Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Velvet shank, the mushroom that grows in frost

By Valeriia·Updated ·2 min read

The velvet shank fruits long after other mushrooms have gone to sleep. Here's how to recognise it, where to find it in winter and how to avoid confusing it with dangerous lookalikes.

Velvet shank (Flammulina velutipes): tiers of orange caps on a dark, moss-covered trunk
Photo: marsupium photography · CC BY-SA 2.0 · source

When there's snow in the forest and every other mushroom is long gone, bright orange-brown caps appear on tree trunks. This is the velvet shank, or Flammulina, a remarkable mushroom that shrugs off frost and keeps growing when others die. Here's how to recognise it, where to find it and why you need to be careful with it.

What the velvet shank looks like

The velvet shank's features are simple and easy to spot:

  • Cap bright orange-brown, honey-coloured or orange, smooth and slightly slimy, 2 to 10 cm across.
  • Stem thin, springy, velvety, dark brown toward the base, as if dressed in brown “velour.”
  • Gills pale, cream, fairly widely spaced.
  • There is no ring on the stem, which is an important detail.

It grows in tight clusters right on the bark.

Where and when to look for the velvet shank

The velvet shank fruits from late autumn to early spring, most actively during thaws. It copes with real frost: a frozen mushroom thaws out and carries on growing.

Look for it not on the ground but on the trunks and stumps of broadleaf trees: willow, poplar, ash, elm. For other mushrooms that grow on wood, see edible mushrooms that grow on trees, and for the winter season in general, winter mushrooms of Europe.

Dangerous lookalikes

The main caution: a thin-stemmed velvet shank on a stump looks a lot like the deadly funeral bell and other small brown mushrooms. The key difference is that the velvet shank has no ring on the stem, and its stem is dark and velvety. If there's a membranous ring on the stem, do not take the mushroom. The funeral bell’s ring is thin, though, and can disappear with age, so check the spore print too: white in the velvet shank, rusty brown in the funeral bell.

Because of this resemblance, the velvet shank is best left to experienced foragers. The general rules are in our article false honey fungus: how to tell it from the real thing.

Is the velvet shank edible?

Yes, the velvet shank is edible and tasty, but it must be boiled. It must not be eaten raw: cook it for at least 15 minutes before eating. There's more on this in which mushrooms you can eat raw.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

How do you recognise the velvet shank (Flammulina)?

Look for a bright orange-brown, honey-coloured, slimy cap, a thin springy stem in dark velvet and pale gills. One important detail: there's no ring on the stem. It grows in clusters on trunks.

When does the velvet shank grow?

The velvet shank fruits from late autumn to early spring, most actively during thaws. It withstands frost: a frozen mushroom thaws out and keeps growing.

Where should you look for the velvet shank?

Not on the ground but on the trunks and stumps of broadleaf trees: willow, poplar, ash, elm. It grows in tight clusters right on the bark.

Does the velvet shank have poisonous lookalikes?

Yes, it resembles the deadly funeral bell (Galerina) and other small brown mushrooms. The main difference: the velvet shank has no ring on the stem and a white spore print. Do not take a mushroom with a ring, and since the funeral bell’s ring can disappear with age, always check the spore print as well: in the funeral bell it's rusty brown.

Is the velvet shank edible?

Yes, the velvet shank is edible and tasty, but it must be boiled. It must not be eaten raw: cook it for at least 15 minutes before eating.

Why isn't the velvet shank afraid of frost?

It's adapted to fruiting in the cold: its growth slows down but doesn't stop. The wood protects the mycelium, so during thaws the velvet shank comes back to life even from under the snow.

How does the velvet shank differ from honey fungus?

Honey fungus has a ring on the stem and grows in autumn. The velvet shank has no ring, a dark velvety stem and an orange-brown slimy cap, and it fruits in winter. They're different species.

Related articles