch, in groves and grassy clearings, and in mixed forests where birch grows alongside pine. It loves warm ground and a bit of sun.

When should you pick Boletus betulicola?

The season runs from early summer to autumn, in flushes after warm rains. Go roughly one to two weeks after rain, and check the mushroom forecast.

How does Boletus betulicola differ from the brown birch bolete?

They're different mushrooms. Boletus betulicola has a thick barrel-shaped stem with a net and a pale cap, while the brown birch bolete (Leccinum scabrum) has a slender stem with dark scales and a darker velvety cap. The porcini's flesh is firmer.

Does Boletus betulicola turn blue when cut?

No. The flesh of a true porcini stays white when cut. If the mushroom turns blue or red, it's a different species, and you shouldn't take it. White flesh alone doesn't prove a porcini, though: the bitter bolete's flesh stays white too.

How does Boletus betulicola differ from the summer and pine boletes?

Mainly by colour and tree. Boletus betulicola is the palest and sticks to birches, the summer bolete is hazelnut brown under oak, and the pine bolete is dark wine-coloured under pine.

Is Boletus betulicola edible?

Yes, it's a true porcini, edible and highly prized. Pick young, firm ones with white or light yellow pores; they're excellent both fresh and dried.

Related articles