Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Why mushrooms taste bitter and how to get rid of it

By Valeriia·Updated ·3 min read

Mushrooms can taste bitter for different reasons, from a poisonous lookalike to the wrong cooking. Here's why it happens, and when bitterness is a danger signal.

Bitter bolete (Tylopilus felleus): a young brown cap on a yellowish, netted stem in moss
Photo: creaturefeature97 · CC0 · source

You picked a lovely basketful, cooked it, and the dish is so bitter it's inedible. Mushroom bitterness has several causes, and some of them matter for safety. Here's why mushrooms taste bitter, how to get rid of the bitterness, and when a bitter taste means you should leave the mushroom in the forest.

1. A bitter bolete slipped into your basket

The most common culprit behind a ruined dish is the bitter bolete (Tylopilus felleus), a porcini lookalike. From the outside it looks almost like a porcino, but it's very bitter, and a single one can ruin the whole pot.

The bitter bolete isn't deadly, but its unbearable bitterness, which only gets stronger with cooking, makes it inedible. We explain in detail how to tell it from porcini in our article June lookalikes: the cornflower bolete and the bitter bolete.

2. Some mushrooms are bitter “by nature”

Some mushrooms eaten in Northern and Eastern Europe are naturally bitter or acrid, above all milk caps (Lactarius) with their peppery milk. Not everyone agrees they're food: the woolly milk cap is eaten in Finland and Russia, but we, like many authorities, list it as poisonous: it can cause very unpleasant stomach upsets, so don't eat it. Where milk caps considered edible are eaten, they're:

  • soaked in cold water for several days, changing the water;
  • or boiled, with the cooking water poured off.

That's why these mushrooms are traditionally salted rather than fried. Without soaking they really are bitter.

3. The mushroom is overmature or improperly cooked

Sometimes even a familiar mushroom tastes bitter:

  • overmature, old mushrooms often develop an unpleasant aftertaste;
  • chanterelles can turn bitter if they're frozen raw;
  • mushrooms picked near roads or in polluted places can also taste off (more on this in our article mushrooms near roads and cities).

When shop-bought mushrooms taste bitter

If a dish of button mushrooms or shiitake comes out bitter, check how old they were first: old mushrooms often develop an unpleasant aftertaste. We found no solid source that explains every bitter shop-bought mushroom, so we won't guess. Throw away any that are slimy or smell sour, and if you feel unwell after eating them, talk to a doctor.

4. When bitterness is a danger signal

Most important of all: taste tells you nothing about safety. Some poisonous mushrooms are acrid, but people who survived eating deadly amanitas said they tasted good. That's why there's a simple safety rule: never taste unfamiliar mushrooms, not even raw, to “check whether they're bitter.”

Bitterness on its own doesn't prove a mushroom is toxic, and a mild taste doesn't prove it's safe. Read more about false “tests” in our article myths about identifying poisonous mushrooms.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Why do mushrooms taste bitter?

There are several reasons: a bitter bolete (a porcini lookalike) got into your basket, the mushroom is naturally bitter (milk caps, woolly milk caps), or it's overmature or badly cooked. Taste doesn't tell you whether a mushroom is safe, so don't eat a wild mushroom you can't identify.

How do you remove bitterness from mushrooms?

Where naturally bitter milk caps are eaten, they're soaked in cold water for several days, changing the water, or boiled with the cooking water poured off. But you can't “fix” the bitter bolete this way: its bitterness only gets stronger.

Why does my porcini dish taste bitter?

Most likely a bitter bolete (Tylopilus felleus) slipped in among your porcini. From the outside it looks like porcini but is very bitter, and a single one ruins the whole pot.

Can you taste a mushroom to check for bitterness?

Never taste unfamiliar mushrooms, not even raw. Taste proves nothing: people who survived deadly amanitas said they tasted good. Identify a mushroom by its features, not with your tongue.

Why do chanterelles taste bitter?

Chanterelles can turn bitter if they're frozen raw. Heat them in a pan before freezing.

Are bitter mushrooms poisonous?

Not always, and a mild taste doesn't mean it's safe either. The bitter bolete is inedible but not deadly (some sources report stomach upsets from it), some poisonous mushrooms are acrid, and deadly amanitas reportedly taste good. Identify a mushroom by its features, not its taste.

Will the bitterness go away after boiling?

Partly, in naturally bitter mushrooms, if you boil them and pour off the water. But the bitter bolete's bitterness only gets stronger with cooking, so a dish it has ruined can't be saved.

Related articles