Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Can you pick mushrooms after a frost?

By Valeriia·Updated ·3 min read

The first frosts don’t always end the season. Frost ruins some mushrooms, while others are just getting started. So can you pick mushrooms after a frost, and which ones aren’t afraid of the cold?

Velvet shank (Flammulina velutipes): collage of orange clusters on a tree trunk
Photo: Henk Monster · CC BY 3.0 · source

Frost can ruin the mushroom you see, but the fungus itself lives on in the soil or wood: many species fruit in the same spot year after year. As for picking, some mushrooms really do spoil after a frost, while others come into their own exactly then.

Let's see what frost does to mushrooms and which ones are still worth looking for.

What frost does to mushrooms

Even a light overnight frost can damage a mushroom in ways you can't always see or smell. But a hard frost destroys the structure of the flesh: the mushroom freezes through, and once it thaws it goes watery and mushy and spoils quickly.

So the rule is simple:

  • Don't pick a mushroom that froze on the stump, thawed and went mushy: it's spoiled.
  • Leave ordinary forest mushrooms that froze in the forest, even if they still look firm: frost damage can't always be seen or smelled. Only frost-hardy winter mushrooms such as velvet shank and oyster mushrooms are the exception, and only if you're certain of the species.

Which mushrooms are ruined by frost

Delicate gilled and pored mushrooms (brittlegills, late boletes, old honey fungus) are no good after a hard frost and a thaw. We cover when mushroom season ends in a separate article.

Which mushrooms aren't afraid of the cold

Some species are perfectly at home in the frost:

  • Velvet shank (Flammulina). It fruits in late autumn and during winter thaws; read more about this winter mushroom in a separate article.
  • Oyster mushroom. It grows on wood into early winter, and in southern Europe into the heart of winter; see our separate article on when oyster mushrooms appear.
  • Herald of winter (Hygrophorus hypothejus). It often fruits after the first frosts under pines. The yellow knight also comes late, but leave it alone: First Nature says it should not be collected, because muscle damage has been linked to eating it.

We also cover how cool-weather and first-frost mushrooms behave.

Does freezing make a poisonous mushroom safe?

No. Tox Info Suisse, the Swiss poisons centre, says amatoxins, the deadly toxins of the death cap, can't be neutralised by boiling, frying, drying, pickling or deep-freezing. So frost changes nothing about whether a mushroom is poisonous.

Late in the year the risk to know is the velvet shank's deadly lookalike, the funeral bell (Galerina marginata), which also grows on wood. The funeral bell often has a ring or a trace of one on the stem, but it can be missing, so a missing ring proves nothing. Its spore print is rusty brown, the velvet shank's is white. If someone may have eaten a poisonous mushroom, call 112 (999 in the UK).

The golden rule

  • Look at the mushroom's condition, not the calendar. Ordinary mushrooms that froze stay in the forest. Frost-hardy winter species such as velvet shank and oyster mushrooms can be taken if they're firm and fresh and you're sure of the species.
  • Watch for thaws. When it warms up after a frost, it's worth another look on wood.
  • Cook right away: mushrooms nipped by the cold don't keep as well.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Can you pick mushrooms after a frost?

Only frost-hardy winter mushrooms such as velvet shank and oyster mushrooms, and only if they're firm, fresh and you're certain of the species. Leave other mushrooms that froze in the forest: frost damage can't always be seen or smelled. If a mushroom has gone mushy after freezing and thawing, don't pick it: it's spoiled.

Which mushrooms are ruined by frost?

Delicate brittlegills, late boletes and old honey fungus turn watery and unusable after a hard frost and a thaw.

Which mushrooms aren't afraid of frost?

Velvet shank (Flammulina), which fruits through winter, oyster mushrooms, and the herald of winter, which often fruits after the first frosts.

Does frost kill mushrooms?

It can ruin the mushroom you see: a hard frost destroys the flesh, and once it thaws it turns watery and spoils quickly. The fungus itself lives on in soil or wood, so many species come back in the same place.

Is a frost-nipped mushroom edible?

Only if it's a frost-hardy winter species such as velvet shank or oyster mushroom, still firm and fresh, and you're certain of the species. Ordinary mushrooms that froze are best left in the forest, as frost damage can't always be seen or smelled. A thawed, mushy mushroom is no good any more. Freezing never makes a poisonous mushroom safe.

When does the season finally end?

Once hard frosts arrive and the ground freezes, fresh forest mushrooms disappear, but velvet shank goes on through winter.

Why aren't winter mushrooms afraid of the cold?

They're adapted to fruiting in cool weather, so they come into their own just as other mushrooms are finishing.

Is it worth going to the forest after the first frosts?

Yes, if you're after cold-hardy species on wood: velvet shank and oyster mushrooms. For ordinary forest mushrooms, it's too late once a hard frost has hit.

Related articles